Ultimate Werewolf

[gabe]

i think daven has done a fair job defending himself. i think MMM has been kinda scattered and i dont have a good read but he would be a good lynch

ITT monstrman is being honest and wants to tell us all how honest he is

Using words like honest, genuine, legitimate is a wolf tell but here it could just be a style thing as it's so frequent.

i think its a real wolf tell. you cant give him a pass on it because we havent played with him. hes still a human that behaves/posts like one. hes a really solid lynch target now. the points early in day 1 against him i still think are pretty valid

[Luco]

i think daven has done a fair job defending himself. i think MMM has been kinda scattered and i dont have a good read but he would be a good lynch

You've been back and forth on mojo. Why do you say he would be a good lynch?

i think its a real wolf tell. you cant give him a pass on it because we havent played with him. hes still a human that behaves/posts like one. hes a really solid lynch target now. the points early in day 1 against him i still think are pretty valid

You caught gator with exactly this a few games back (during his forever wolf run). What do you think of the evidence baud has produced that shows this is normal and in-character for a monstr villager? Surely that reduces the tell to null?

[monstrman]

i think daven has done a fair job defending himself. i think MMM has been kinda scattered and i dont have a good read but he would be a good lynch


i think its a real wolf tell. you cant give him a pass on it because we havent played with him. hes still a human that behaves/posts like one. hes a really solid lynch target now. the points early in day 1 against him i still think are pretty valid

"I think the tell that was just proven to be something he says in both alignments is still a wolf tell" how do you even believe what you are saying?

Yes I'm still a human and still act and behave like one, hence when I am in a game I act according to the same mannerisms regardless of my aligment.

"Monstrman uses those words in both alignments, but is still a viable lynch target because that's a wolf tell" isn't a line of thought that even remotely makes sense.

[baudib]

i think daven has done a fair job defending himself. i think MMM has been kinda scattered and i dont have a good read but he would be a good lynch


i think its a real wolf tell. you cant give him a pass on it because we havent played with him. hes still a human that behaves/posts like one. hes a really solid lynch target now. the points early in day 1 against him i still think are pretty valid

Gabe, what exactly are you doing this game? Almost every post you make makes my eyebrows twitch.

There's so much that read like your past couple of wolf.

"Hey, we have to lynch the new guy because we won't be able to read him." Then you make a surface read of a couple of posts and declare you have read him.

This sounds like more policy-lynching and while I've seen you make some whimsical votes on D1, this is nothing at all when you were making votes on me and Keybored last game as a villager. It sounds more like "Hey guys, we can't have all these duck names around, I'm telling you it'll be confusing." And as you pointed out, the Gabe name carries more weight, so you can try to push more B.S.

We've had a lot of newcomers in the past few games, and I don't remember you ever expressing this idea that it's +EV to just policy lynch them.

wuf my soul read credits have only gone up this year.. however im a bad wolf, a terrible ghost angel, and my success rate at convincing the village to kill someone i read when i die is 0% (props to gator and ong recently for escaping my deathrattle)

You trying to sell the notion that you're a bad wolf is...weird. Also, the phrase is not wolfy in itself but I remember you saying, meh, BigRed is an +EV lynch...when you were a wolf. Then you pointed out how sometimes you can find dissonance in players' thinking...the last time I recall you using "dissonance" in an argument was you putting together a couple of Gator quotes and saying, "Dissonance is a wolfy trait."

yeah, you were a wolf that game, too.