No theme werewolf gameplay thread

[JKDS]

Your JKDS-Rilla conspiracy lacks thought and teeth. Rilla never voted me. I never voted rilla. I would have died had hoopy/luco/bid not voted rilla. Where is the giant wolf conspiracy to kill rilla, and why?

How does such a play shield me in the future?

If you're suggesting one of hoopy/BID is a wolf and at the last minute killed rilla as a conspiracy, how did they know that Luco and the other hoopy/bid would vote rilla?

If you're suggesting one of hoopy/bid is a wolf, that they killed rilla because rilla asked to be a 'meat shield' and was dying anyway, wouldnt they do the same to me?

You have to make so many jumps for this theory. It doesnt make any sense, and thats why you have been previously advocating against it. However, now that I'm attacking you, you've decided to support it instead.

Instead of a giant illogical conspiracy, it makes more sense that rilla got owned by villagers. Yeah, you voted rilla. I pointed that out. But you did so only after he got serious heat from other players. You did so only after a wagon formed. Of course a wolf could, and would, do this. There doesnt need to be any grand scheme behind it, just a simple reactionary and level 1 idea that when a wolf is gonna die, other wolves vote him too.

[MadMojoMonkey]

Your JKDS-Rilla conspiracy lacks thought and teeth. Rilla never voted me. I never voted rilla. I would have died had hoopy/luco/bid not voted rilla. Where is the giant wolf conspiracy to kill rilla, and why?

How does such a play shield me in the future?

If you're suggesting one of hoopy/BID is a wolf and at the last minute killed rilla as a conspiracy, how did they know that Luco and the other hoopy/bid would vote rilla?

If you're suggesting one of hoopy/bid is a wolf, that they killed rilla because rilla asked to be a 'meat shield' and was dying anyway, wouldnt they do the same to me?

You and rilla weren't alive together long enough to cast votes toward each other. It's a moot point, because I have no idea what you and rilla's votes would be as wolves or as villagers.

It's not a giant conspiracy to kill rilla, which you seem to keep insisting. Take note, village, that this is NOT what I'm saying.

I'm saying it was not a plan at the start of day 2, but as the day developed, it had JKDS vs ong, with rilla on the side. JKDS was in the lead, while ong was on the back burner. I vote rilla. Then you show up to defend yourself in earnest. Clearly your intent is to drive the vote back on to ong.

Now, I admit that this part is not perfectly clear:
hoopy's bold (2:41), then Luco's bold (2:57), then BID (3:13), then ong (3:58)
It could have been the wolf plan to break the vote from you and hope for a further split that would allow them to jump back on ong. If it's hoopy, he could have well intended to back off, but then the wagon built so fast that it wouldn't have mattered if he did. If it's BID, then he jumped on at the last minute as a grab for cred and to save you over rilla.

You have to make so many jumps for this theory. It doesnt make any sense, and thats why you have been previously advocating against it. However, now that I'm attacking you, you've decided to support it instead.

Wait. You're attacking me? Is that how you think this is going down? You're counterstrike relies on appeals to pathos, and you pretend you're on the attack? That's cute.

The only problem with my theory is that I was assuming you were a villager until I had reason to think otherwise. The way you nailed Gator to the wall in World War Werewolf was amazing. I wrongly had you pegged for wolf in that game. So I was trying to not make the same mistake twice.

Instead of a giant illogical conspiracy, it makes more sense that rilla got owned by villagers. Yeah, you voted rilla. I pointed that out. But you did so only after he got serious heat from other players. You did so only after a wagon formed. Of course a wolf could, and would, do this. There doesnt need to be any grand scheme behind it, just a simple reactionary and level 1 idea that when a wolf is gonna die, other wolves vote him too.

Ong and Luco were on, then off rilla earlier that day. I suppose that's what you mean by serious heat and a wagon. When I put my vote on rilla, I was the only one.

Wait.

Pay attention, village. Remember how JKDS said my arguments were not thought-through.


JKDS is saying that I am a wolf and that he's a villager.
He's saying that I put my vote on rilla and left my vote on rilla for 20 hours,
during which time I pressed my point and did not rescind my vote,
during which time JKDS wagon was 1 away from lynch w/o me on it.
JKDS is saying that I not only re-started a broken wagon on my wolf buddy, whom I did not intend to kill,
He's also saying that I did all of that, then didn't lynch him instead of my wolf buddy.
BUT
That it was not my plan to kill my wolf buddy.

Is that what you're saying?

[JKDS]

You and rilla weren't alive together long enough to cast votes toward each other. It's a moot point, because I have no idea what you and rilla's votes would be as wolves or as villagers.

It's not a giant conspiracy to kill rilla, which you seem to keep insisting. Take note, village, that this is NOT what I'm saying.

I'm saying it was not a plan at the start of day 2, but as the day developed, it had JKDS vs ong, with rilla on the side. JKDS was in the lead, while ong was on the back burner. I vote rilla. Then you show up to defend yourself in earnest. Clearly your intent is to drive the vote back on to ong.

But...not onto rilla...so the plan wasnt for a wolf-jkds to conspire to kill a wolf-rilla...This is not what you've said before.

Now, I admit that this part is not perfectly clear:
hoopy's bold (2:41), then Luco's bold (2:57), then BID (3:13), then ong (3:58)
It could have been the wolf plan to break the vote from you and hope for a further split that would allow them to jump back on ong. If it's hoopy, he could have well intended to back off, but then the wagon built so fast that it wouldn't have mattered if he did. If it's BID, then he jumped on at the last minute as a grab for cred and to save you over rilla.

Who's plan? If im a wolf, only one of hoopy, luco, bid, or ong could be a wolf. The four CANNOT have conspired together. Its not possible. Only one can be a wolf. There were two hours till deadline. Youre saying the wolf plan was to switch in the HOPE that enough votes would follow to switch the lynch? AND to another wolf no less? No. This whole idea is preposterous, and I cannot believe you're continuing to fight for it when you yourself saw the sillyness of it before.

Wait. You're attacking me? Is that how you think this is going down? You're counterstrike relies on appeals to pathos, and you pretend you're on the attack? That's cute.

Yes, I call researching your posts, making arguments against you, and voting you an attack. But disagree, by all means. Im sure ppl care.

Ong and Luco were on, then off rilla earlier that day. I suppose that's what you mean by serious heat and a wagon. When I put my vote on rilla, I was the only one.

Ppl left rilla's wagon to move to mine. Rilla was still under pressure at this time. You admit your vote did nothing though.

Wait.

Pay attention, village. Remember how JKDS said my arguments were not thought-through.


JKDS is saying that I am a wolf and that he's a villager.
He's saying that I put my vote on rilla and left my vote on rilla for 20 hours,
during which time I pressed my point and did not rescind my vote,

Two posts is now pressing, one of which said i was wolfy.

during which time JKDS wagon was 1 away from lynch w/o me on it.
JKDS is saying that I not only re-started a broken wagon on my wolf buddy, whom I did not intend to kill,
He's also saying that I did all of that, then didn't lynch him instead of my wolf buddy.
BUT
That it was not my plan to kill my wolf buddy.

Is that what you're saying?

Im sure it makes tons of sense for a wolf to switch to a villager and be the final vote. Thats never been seen as suspect before.

Its very easy to see rilla telling you to lynch him, and then you following the order.