Vikings, Gods and Giants Game thread

[wufwugy]

rong - luco
jkds - luco
luco - rong
hoopy - rong
daven - rong
wuf - rong

luco - 2
rong - 4

no vote - rascal, gabe

[gabe]

every post makes me switch back n forth between luco n rong

the hard evidence makes me want to vote for rong. these are just the general wolfy traits that wuf alluded to. "ill post alot of stuff later guys!" is such a typical wolfy cop out. if jkds believes the luco-wolf theory is possible then rong could somehow be a wolf too. jkds doesnt convince me rong is safe.

jkds does a pretty good job of making luco look bad. luco also is doing that thing i called out gator for doing last game. the thing is when a wolf casts his own thoughts and theories onto someone else. luco wants to hang me because the only villagery thing ive done is vote for ong. well shit the only villagery thing hes done is vote for ong! and hes wrong about me

i needed to get these thoughts out of the way before i reread again

[Luco]

every post makes me switch back n forth between luco n rong

the hard evidence makes me want to vote for rong. these are just the general wolfy traits that wuf alluded to. "ill post alot of stuff later guys!" is such a typical wolfy cop out. if jkds believes the luco-wolf theory is possible then rong could somehow be a wolf too. jkds doesnt convince me rong is safe.

jkds does a pretty good job of making luco look bad. luco also is doing that thing i called out gator for doing last game. the thing is when a wolf casts his own thoughts and theories onto someone else. luco wants to hang me because the only villagery thing ive done is vote for ong. well shit the only villagery thing hes done is vote for ong! and hes wrong about me

i needed to get these thoughts out of the way before i reread again

You read me better than most gabe so the fact that you don't see my D3 effort as villagery is straight up alarming

And I don't want to hang you, I want to figure you out.

[gabe]

what do you guys think of the present vote counts? the wagon sizes wouldnt make you think rong is the wolf

rong - luco
jkds - luco
luco - rong
hoopy - rong
daven - rong
wuf - rong

luco - 2
rong - 4

no vote - rascal, gabe

[wufwugy]

what do you guys think of the present vote counts? the wagon sizes wouldnt make you think rong is the wolf

meh only two wolves left (one sk). their voting power isnt amazing. if rong is a wolf, it's reasonable that the other wolf is already on him (*cough* hoopy). he knows he's doomed

rong isnt that far ahead either.

[Luco]

what do you guys think of the present vote counts? the wagon sizes wouldnt make you think rong is the wolf

Say for arguments sake that rong is a wolf. He has ONE buddy to defend. What would you expect to see here?

[gabe]

Now you're just arguing semantics.

im not "just" doing that im also exploring what was in your head to make you post that. i dont think most people would have the same thought as you. but now that i think about it, it probably increases the chance you are loki more than it increases the chance you are a wolf

Say for arguments sake that rong is a wolf. He has ONE buddy to defend. What would you expect to see here?

if rong is a wolf then jkds isnt a wolf. it would be too bad for both of them to be on you here, with no one else on the wagon. thats the only player based read i have on the current votes

playing "lets pretend x is a wolf" makes people consider X wolfy in a biased way. your motives are questionable, especially now that im thinking rong receiving 50% of votes makes him probably village

[Luco]

im not "just" doing that im also exploring what was in your head to make you post that. i dont think most people would have the same thought as you. but now that i think about it, it probably increases the chance you are loki more than it increases the chance you are a wolf

if rong is a wolf then jkds isnt a wolf. it would be too bad for both of them to be on you here, with no one else on the wagon. thats the only player based read i have on the current votes

playing "lets pretend x is a wolf" makes people consider X wolfy in a biased way. your motives are questionable, especially now that im thinking rong receiving 50% of votes makes him probably village

That last sentence is LOL

You really, genuinely think that I was getting subliminal there?

[gabe]

That last sentence is LOL

You really, genuinely think that I was getting subliminal there?

anyone can subliminally be subliminal

im more saying its a consequence of your thoughts, not that you directly decided on that plan

[Luco]

anyone can subliminally be subliminal

im more saying its a consequence of your thoughts, not that you directly decided on that plan

Despite the fact that I said 'for arguments sake', as in 'for the purposes of this discussion'?

[Luco]

rong - luco
jkds - luco
luco - rong
hoopy - rong
daven - rong
wuf - rong

luco - 2
rong - 4

no vote - rascal, gabe

Ok lemme think this through. Gabe you gave a vague one line response when I asked you to think about this, I was hoping for a bit more substance.

I have already stated that rong / jkds are unlikely wolves.

Assuming that rong is a wolf (for the purposes of thinking this through, GFY gabe) - his buddy would likely have been a bit slow getting on his wagon. Wuf was first, then daven, hoopy, luco, rascal.

So it would be hoopy, rascal, or gabe.

If rong said 'I'm dead go for cover' then it's hoopy or rascal, if not it's gabe. None are likely though, gabe has stuck his neck out defending rong D2 and D3 and hoopy said something D2 iirc that made him and rong unlikely wolves (something like 'I might hop on, we'll see'). Rascal has been all over rong. Gabe maybe slightly more likely as he's been kinda wishy-washy on rong now that I think about it, but still it doesn't feel right to me

So thinking it through I'm inclined to agree with you gabe that the VC implies rong is a villager.

[gabe]

when I asked you to think about this, I was hoping for a bit more substance.

i did think about it, but all i could come up with was speculation. and i dont like going down that road unless im trying to convince players of something. so i just typed some other stuff it made me think about

[Luco]

i did think about it, but all i could come up with was speculation. and i dont like going down that road unless im trying to convince players of something. so i just typed some other stuff it made me think about

I would have been happy with speculation