Varchertine's Werewolf Game Thread

[OngBonga]

Here's why baudib is a wolf.

If he's a villager, he would be thinking "maybe ong is right, maybe boog is clear". He's flat out insisting I'm wrong. There's no flexibility, because he needs boog/monstr as mislynch. Last time baudib was a wolf, I owned his ass on d1 and sent him packing. After the game he buttered me up so bad, insisting I'm a great player etc. So if he think I'm so god damn fucking awesome, why isn't he thinking I might actually be right to clear boog? Why does he insist that the wolves would sit back and do nothing while a wolf is about to be lynched, slightly ahead of a gabe/rong v/v pair?

baudib needs this mislynch. That's why he's not budging.

[baudib]

Here's why baudib is a wolf.

If he's a villager, he would be thinking "maybe ong is right, maybe boog is clear". He's flat out insisting I'm wrong. There's no flexibility, because he needs boog/monstr as mislynch. Last time baudib was a wolf, I owned his ass on d1 and sent him packing. After the game he buttered me up so bad, insisting I'm a great player etc. So if he think I'm so god damn fucking awesome, why isn't he thinking I might actually be right to clear boog? Why does he insist that the wolves would sit back and do nothing while a wolf is about to be lynched, slightly ahead of a gabe/rong v/v pair?

baudib needs this mislynch. That's why he's not budging.

Nope, I'm a villager and I'm telling you that if you're a villager, your reason for clearing Boog is utter hogwash.

We need to look no further than last game to see wolves parked on a wolf (you, D1) despite viable villager wagons to disprove your theory.

[OngBonga]

Nope, I'm a villager and I'm telling you that if you're a villager, your reason for clearing Boog is utter hogwash.

We need to look no further than last game to see wolves parked on a wolf (you, D1) despite viable villager wagons to disprove your theory.

Yes but I did something crazy, there was a reason the wolves were on me. What the fuck are they doing sitting around doing shit all while a wolf gets lynched? Yes it happens sometimes, but I'm playing probabilities here. Out of the three other wolves, you'd expect at least one of them to make an effort to shift the votes away.

I notice that you continue to suggest there's a good chance of a wolf between me and rascal. But you're not arguing that I was the wolf who tried to save boog. You're just throwing some shit back at me in the hope it looks like villager on villager violence. If you were actually a villager trying to figure shit out, I'd be your top fucking wolf suspect with boog, because you know I'm crazy enough to balls out save his ass, then give him villager cred by insisting that the wolves were going to let him die. That's the kind of cheeky shit I'd try and pull. But you're not thinking about that. Why? Because that's what a villager would be thinking.

You're a lock wolf imo.

[baudib]

Yes but I did something crazy, there was a reason the wolves were on me. What the fuck are they doing sitting around doing shit all while a wolf gets lynched? Yes it happens sometimes, but I'm playing probabilities here. Out of the three other wolves, you'd expect at least one of them to make an effort to shift the votes away.

I notice that you continue to suggest there's a good chance of a wolf between me and rascal. But you're not arguing that I was the wolf who tried to save boog. You're just throwing some shit back at me in the hope it looks like villager on villager violence. If you were actually a villager trying to figure shit out, I'd be your top fucking wolf suspect with boog, because you know I'm crazy enough to balls out save his ass, then give him villager cred by insisting that the wolves were going to let him die. That's the kind of cheeky shit I'd try and pull. But you're not thinking about that. Why? Because that's what a villager would be thinking.

You're a lock wolf imo.

I've got 8 people including my partner telling me you're never a wolf here. It's something I'm weighing very highly and I thought you were a villager too. The possibility that you're a villager is high enough that you're not the priority when there are 3 wolfier candidates.

[MadMojoMonkey]

Nope, I'm a villager and I'm telling you that if you're a villager, your reason for clearing Boog is utter hogwash.

We need to look no further than last game to see wolves parked on a wolf (you, D1) despite viable villager wagons to disprove your theory.

It can easily be argued that gabe simply had to park on Ong because gabe would have been lock-wolf if he didn't jump on that.

Then daven and myself would not let go of the fact that ong-wolf would def. do this, and there was nothing in the rules that said a dayvig was not a wolf role.

So the wolves parking on Ong in that scenario were put in a tough spot, forced to respond to D1 (arguably) spew.

[baudib]

Ong not wanting to lynch either Boog or the late Gabe voters is really really troubling.

[OngBonga]

Ong not wanting to lynch either Boog or the late Gabe voters is really really troubling.

Wut? Look at my recent reads list. wuf/hoopy and daven/bigred are in my "to lynch" pile.

[baudib]

Wut? Look at my recent reads list. wuf/hoopy and daven/bigred are in my "to lynch" pile.

Then your logic is inconsistent. Follow it backwards; if Wuf is a wolf, why does he switch to Gabe and not consider Boog at all?

The Gabe lynch points to Boog being a wolf, Wuf's vote points to him and Boog being wolves together. This is easily the most likely/logical W-W pairing in the game.

[OngBonga]

Then your logic is inconsistent. Follow it backwards; if Wuf is a wolf, why does he switch to Gabe and not consider Boog at all?

The Gabe lynch points to Boog being a wolf, Wuf's vote points to him and Boog being wolves together. This is easily the most likely/logical W-W pairing in the game.

If wuf is a wolf, he jumped on board because gabe/rong mislynch is a shit load better than boog/monstr, especially since the latter can be left for next day's mislynch. The wolves were doing nothing because both wagons were v/v, so why draw attention, just stay quiet. Once I rallied for gabe votes, daven and wuf jump on board. Maybe a wolf thinks I take the fall for the v/v flip, and lunges for the fistpump mislynch.

What the gabe wagon does not do is implicate boog, like you are suggesting. Not unless you think I'm a wolf.

[baudib]

If wuf is a wolf, he jumped on board because gabe/rong mislynch is a shit load better than boog/monstr, especially since the latter can be left for next day's mislynch. The wolves were doing nothing because both wagons were v/v, so why draw attention, just stay quiet. Once I rallied for gabe votes, daven and wuf jump on board. Maybe a wolf thinks I take the fall for the v/v flip, and lunges for the fistpump mislynch.

What the gabe wagon does not do is implicate boog, like you are suggesting. Not unless you think I'm a wolf.

no, a thousand times no. If you're a villager it makes it all the more likely that wolves followed you onto Gabe. For one thing you have no idea how Wuf would play this as a wolf, you said yourself that the idea of lynching Gabe on D1 was amazing. Wolves could be scared of the blowback of lynching vill Gabe.

And wolves don't give a shit about one mislynch over another. You're suggesting that Boog isn't a wolf because wolves would have made a play earlier (they actually did, btw) and that the wolves would expose themselves over V-V wagons but not V-W wagons?

you can't be serious.

[daven]

Ong not wanting to lynch either Boog or the late Gabe voters is really really troubling.

instead he wants to lynch an early gabe voter. you do remember that you were frothing for us to lynch gabe right?

Are all of you incapable of reading? I'm not blaming anyone.

If Gabe flips V then have at me, I'm owning it.

[baudib]

instead he wants to lynch an early gabe voter. you do remember that you were frothing for us to lynch gabe right?

i mean you keep quoting this as if it matters. I said it, everyone knows I said it and I stand by it. I actually made a case for why Gabe seemed shady, you and Ong piled on for what reasons?

[daven]

i mean you keep quoting this as if it matters. I said it, everyone knows I said it and I stand by it. I actually made a case for why Gabe seemed shady, you and Ong piled on for what reasons?

my reason (you'd have to read old posts though, and it seems you hate that) was that i thought both gabe and boog likely villagers but rong more likely wolf than monstr so i voted the lynch that i thought most likely to tag a wolf.

[baudib]

my reason (you'd have to read old posts though, and it seems you hate that) was that i thought both gabe and boog likely villagers but rong more likely wolf than monstr so i voted the lynch that i thought most likely to tag a wolf.

And given the results of Day 1 and your blessed Gabe reread, what do you think of Boog now?

[daven]

And given the results of Day 1 and your blessed Gabe reread, what do you think of Boog now?

hang on, when you go back do you simply read single players and ignore the context in which their posts are made? that would explain a lot.
i still think that boog is more likely villager than wolf but his lack of content is disturbing and gabe thought he was wolf. I do think there's a reasonable chance monstr is wolf though...