Carnage before Christmas

[OngBonga]

hotshots played particularly badly here I think. I'm cool with people going for glory, but d1 is crazy. keybored was under no pressure, he definitely should wait. And I have no idea what hoopy is thinking when he rescinds his doobs vote. That was crazy. If he sticks with that vote then doobs doesn't get mislynched today, luco dies instead and maybe dan gets found out. idk, but keith has a lot on his side, particularly the plan which kills a wolf. wuf is obv villager.

hoopy cost us more than keybored did. Self preservation abandoned him at the most critical time.

[OngBonga]

If I were a hotshot, I might have shot dan for asking for someone to shoot baudib. Why the hell does a villager say that? Wuf nailed it about faking, I wanted to but didn't because it narrows down the pool. dan slipped there.

[Luco]

hotshots played particularly badly here I think. I'm cool with people going for glory, but d1 is crazy. keybored was under no pressure, he definitely should wait. And I have no idea what hoopy is thinking when he rescinds his doobs vote. That was crazy. If he sticks with that vote then doobs doesn't get mislynched today, luco dies instead and maybe dan gets found out. idk, but keith has a lot on his side, particularly the plan which kills a wolf. wuf is obv villager.

hoopy cost us more than keybored did. Self preservation abandoned him at the most critical time.

Yup yup yup, I was already thinking this - if hoopy hadn't rescinded at the last second the village would have had a decent shot at winning

Hoops, always take the non-zero shot at a wolf i.e. not yourself

[OngBonga]

Then again you guys failing to use your roleblocker when you should default to the person you're killing, that's also pure spew that nearly cost you an easy win.

[MadMojoMonkey]

I was asleep, give me a minute to catch up.

Looks like gg, wolves.

It would take me a couple of hours to do a fresh write-up given my current mental state (just woke up).

Spoiler: Show

The village lynched dhubermex, a Vanilla Villager, on D3.

***
Nothing can stop parity on D4, so the wolves win the game.

GG, WP, wolves.

[MadMojoMonkey]

Wolf Chat:
http://www.quicktopic.com/51/H/Vv9Vjp9DvKRxf


Dead Thread:
http://www.quicktopic.com/51/H/FebZaKmAvbK


Night Watch (N1):
http://www.quicktopic.com/51/H/fZsvj9fe5n69


Night Watch (N2):
http://www.quicktopic.com/51/H/cfbRvKfdpE6q

[MadMojoMonkey]

A mods notes to self:

STOP AND DO NOTHING when responding to players in game. The probability to accidentally do something which conveys unintended information is high. BE PATIENT AND CAREFULLY CHOOSE YOUR RESPONSE.

The Time Zones of the players is not to be ignored when choosing EOD timing. Also, EOD timing is much more important to the game play than Start of Day. Choose time to maximize player involvement at EOD.

Give the players room to play. Don't be thin-skinned about players commenting on your choices. They are working through the hidden info, and part of that process is to scrutinize the info they DO have and the sources of said info. Be objective when analyzing their comments.

[Keybored]

hotshots played particularly badly here I think. I'm cool with people going for glory, but d1 is crazy. keybored was under no pressure, he definitely should wait. And I have no idea what hoopy is thinking when he rescinds his doobs vote. That was crazy. If he sticks with that vote then doobs doesn't get mislynched today, luco dies instead and maybe dan gets found out. idk, but keith has a lot on his side, particularly the plan which kills a wolf. wuf is obv villager.

hoopy cost us more than keybored did. Self preservation abandoned him at the most critical time.

Not gonna duck it...I sucked.

But Hoopy's play put the whole village game into a death spiral.
Maybe he gets Honorary Wolf over Dhubs, who was mostly MIA anyway.

Gabe, beer's are on me, mate!

[Keybored]

Still wanna know why Wuf was all "Don't vote" yesterday and even early today too...but spewed anyway.

[Luco]

Keybored, congrats thread:

http://www.flopturnriver.com/pokerfo...es-198486.html

[OngBonga]

MMM - is it possible to not show this night chat to everyone when the game is over? I have a solid rep to uphold.

haha quote of the game

[Keith]

lol .......just read the n1 chat thread ......only BID could do it .........except daven posted in the wolf thread last game.... wierd that its the second time JKDS has been in a wrong threadaments moment as well after dranger's mistake years ago .

[Luco]

lol .......just read the n1 chat thread ......only BID could do it .........except daven posted in the wolf thread last game.... wierd that its the second time JKDS has been in a wrong threadaments moment as well after dranger's mistake years ago .

Did you notice that later on he accidentally posted in the den instead of the dead thread too?

[Keith]

yep ....how prophetic my words were

why randomize day 1 lynch and not sure what info you are hoping to get from a private chat that you can't tell what happened in it. Left to himself BID is a liability and targetting gabe over that comment seems opportunistic. lynch BID

[OngBonga]

from last game...

Man, this game is cracking me up. Well done, MoMo! You picked the perfect scenario capable of spinning this particular group of megalomaniacal over-thinkers into a star imploding into a black hole. Hey you guys, ask yourself this:

If Keybored's a Villager, then who'd want to go balls out to A) Lynch him and/or B) Save him?

I think the ppl pushing uber hard to mislynch me are wolves.
The attack is way too emotional and feigns logic.
I think their plan is to get us to waste our last V-HS on another villager (me).
They don't care about the lunch, it's our last HS they're after.

I think the ppl arguing to save me are truly considering what's best for the village and their logic is sound.

Fellow Hot Shot...Save it for the high percentage shot or submit to a village consensus.

I'm pretty sure I've seen the name momo thrown around a fair bit over the last few games, and dan has been involved in these games.

edit - sorry for posting this in here, I forgot to cut and paste and just hit submit. Reposted in the correct thread!

[MadMojoMonkey]

Last edited by OngBonga; Today at 11:23 AM.

ongbonga is modgat from the Carnage game post mortem.