WW JK9 game thread

[Poopadoop]

So looking at Benny's first day, he basically went back and forth between seriously accusing Jack and seriously accusing Luco, threw in a joke accusation at baudib in-between, before finally going with the crowd and lynching Oskar.

If I'm either of Jack or Luco and a wolf I'm obviously going to be nervous about this (unless I'm a sociopath), but I'm also going to be aware that killing Benny will make me look suspicious, since i was one of his main targets. So I don't think it's either of them that's a wolf.

If I'm spaceman or mnstrman, Benny was pretty trusting of both and there's no reason to kill him when he's off on the wrong track and defending us besides. So neither of them is a wolf imo.

If I'm Ong or baud, killing Benny gets rid of a pretty active villager and doesn't make either of us look suspicious.

So it's Ong and baud as my two top votes. I'll keep my vote to baud first cause it's fun watching Ong squirm. Also because neither of them will kill me on night two 'cause that's pretty much a confession.

[jackvance]

Poop with the analysis.

It's pretty decent analysis actually but I think the way you are trying to guess the motives of the wolves is understandable but from my experience not accurate. Noms are usually either special hunting or killing off the most villagery looking person, especially early and mid game. I remember a game where Gator was a wolf and throughout the whole game I was trying to figure out the logic of why this and that person was getting eaten, linking it to people and their motives. But when the game ended I checked out the den and all Gator and team did was try to kill whoever they thought was most likely to be the seer every night. Notice that Benny was a special, so either the wolves sniffed that out or more likely, he had positioned himself as a solid villager.

So it's Ong and baud as my two top votes. I'll keep my vote to baud first cause it's fun watching Ong squirm. Also because neither of them will kill me on night two 'cause that's pretty much a confession.

That's an example of the kind of reasoning I don't agree with because it's too easy for the wolves to fake. Especially when you say it out loud.