Varchertine's Werewolf Game Thread

[Hoopy]

My read on wuf is neutral right now. He pushed really hard for revealing pairs and then went quiet when nothing happened which was worrying as that's unusual for him. The mega post he made is more in keeping with traditional wuf style + the after thoughts look genuine.

The private chat is not helping his case for being a villager, though neither is it wolfy.

[wufwugy]

My read on wuf is neutral right now. He pushed really hard for revealing pairs and then went quiet when nothing happened which was worrying as that's unusual for him. The mega post he made is more in keeping with traditional wuf style + the after thoughts look genuine.

The private chat is not helping his case for being a villager, though neither is it wolfy.

i think using private chat is wrong. that's why ive said mostly nothing. if i have something important to say, it will be said in the game thread. we have always believed that it's important for everything to see the light of day in the game thread. the private chat format goes against this.

what has private chat done for us? ong and rascal think each other is a wolf. we have no idea why because we cant see the private chat. we have no way of evaluating the veracity of their claims. but as long as they say it's based in private chat, we basically have to take their word for it. i dont want to do that, but what choice is there

then we have rilla and baud, who also cleared each other based on private chat. more shit we cant evaluate

then we have mmm and bid, where mmm said his clearing of bid was all private chat.

not only would it be the easiest thing in the world for wolves to do this, but private chat use necessarily detracts of game thread use. at the rate we're going, the late game is going to be just a bunch of "take my word for it" instead of "here's the actual case for the player being villager or wolf based on stuff that happened in thread that everybody can see"

[OngBonga]

i think using private chat is wrong. that's why ive said mostly nothing.

Who here thinks this is villager wuf speaking?