Well it's not that simple and you know it.

Firstly it's day 1 and reads are likely to change, possibly repeatedly from here in.

Secondly, you're stating that day 1 reads should take precedent over managing potential late game problems. That's fine if it's your opinion but you need to weigh up the strength of your conviction vs the level of trouble that could later be caused.

In this instance my suspicions are weak and the potential trouble is big. So yeah, I wanna lynch mmm in spite of the majority of his behavior falling into the villagery side of things.