25nl Nut Flush Paired Board

[Lucix]

Villain is 37/6.5/1.86 over 46 hands. Is it ok to shove nut flush on paired board, or is a call more appropriate?

BB: $16.50
UTG: $35.55
MP: $23.25
CO: $20.15
BTN: $24.65
Hero (SB): $30.55

Pre Flop: Hero is SB with 7 A
UTG calls $0, 3 folds, Hero calls $0, BB checks

Flop: 5 2 4 (3 players)
Hero bets $0.50, BB calls $0.50, UTG folds

Turn: ($1.00) 6 (2 players)
Hero bets $1.00, BB calls $1

River: ($3.00) 5 (2 players)
Hero bets $3.50, BB raises to $9.50, Hero raises to $28.80, BB calls $19.30

[Lucix]

Looks like the hand history didn't list the blinds. All pots are $0.75 bigger than it lists.

[poker_pup]

Well, that's a tough one. I suppose I would just call his raise instead of going all in. It's my belief that in this instance, the only hands he would call you with will beat you.

[Robb]

Well, that's a tough one. I suppose I would just call his raise instead of going all in. It's my belief that in this instance, the only hands he would call you with will beat you.

+1

My reasoning is this: the betting doesn't really narrow villain's holdings much. The first real read we get on his hand is the river raise which he makes AFTER seeing the flush has hit. Looks like he's not too worried about it, which would worry me.

[pankfish]

Looks more like he has a worse flush than a boat.

[Robb]

Looks more like he has a worse flush than a boat.

True. So...do you call the river raise, or rr?