Russians vs. Americans: A Werewolf Game for October 2015

[Beck Novo]

Honestly, I think the wolves made a shit play by poisoning SIU/Kami.

My thought is that if Kami is in fact a villager, that the wolves would not poison her. Why? Because she's a currently a liability to us so risking her death only helps us in the long run. Which would mean that I think our own poisoner poisoned Kami. Leaving SIU to be poisoned by the wolves, making him lock village. (I'm discrediting the possibility that the wolves poisoned one of their own.)

But why poison SIU, the counter-wagon? The longer he's alive and within the PoE, the more difficult time we'll all have.

I honestly cannot see a scenario where Kami and SIU are not v/v.

[lilrascal]

Honestly, I think the wolves made a shit play by poisoning SIU/Kami.

My thought is that if Kami is in fact a villager, that the wolves would not poison her. Why? Because she's a currently a liability to us so risking her death only helps us in the long run. Which would mean that I think our own poisoner poisoned Kami. Leaving SIU to be poisoned by the wolves, making him lock village. (I'm discrediting the possibility that the wolves poisoned one of their own.)

But why poison SIU, the counter-wagon? The longer he's alive and within the PoE, the more difficult time we'll all have.

I honestly cannot see a scenario where Kami and SIU are not v/v.

I tend to agree with you, but I can also see the situation of one of them being a wolf and poisoning the other just for the FPS.

[Beck Novo]

I tend to agree with you, but I can also see the situation of one of them being a wolf and poisoning the other just for the FPS.

Two questions for you. How often does an FPS happen here on FTR?

And which option do you think is the most likely? V/V, V/W, or W/W?

[lilrascal]

Two questions for you. How often does an FPS happen here on FTR?

It's happened in a couple games that I've played here, but I've only been playing here since the beginning of this year. But, most of the players in this game are non-FTR regulars, so I don't know how much it would come into play here.

And which option do you think is the most likely? V/V, V/W, or W/W?

I'd say v/v is most likely, followed closely by v/w. I don't think it's w/w.