*** Official Politics Shitposting Thread ***

[BananaStand]

The argument K made here had nothing to do with money. The argument was she wasn't old enough to make up her own mind.

Ok, I read something else, but whatever. So she wasn't old enough. That's not his opinion. That's not something judges get to decide.

The laws in the state say how old you have to be, and she wasn't old enough. That's a judges job.....follow the law. If you don't like a law, a judge is not the person to talk to about it. That's something you libtards don't seem to understand. You're all anti-fascist, but you also think that one guy in a robe should be able to just give you your way all the time.

[Poopadoop]

Ok, I read something else, but whatever.

Lol "I read some bullshit lies and believed them, but so what? I'll do it again and come on here and scream at anyone who says otherwise."

The laws in the state say how old you have to be, and she wasn't old enough. That's a judges job.....follow the law. If you don't like a law, a judge is not the person to talk to about it. That's something you libtards don't seem to understand. You're all anti-fascist, but you also think that one guy in a robe should be able to just give you your way all the time.

That might be a good argument if the opinion was unanimous. It wasn't. Clearly there was enough ambiguity in the law to make different interpretations possible. That's where a person's judgment and humanity comes in. And when you think a 17 year old girl can't decide for herself she wants an abortion, and the gov't won't provide her with a proxy to help in that decision, it's tough shit for her, then you're a cunt plain and simple.

[BananaStand]

Lol "I read some bullshit lies and believed them, but so what? I'll do it again and come on here and scream at anyone who says otherwise."

No, I read actual excerpts from one of BK's opinions. It must have been a different case.

That might be a good argument if the opinion was unanimous.

LOL, you might be right if there was no such thing as an activist judge.

Clearly there was enough ambiguity in the law to make different interpretations possible. That's where a person's judgment and humanity comes in.

NO!!!!!!! That's where CORRUPTION comes in.

Good judges rarely see ambiguity in the law. The law says what it says. If you want the law to say something else, pass a law that say something else.

And when you think a 17 year old girl can't decide for herself she wants an abortion

I doesn't matter what anyone "thinks". What matters is the law. You could make the same argument that says a 17 year old girl can decide for herself to have sex with her math teacher. SHE CAN'T

it's tough shit for her

There are plenty of cheap abortion clinics in Mexico. She's welcome to go there any time she wants.

then you're a cunt plain and simple.

Then I'm a cunt.

[Poopadoop]

No, I read actual excerpts from one of BK's opinions. It must have been a different case.

Fine, don't worry about it.

LOL, you might be right if there was no such thing as an activist judge.


NO!!!!!!! That's where CORRUPTION comes in.

Good judges rarely see ambiguity in the law. The law says what it says. If you want the law to say something else, pass a law that say something else.

Actually, yes. Any view of the Law as purely black-and-white is simply naive. Words themselves are ambiguous. Judges spend lots of their time interpreting the law, and by definition that process is subjective. If it wasn't subjective, you would always have unanimous SC decisions, for example.

I doesn't matter what anyone "thinks". What matters is the law. You could make the same argument that says a 17 year old girl can decide for herself to have sex with her math teacher. SHE CAN'T

No you couldn't actually make such an argument, because the law is clear and unambiguous on that. It's also clear that you're expected to stop at a stop sign. The law was instead ambiguous on this case, which is why there were dissenting opinions.

There are plenty of cheap abortion clinics in Mexico. She's welcome to go there any time she wants.

Funny that option was never offered to her while she was in custody.

Then I'm a cunt.

I think that is at least something that would be unanimously agreed on.