No theme werewolf gameplay thread

[BankItDrew]

If JKDS flips wolf, it looks terrible for MMM, Ong, Hoopy, and myself, in that order.

[Keybored]

If nobody moves or votes rest of day, JKDS is L-1 for first to reach 2 votes.
The Dhuber jump does not protect JKDS and it gives both Hoopy & Ong a free pass.
-Hoopy no longer has to uphold his vow to hit JK at end of day.
-Ong could get shitfaced and forget how to get home.

Something smells funny.

[BankItDrew]

I fucked that up. If JKDS flips wolf, it looks bad for:
MMM
Dhub
Hoopy
then myself.

I don't believe keybored has given a strong opinion. Put ong in there where you'd like.

[MadMojoMonkey]

My reads

JKDS:
I've seen nothing to change my opinion on JKDS. He's not been hunting, he's been reacting. His arguments are thin and circumstantial. He sneaks tidbits in like "if ong is vil, then ong would ..." and treats them like they are irrefutable facts, when they are plainly opinions... and even as strong reads, there is a probability that they're wrong.
JKDS sees no nuance in other people - calling the same behavior villagery for him, but wolfy for someone else. This kind of dichotomy is the opposite of logic.
JKDS's arguments are heavy in appeals to emotion.
JKDS has repeatedly gone into the "cornered canine" ITT.

dhubermex:
I think dhub's game looks too obviously wolfy to be genuinely wolfy... but I could be leveling myself.

ongbonga:
I thought ong was right about JKDS, and therefore right about 3 wolves, but if he comes down on me, then he's seriously ignoring a preponderance of evidence in my favor, and latching onto the small inconsistencies that are unavoidable for a working villager. I know he's a strong player, so this argument doesn't hold for BID, keybored, dhubs - BID has bad history, and the others have no history with me, so I can't judge their skill.

It's hard to see the ong/JKDS as W-W, but it's worth a re-read.

BankItDrew
I could fall either way. He's playing this game very differently than his usual all spew all the time style.

Hoopy:
I really don't know. I want to say V. All of the villagers have been working to figure me out... don't see an easy choice. Hoopy seems quite content with sitting on me as V... which stands out.

Keybored:
There is so vastly much evidence that he's a villager that if he's W, he's fooled me wholly. gg

[Keybored]

^^^ well scratch that...Hoopy just hit JK. I'll STFU now.

[BankItDrew]

God damn it I want to lynch dhub so bad. How has he survived this long?

[BankItDrew]

FWIW, I want to remind people that MMM is by far my strongest village lean. In case shit happens...

[Keybored]

FWIW, I want to remind people that MMM is by far my strongest village lean. In case shit happens...

Do u support his JKDS stance?

[BankItDrew]

Nope.

If JKDS flips wolf, then yes.

[Keybored]

If we get a lynch, it's wolf killing time. So, if I don't wake up tomorrow...
It means I wasn't protected & the wolf(s) is in JKDS/Dhuber.
Hoopy & BID & Ong are straight village, y'all.
MMM could be the other.

[dhubermex]

Okay then, I'll cast the deciding vote. There's more than enough evidence on the last two pages alone to point to my Village status and I gave everyone plenty of time to come up with something better (or start a BID wagon). No takers.

I'd say the chances JKDS is a wolf is right at 50/50... so here's the fourth vote needed.

lynch JKDS

If he flips wolf then what a great wolf he was. If he flips Village then as he said there should be enough info out there now on who to lynch next day, but I'm sure at least one villager will team up with the wolves (if there are indeed 2 remaining after this) and nominate me.

[Hoopy]

Well that's it then.

Now we wait for wufmod, fingers crossed.

[MadMojoMonkey]

Baited breath

[dhubermex]

I fucked that up. If JKDS flips wolf, it looks bad for:
MMM
Dhub
Hoopy
then myself.

I don't believe keybored has given a strong opinion. Put ong in there where you'd like.

How does JKDS flipping either way look bad for me? I practically gave my lynch away to try to get a wolf to hop on board (no takers), had pretty much "sealed" his fate as Keybored put it earlier in the day when vote was 3-2-1, then rescinded to put it in a wolf's hands, but he didn't take the bait (or wasn't online at the time).

It troubles me that both you & Keybored are trying to "lead" the thread. I don't believe either of your opinions are that qualified when it comes to this match (unless you're both wolves, then well played obv). I think you're a wolf, and the other one is somewhere in JKDS/MMM. Perhaps Keybored is in the mix and maybe Ong... I'm sincerely confused because there are posts by each player now that look good or look bad. The Hoopy rescind is the clearest Villager lean so far (in my opinion).

[JKDS]

Aroooooooooo. Lame.

[MadMojoMonkey]

[BankItDrew]

Aroooooooooo. Lame.

bahahaha sick

[MadMojoMonkey]

Now bring us a save tonight, ghost angels.

[dhubermex]

Aroooooooooo. Lame.

Man, I LOVE your wolf game... respect.

With that said, things are looking much better now!

[Hoopy]

[Keybored]

Whew...that was crazy! We woulda been hurting. Nuthin but love, JK!

[OngBonga]

Sup. So what did I miss?





Oh. BAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

[JKDS]

Jokes on you guys, now i get to troll the dead thread.

[OngBonga]

Last one is drew, ong for mvp, 100% ownage.

[dhubermex]

Last one is drew, ong for mvp, 100% ownage.

I'm fine with this line of thinking.

[MadMojoMonkey]

If JKDS flips wolf, it looks terrible for MMM, Ong, Hoopy, and myself, in that order.

I fucked that up. If JKDS flips wolf, it looks bad for:
MMM
Dhub
Hoopy
then myself.

I don't believe keybored has given a strong opinion. Put ong in there where you'd like.

God damn it I want to lynch dhub so bad. How has he survived this long?

FWIW, I want to remind people that MMM is by far my strongest village lean. In case shit happens...

Do u support his JKDS stance?

Nope.

If JKDS flips wolf, then yes.

You wanna just howl now, BID?

[dhubermex]

From Post #830

Page 7 -- Ong again wants JKDS at #456. The previous post where JKDS claims I'm "almost certainly a Villager" still is a soft spot for me. Could Ong-JKDS dispute be V-on-V violence? BID pays lip service to MMM at #461... it seems weird. But then he also pays lip service to JKDS in that same post. This comes off to me as BID-wolf including one known Villager and one known Wolf in a single post for the sake of deception. The question here (if BID-wolf is more than a suspicion) is which wolf would he mention first. Percentage-wise I think it would need to be the first one... but it's a very strange post regardless imo. BID then refers to "wolves' master plan" at #463. Luco lets his fellow Villagers know at #465 that JKDS has the "smartest" wolf game... good to know coming from him.

BID's Post #461 is best tell imo.

[JKDS]

Guys, I've changed my mind. MMM is a villager!

[dhubermex]

Here's BID's Post #461 paying lip service.

You were in my wolfy camp on Day 1 and I mentioned why, then.

MMM - Thanks for the compliment. My justification is that I didn't care before but now I do.

Ong - I truly do think you're a wolf. I think I have a solid read on the way you post whether you are a villager or a wolf. If I'm wrong, I guess it's back to the drawing board for me as far as soulreads go.

I think the best thing you can do right now is do what JKDS did at the end of Day 2: Get your shit together and provide us with as much insight as you possibly can. You mentioned that you were pushing for a rilla lynch at one point, so start there.

Basically JKDS flipping wolf looks bad, worse and worst for BID and only BID at this point.

[MadMojoMonkey]

Guys, I've changed my mind. MMM is a villager!

shhhh.... it'll all be over soon, littly puppy.

gg

It's my respect for your game that both bought you time, and ultimately got you.

[OngBonga]

It might not be drew, it could be keybored. Remember jkds said that thing where keith was 2/3? Well maybe jkds knew keith was 2/3, and he slipped.

[Keybored]

Whoaaaa Wilbur...wait for the buzz to wear off b4 spewing crap. We ALL hated on JK today!

[MadMojoMonkey]

I think rilla was trying to help his wolf buddy by asking a challenging question in the physics monkey thread.

@wuf: unfair advantage to their team fersher!!

[wufwugy]

So is that 4 on jkds?

[JKDS]

Yes

[wufwugy]

Dat JKDS be all dead n snazz

The Living

MMM
Dhuber
Ong
BID
Hoops
Keybored

The Dead

A crazy, themed game (or ur mam)
baudib
keith
rilla
daven
gabe
luco
jkds

The Village

5 villagers
1 wolves
4 ghost angels!


Night 4 now. Gots till 2:30 PM PST peeps. Smoke em if you got em!































































































































































LOLNOPE

The Living

MMM
Dhuber
Ong
BID
Hoops
Keybored

The Dead

A crazy, themed game (or ur mam)
baudib
keith
rilla
daven
gabe
luco
jkds

The Village

4 villagers
2 wolves
4 ghost angels!


Night 4 now. Gots till 2:30 PM PST peeps. Smoke em if you got em!

[MadMojoMonkey]

Wait, WTF?

[Hoopy]

Fuuuuuuucccccccckkkkkkkk!!!!!!!

[Hoopy]

JKDS with the master troll?

[MadMojoMonkey]

seriously, WTF? my F5 is broken.

If JKDS is vil, then he hung me... and w/o a save tonight it's gg wolves.

Why in the hell did Luco die?

[BankItDrew]

hahaha ownd

[BankItDrew]

MMM is looking like shit all of a sudden

[BankItDrew]

huber is a wolf guyz

jesus fucking christ when r u gonna get on this

[MadMojoMonkey]

I know... you have to take me down now. There's no way around it.

I was wrong on gabe, I was wrong on JKDS, and I spent all day gunning for JKDS.

If there's no save tonight, then I'm done, it's 2V/2W and it's done.

Even if it's a save tonight, village mislynch on me means another save must happen... which triggers the revive, but it's the only path now.

[OngBonga]

Tosser. Now we get to waste typing energy by arguing about whose reactions were fake and whose weren't.

[Keybored]

Oh no he di-int!!
Who does that?
This game sux.
I want my $$ back...

[Keybored]

Tosser. Now we get to waste typing energy by arguing about whose reactions were fake and whose weren't.

I'd rather try to figure out what all that vote hopping was about

[OngBonga]

I doubt a wolf laughs in the thread. drew looks good to me. Anyone else, well it's not even worth discussing really. Maybe mojo and doobs didn't know and started digging. Or maybe they did that because they thought it would look good. idk.

[BankItDrew]

You guys should just do what I do from now on. Here's my dhuber impression:

I'M A VILLAGER

Just get on my back and I'll take you to the promised land.

[Keybored]

It might not be drew, it could be keybored.

Tosser. Now we get to waste typing energy by arguing about whose reactions were fake and whose weren't.

Take that...beeooootch!

[Hoopy]

I'm going to bed. This game is making me tilt right now.

[wufwugy]

I have gotten lots of questions from all angles about the revive.

If it happens, it would be on the night after the second successful save, and it doesn't include an auto-block. If a lynch causes something like 2v2, then a revive (or block) that night does nothing to raise the numbers back to 3v2. Obviously this means a revive is unlikely at this point, but it technically can still happen

Some may not be happy with this, as I didn't say it explicitly in my original writeup of the rules, but we'll have to talk about it after the game. The rule as it is now was always the rule I was going to use since the beginning of the game. After the game I can explain why the rules appeared to change (it was more like what I told you about the rules changed, not the rules as I intended them). The one rule that definitely did change was allowing just one revive instead of two. I should never have said two were possible and I changed that as soon as I thought it through

[BankItDrew]

If there's no save tonight, then I'm done, it's 2V/2W and it's done.

This incriminates MMM

He's saying that you have to kill MMM, which leads to a probable wolf win, which indirectly implies not to do it. Fuck this thinking.

[BankItDrew]

The one rule that definitely did change was allowing just one revive instead of two. I should never have said two were possible and I changed that as soon as I thought it through

I'm fine with this as long as you had the intent to make the game as fair as possible.

What wouldn't be cool is if you changed the game because at the time of the change, things had swung, throughout the course of the game, to one side or the other, with the intent to bring it back closer to 50/50.

[Keybored]

Why in the hell did Luco die?

I know, right?

[wufwugy]

What wouldn't be cool is if you changed the game because at the time of the change, things had swung, throughout the course of the game, to one side or the other, with the intent to bring it back closer to 50/50.

There's no easier way to kill the game than having a mod who does that

[BankItDrew]

There's no easier way to kill the game than having a mod who does that

agreed







gabe





i have a hard time getting over stuff

[Keybored]

huber is a wolf guyz

jesus fucking christ when r u gonna get on this

You guys should just do what I do from now on. Here's my dhuber impression:

I'M A VILLAGER

Just get on my back and I'll take you to the promised land.

Uh huh, yup yup. What he said ^^^

[MadMojoMonkey]

I have gotten lots of questions from all angles about the revive.

If it happens, it would be on the night after the second successful save, and it doesn't include an auto-block. If a lynch causes something like 2v2, then a revive (or block) that night does nothing to raise the numbers back to 3v2. Obviously this means a revive is unlikely at this point, but it technically can still happen

Jesus look at the chart, there is no way for a revive to happen unless the population is 3 V 1 W at the start of Night 6.

[wufwugy]

agreed







gabe





i have a hard time getting over stuff

when did gabe do that?

[BankItDrew]

When my wolf buddy sent in a nom, then i sent in a diff nom, and gabe nullified both

[dhubermex]

Well thanks JKDS for the tip of the hat and "psych" on the way out the door. So now we're looking at BID/Keybored team as most likely wolves?

[wufwugy]

When my wolf buddy sent in a nom, then i sent in a diff nom, and gabe nullified both

invalidated them? meh im coinflipping between the two unless one of the wolves was consistently the lead wolf, in which case im ignoring the vote of the non-lead

gotta admit though that was fucking funny and not too undeserved. you went on a cruise to jupiter or some shit during that game, returning only to say "LOLOLOLOLOL AM I LYNCHED YET"

[BankItDrew]

I can be redic/dumb sometimes

[Keybored]

gotta admit though that was fucking funny and not too undeserved. you went on a cruise to jupiter or some shit during that game, returning only to say "LOLOLOLOLOL AM I LYNCHED YET"

I give Wuf a village lean for perpetuating JKDS' clever ruse.

[Keybored]

@BID . . . How does JKDS flipping either way look bad for me?
It troubles me that both you & Keybored are trying to "lead" the thread. I don't believe either of your opinions are that qualified when it comes to this match (unless you're both wolves, then well played obv). I think you're (BID) a wolf, and the other one is somewhere in JKDS/MMM. Perhaps Keybored is in the mix and maybe Ong.

Jesus, Focker...you just nailed the entire village as wolf! Well, I suppose Hoopy's safe. Shit, let's celebrate!

[Keybored]

So now we're looking at BID/Keybored team as most likely wolves?

Okay...and JKDS' mislynch exposed us how? You gonna do some research now or wait another two weeks b4 bothering with this stupid analysis stuff??

[Keybored]

Jesus look at the chart, there is no way for a revive to happen unless the population is 3 V 1 W at the start of Night 6.

Oh, FFS MoMo, nobody looks at flow charts!! YGBFKM...

[BankItDrew]

Wat's a flow chat

[dhubermex]

Now we get to waste typing energy by arguing about whose reactions were fake and whose weren't.

This is precisely what it comes down to. Four legit reactions and two fake ones. JKDS' last act as a living Villager was the psych-out and it simplifies things. Worst-looking reactions in my opinion are those of BID and Ong. Not a lot can be read from MMM, Hoopy or Keybored reactions.

I say we hit the BID wagon as soon as next day starts.

[Keybored]

Aroooooooooo. Lame.

bahahaha sick

Now bring us a save tonight, ghost angels.

Man, I LOVE your wolf game... respect. With that said, things are looking much better now!

some stupid video capture of a dude from the '80s dancing

Whew...that was crazy! We woulda been hurting. Nuthin but love, JK!

Sup. So what did I miss? Oh. BAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

Guys, I've changed my mind. MMM is a villager!

shhhh.... it'll all be over soon, littly puppy. gg It's my respect for your game that both bought you time, and ultimately got you.

This is precisely what it comes down to. Four legit reactions and two fake ones. JKDS' last act as a living Villager was the psych-out and it simplifies things. Worst-looking reactions in my opinion are those of BID and Ong. Not a lot can be read from MMM, Hoopy or Keybored reactions. I say we hit the BID wagon as soon as next day starts.

How do BID/Ong's reactions fare worst/wolfish of all?
Other than further your BID objective.
Please elaborate...

[MadMojoMonkey]

BID says "sick"... why would he say that? He knows JKDS howl is a lie.

ong looks bad because he didn't dislocate his shoulder by fistpumping too hard. Serious pwnage if he was right on 3/3 in 3 days.

I missed that he cleared me in his final post. Maybe I don't have to punch him and wuf collectively in the face for the emotional rollercoaster of this page. Just wuf. And wuf's mom.

I feel like it has to be ong, but wtf? I was so sure it was JKDS... so.

I can has a break, now?

[MadMojoMonkey]

by "him" in the 3rd part, I mean JKDS.

and by break, I mean nap... I mean real sleep.

[Keybored]

bahahaha

BAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

Worst-looking reactions in my opinion are those of BID and Ong.

Oh wait, I think I've solved the "psyche out" riddle, Dhuber...

Bahahaha looks a lot like Baaaaahhhh which, everyone knows, is the sound a sheep makes. And sheep (as taught to us at the earliest age) are the favorite pickins of wolves; aka, their arch nemesis. Hence the term, wolf in sheep's clothing. And since that's all subliminal stuff we have jumbled up in our noggins, only a person who IS a wolf but PRETENDING to be a sheep would make such a Freudian slip.

Do I get a gold star? Or just a lynch nom ahead of BID?
How many minutes after the nk reveal are you gonna wait to make your lynch nom this time?

[Keybored]

JKDS left us with a trap for the wolves (heavy village lean, kid).
So, what if he caught someone?
Certainly Dhubs thinks so.
Let's see...

1hr 36mins passed between the lynch vote and Wuf's reveal. During which...
There were 22 posts but 3 were from JKDS, so strike them and I didn't count Wuf.
Of those 19 posts among us living:
MMM = 6
Doob = 5
Ong = 3
Hoopy = 2
KeyB = 2
BID = 1

Of those 19 posts:
-13 were gg/hi-5/happy-slappy/jungle love stuff completely off the wolf path.
-6 were game thread down to business affairs

So, who was having fun and who was back to work?
Of the 6 posts hitting the bricks:
-4 were from Dhuber
-1 was Ong
-1 was MMM

Ong's game post was a 1-liner mostly off topic: "Last one is drew, ong for mvp, 100% ownage."
MMM's game post was a 6-post quote followed by: "You wanna just howl now, BID?"
Dhuber's 4 game posts were straight up on the hunt using several quotes (old/new), full paragraphs, etc., etc.

Did the brilliant JKDS trap work?
IDK cuz all 6 of us said Whoopy! Which means the wolves sniffed out the ruse and played along.
But the numbers clearly show that 2 of us didn't act in the same manner as the rest of us...
MMM was uncomfortably playing along a bit too much.
Dhoob was completely opposite; nose down, on the fucking warpath.