|
I really don't see HOW you can put someone on a direct hand like that, sure you could possibly say KK+, but it just isn't possible to be able to put someone on an exact hand preflop... I also don't agree with you wanting to fold postflop if you didn't hit a set. If the flop is all undercards, are you going to fold? Doubt it, its -EV to do if you do.
I don't know what to say here -- I'm finding that sometimes I'm almost certain from betting pattern that I know what I'm up against. I don't think it's magical, I think it's something you pick up on after a while -- some players won't reraise with anything but AA (or sometimes KK) for instance, and others like to raise 4-6BB with JJ-QQ, where everything else is a standard raise.
Here's the hand in question: I made the read, I played accordingly, and was right. It happens -- when it happens, IMHO, you should trust it.
PokerStars No-Limit Hold'em, $0.10 BB (6 handed) Hand History Converter Tool from FlopTurnRiver.com (Format: FlopTurnRiver)
saw flop|saw showdown
UTG ($9.20)
MP ($9.95)
Hero ($14.85)
Button ($3.55)
SB ($16.50)
BB ($3.15)
Preflop: Hero is CO with Q , Q .
2 folds, Hero raises to $0.3, 2 folds, BB raises to $0.5, Hero calls $0.20.
Flop: ($1.05) T , 4 , Q (2 players)
BB bets $0.3, Hero raises to $1, BB calls $0.70.
Turn: ($3.05) 7 (2 players)
BB bets $0.4, Hero raises to $1.65, BB calls $1.25 (All-In).
River: ($6.35) T (2 players, 1 all-in)
Final Pot: $6.35
Results in white below:
BB has Ad As (two pair, aces and tens).
Hero has Qc Qh (full house, queens full of tens).
Outcome: Hero wins $6.35.
Here's the second one I mentioned -- it turns out it was AAA vs QQQ instead of full houses. Now, it might help to mention that I've played > 100 hands against this guy (and even know his real name ), and his V$PiP is something like 14%. I had no doubt be had aces, but I didn't think my read was good enough to trust so I crossed my fingers and went ahead and pushed. In hindsight I didn't lose that much, but it sure felt like a whole stack.
PokerStars No-Limit Hold'em, $0.10 BB (8 handed) Hand History Converter Tool from FlopTurnRiver.com (Format: FlopTurnRiver)
saw flop|saw showdown
Hero ($10.95)
Button ($9.85)
SB ($5.95)
BB ($5.40)
UTG ($3.50)
UTG+1 ($7.80)
MP1 ($2.70)
MP2 ($9.80)
Preflop: Hero is CO with Q , Q .
UTG raises to $0.2, 1 fold, MP1 calls $0.20, MP2 raises to $0.5, Hero calls $0.50, 2 folds, BB calls $0.40, UTG calls $0.30, MP1 raises to $0.8, MP2 calls $0.30, Hero calls $0.30, BB calls $0.30, UTG calls $0.30.
Flop: ($4.05) Q , A , 2 (5 players)
BB checks, UTG checks, MP1 bets $0.2, MP2 calls $0.20, Hero raises to $2.1, BB folds, UTG folds, MP1 calls $1.70 (All-In), MP2 folds.
Turn: ($8.25) T (2 players, 1 all-in)
River: ($8.25) 6 (2 players, 1 all-in)
Final Pot: $8.25
Results in white below:
MP1 has Ah Ad (three of a kind, aces).
Hero has Qc Qh (three of a kind, queens).
Outcome: MP1 wins $8.05. Hero wins $0.20.
It turns out, that for me (and I doubt it's just me), then if I feel a certainty that a certain played has xx, then it's usually correct, and I'd best listen to that read. Not that I get them all the time, but when they're there they're reliable.
You disagree, and I say "cool." You're probably way beyond the 5,000 hand point anyway. 
I don't agree with you saying Top pair top kicker "sucks". Top pair top kicker is a GOOD hand to have, as long as you play it properly, trusting reads here does help, but you have to be putting your opps on ranges throughout the hand (preflop, flop, turn, river). Ranges are something like PP 66+, A10+, stuff like this, not just AJ for sure, he must have AJ! I just know it! Top pair top kicker is strong as long as its played well.
True, and I could have made a more complex statement here, something more like "small hand small pot, big hand big pot."
It turns out, though, sometimes you'll hit 2 pair on the flop, be reraised huge, and know that the player making the raise has you beat. If you're new to the table this is marginal, but if you've watched the guy in the last 80 hands it might be a bit more dependable. Regardless, it's been my experience (at micro limits, of course) that someone will let you know when you're beat. I can generalize by saying that for my play, if I don't listen when some schmoe tells me I'm beat then I'm generally losing money. I hope to develop my reads better so in the future I can tell that the bozo has j3 and just hit his J before going all-in on a board of AKJ, but right now the number of times that's happened has been greatly shadowed by those where the bet was an honest one -- I was beat.
I completely disagree with you saying two pair sucks very often.. bottom 2 pair, sure, be cautious but top two pair (AK on AK6 board for example) can't be played as if you assume he has a set every single time, you just won't maximize profit this way. Two pair is very rarely not golden (depending on the board).
Depending on the board and on what the other player's telling you. I'm not trying to say "don't bet top 2 pair." I'm trying to say "don't call a $9 bet into a $1.30 pot if all you've got is top 2 pair." Better?
|