*** Witch Hunt: Village of Souls gameplay thread ***

[wufwugy]

As it normally is, the witches win if they equal the number of villagers. The reason for this is that even if the game is 3 witches and 3 villagers and a villager correctly fingers a witch, a night phase will happen and it will then be 2 witches and 2 villagers. The baddies simply win when both teams are of equal size

[gabe]

As it normally is, the witches win if they equal the number of villagers. The reason for this is that even if the game is 3 witches and 3 villagers and a villager correctly fingers a witch, a night phase will happen and it will then be 2 witches and 2 villagers. The baddies simply win when both teams are of equal size

why?? if its 3-3, then there is a correct finger with subsequent night phase, its 2-2, then repeat and its 1-1, then whoever fingers the other person first once the thread is unlocked wins the game. right? of course different things can happen which i wont disclose but given the posted rules, the baddies dont lock it up when its even. please explain (even if it includes having to admit the rules arent impeccable)

[wufwugy]

why?? if its 3-3, then there is a correct finger with subsequent night phase, its 2-2, then repeat and its 1-1, then whoever fingers the other person first once the thread is unlocked wins the game. right? of course different things can happen which i wont disclose but given the posted rules, the baddies dont lock it up when its even. please explain (even if it includes having to admit the rules arent impeccable)

It just won't work in the game. The least convoluted method to let fingerings continue after 3-3 is me PMing a random villager, telling him to post his pick, then if he's right, the game continues, then he gets nom'd, rinse repeat two more times

It completely changes the game and it just becomes a question of whether the three remaining villagers can randomly pick the right target in perfect order. Nobody wants the game to be resolved that way