Ultimate Werewolf

[gabe]

lynch monstrman
he'll be impossible to read. he's already less likely to be lynched early (which if he is completely random role, is +ev for the wolf side)

[gabe]

This is a very bad reasoning for a vote. For one, I don't imagine you've ever played with me so you actually cannot say with any degree of certainty wether or not I'll be impossible to read

you are missing the logic boat on this one. (i cut out your "secondly" response because it was irrelevant)

luckily i have 2 completely relevant points for everyone about you:
1. i'm almost sure i've never played with monstrman, but that doesnt stop me from making a read based on the common archetype of a new poster in a forum. my post about you seems obvious yet you think you rebutted it so matter-of-factly. you say its bad reasoning, but you are not taking into account the behavior of the players here. what i stated was perfectly true and i'm sure its +ev in a vacuum to kill you in this spot simple because of you being a first timer here on ftr, and having wolf experience
2. to me it seems so obvious I (or anyone) could make a read about the things i said about you (i included it below). the fact that you are forcefully trying to say its bad reasoning, and stating that opinion of yours as a fact, is definitely wolfy evidence

lynch monstrman
he'll be impossible to read. he's already less likely to be lynched early (which if he is completely random role, is +ev for the wolf side)

i'm sticking with monstrman

[monstrman]

you are missing the logic boat on this one. (i cut out your "secondly" response because it was irrelevant)

luckily i have 2 completely relevant points for everyone about you:
1. i'm almost sure i've never played with monstrman, but that doesnt stop me from making a read based on the common archetype of a new poster in a forum. my post about you seems obvious yet you think you rebutted it so matter-of-factly. you say its bad reasoning, but you are not taking into account the behavior of the players here. what i stated was perfectly true and i'm sure its +ev in a vacuum to kill you in this spot simple because of you being a first timer here on ftr, and having wolf experience
2. to me it seems so obvious I (or anyone) could make a read about the things i said about you (i included it below). the fact that you are forcefully trying to say its bad reasoning, and stating that opinion of yours as a fact, is definitely wolfy evidence



i'm sticking with monstrman

Well that's just plain not nice then