Russians vs. Americans: A Werewolf Game for October 2015

[BankItDrew]

Who is rushing to D2? This game has still barely even started, there are still several players who have yet to post. And many more that have posted but haven't posted anything meaningful.

I ask because this feels like you're feigning concern for the village's well-being. Especially when your vote was for someone who isn't the most likely to be a wolf based on what's happened so far.

+1 to this

I've been guilty of rushing to D2 in the past as both a villager and a wolf, because I thought D1 was sorta pointless. I've changed my stance on that though.

I mainly want to give the inactives ample opportunity to contribute.

[Beck Novo]

I mainly want to give the inactives ample opportunity to contribute.

But you're okay with lynching BigRed?

[BankItDrew]

But you're okay with lynching BigRed?

I rescinded my vote on bigred for two reasons:
1) Go with my guy on ong
2) Give inactives a chance to post

That being said, I think there's a <5% chance bigred contributes anything of significance. Which is why I'd be content with lynching him, even if he's a villager.

[Beck Novo]

I rescinded my vote on bigred for two reasons:
1) Go with my guy on ong
2) Give inactives a chance to post

That being said, I think there's a <5% chance bigred contributes anything of significance. Which is why I'd be content with lynching him, even if he's a villager.

So is his general lack of contribution alignment indicative in any way? I'm getting the feeling that it's not, but still. I hate the idea of lynching someone just 'cause. I want to lynch wolves. But I also want to lynch the wolf that's going to provide us the most information once s/he flips.

[BankItDrew]

So is his general lack of contribution alignment indicative in any way? I'm getting the feeling that it's not, but still. I hate the idea of lynching someone just 'cause. I want to lynch wolves. But I also want to lynch the wolf that's going to provide us the most information once s/he flips.

Bigred doesn't survive late into games often, when he does though, he still doesn't do much at all. One game he made it to a 2v1 spot as a villager and ended up picking the correct player to lynch but... 50/50 right?

His early afk stuff is never role indicative of anything other than being typical bigred.

[NightGizmo]

Bigred doesn't survive late into games often, when he does though, he still doesn't do much at all. One game he made it to a 2v1 spot as a villager and ended up picking the correct player to lynch but... 50/50 right?

His early afk stuff is never role indicative of anything other than being typical bigred.

Ha, yes, I was the lone remaining wolf in that game, and bigred actually figured me out on the last day. I got lucky that the third person went AFK and we won on a dice roll. But even in that game, he was barely around until pretty late in the game.

No reads to be found in his absence.

[Luco]

I rescinded my vote on bigred for two reasons:
1) Go with my guy on ong
2) Give inactives a chance to post

That being said, I think there's a <5% chance bigred contributes anything of significance. Which is why I'd be content with lynching him, even if he's a villager.

I thought you rescinded bigred because of the potential substitute?

[BankItDrew]

I thought you rescinded bigred because of the potential substitute?

3) ...