***2010 CHRISTMAS WEREWOLF***

[bigred]

bigred...christmas drunk,......woooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

this game is dumb, why people playing it. lets lynch stupid people like michael tafe

[TLR]

ill happily lynch anyone who wants warpe dead on day 2. The seer almost always looks warpe up. The seer isnt dead. QED, we'll know warpe's role exactly later on in the game. Killing him is stupid, and people that want him lynched are very likely to be wolves.

I dont really want warpe lynched at this point either, until we get some more info one way or the other, but I dont really follow your logic of wanting to lynch anyone who wants warpe dead, assume the seer looked up Warpe as you predicted and warpe turns out to be a wolf, what do you expect the seer to do...

[JKDS]

assume the seer looked up Warpe as you predicted and warpe turns out to be a wolf, what do you expect the seer to do...

I expect him to bold him without any reasoning whatsoever, and thatd be it. Nothing else is necessary in a vets only WW.

[Hoopy]

Ok I've reread the last 4 pages and it seems like most of the talk is just villagers accusing each other with the wolves staying quiet.

lynch XTR seems like a great option right now.

[BooG690]

Rescind Carroters
Lynch XTR

I can go with that.

[philly and the phanatics]

really hungover from xmas and tired so idk how much sense anything i type is going to make.

Boog that was such an awesome ass mspaint i lold pretty hard.

As for XTR, i would like to see a defense from him but it would not be a terrible lynch (also low risk/fits flomo/3bet wolf model from last game (and obviously other games just thats the most recent one))...

Sticking with JKDS for the time being. It's weird how an SDM wagon never takes off theres been a couple now that have not gone anywhere.

Also @ jkds even in "vet WW" n00bs can still be the seer. But i do agree that lynching warpe today is pretty dumb like i have said multiple times.

Also @ roid...maybe its just that all your posting annoys the shit out of me but it seems like you are over doing the "erratic villager" and are trying to cause confusion/spread panic in village and i do not like it. I agree with boog that the game isnt that bad at all and everyone who keeps piling on shit about how fucked we are is definitely moving their way to my suspect list.

[BooG690]

I really hate the fact that Carroters posts like crazy then goes missing the second I put some heat on him.

[Carroters]

STFU it's christmas. "Ohhh wow look he came back as soon ass the heat was off he's a wolf." No it's christmas and I haven't thought of anything to say since I'm honestly fairly leadless in this game.

I still like a BooG lynch. Hate a Warpe lynch right now. XTR isn't a horrible choice since I guess he's a fairly likely recruit and has been lurking in the shadows and helping the village not at all so far.

Leaving my vote where it is in hope the BooG wagon goes somewhere. If it doesn't I could consider XTR, still kind of wary of philly though tbh that's currently putting me off.

[DropTheBanana]

I still feel rather strong about it.

lynch StillDeadMoney

[Icanhastreebet]

Lynch roid because boog made a cool picture and roid wants to kill him

[Icanhastreebet]

oh also rescind jkds

[TLR]

Carroters is all over the place, and he seems wolfy to me
lynch Carroters

[rong]

rescind JKDS, Lynch Gator Too quiet imo

[rong]

Also, happy christmas! Off to play fallout now.

[GatorJH]

With the way Day 2 is going I would be willing to bet that there are at least 1-2 active wolf semi-bandwagon's going out there. For now I am sticking with SDM but, based on latest postings could go with Boog, XTR or Carroters.

[lolzzz_321]

24 hours...

[Warpe]

Sticking with my Willbur vote.

[wufwugy]

Is dranger usually this active?

I ask because the only actual logic of the game so far that has made any sense is the Santy recruit being on Night 2 due to heat. It implicates Dan, kingnat, and roid. I'm not lynching Dan for my original reasons and it seems others have come to their own, kingnat is getting zero traction yet he's also not posting much which seems odd if he was a special under some heat (but I'm not ruling him out), yet roid came very close to a successful BW, he's been very active, things like posting and checking the thread a lot.

I haven't played with him, does this suggest the Santy recruit theory is correct, and he's our guy?

[fulksy]

never voting for WUF, it took me about 5 mins to read his post because of that sig.

[fulksy]

but I'm sticking with Warpe for now, but still wary of carroters, also JKDS.

[JKDS]

but I'm sticking with Warpe for now, but still wary of carroters, also JKDS.

Why are you wary of me, and why do you want warpe dead?

I need a good explanation here because this is my 2nd theory.

Its called Occam's razor. The simplest explanation is often the correct one. I'm a villager. If warpe is a villager, then we have mr. fulsky trying to cast suspicion and kill off two of what are arguably the village's best assets. Who wants to do this on day 2??? Ill give you a hint, the wolves killed off Rilla on night 1.

[Roid_Rage]

I've advocated multiple times that the wolf team might very well be slightly on the noobier side. (This somewhat implicates myself as well, but what can ya do)

@ Wuf, you can go back and read some of my other games, I'm usually pretty active in these and it probably seems like I'm more active than usual due to the holidays and fewer people actively checking the thread, etc. I get bored easily at my house (I live in Central Michigan with very little to do) so I pop in and typically comment on anything I see going on.

Find me suspicious if you will, but w/e. I'm not gonna get too flustered about it if you want to kill me off due to activity, but I suggest you take a long look at those that are staying quiet and not posting much.

Icanhastreebet specifically.

[wufwugy]

Icanhastreebet specifically.

I was thinking that too. He may be thinking that his posting in the last game got him caught by Benny so he's a quiet wolf now

I was prepared to bold you if you didn't defend yourself because I think if you were a wolf you would have tried to act like you weren't paying attention. So good job getting me off your case

[wufwugy]

Given the last game, I think philly is posting too much to be a wolf. He expressed some level of being upset that he got caught and let the team down, so I think he may have tightened his lips if he was a baddy this time

[JKDS]

gator really seems to be pushing that its not regs, when there's some evidence that it is regs, which makes me suspicious, but again i think i'm reading to much into this. it was between him and warpe, warpe seems more suspicious to me because he's not jumping on a obvious BW which seems opposite of why you should suspect him but it definitely takes some of the focus off him.

Lynch Warpe

He wants to lynch gator too, and his reasoning to lynch warpe isnt even coherent.

rescind sdm, lynch Fulsky

If i have any 'trust me village' cards, id like to use one.

[JKDS]

I like wuf's reasoning on philly, am just as curious about what yaawn is up too, and wish the seer would look up dan_roid because they got me confused.

[fulksy]

Why are you wary of me, and why do you want warpe dead?

I need a good explanation here because this is my 2nd theory.

Its called Occam's razor. The simplest explanation is often the correct one. I'm a villager. If warpe is a villager, then we have mr. fulsky trying to cast suspicion and kill off two of what are arguably the village's best assets. Who wants to do this on day 2??? Ill give you a hint, the wolves killed off Rilla on night 1.

1st timer here, so to be honest i have no clue who are the biggest assets to the village. from what i heard Keith was pretty decent at spotting wolves, and you were one of the 1st to jump onto that BW, maybe I'm wrong and he wasn't very good, but if he was your kind of contradicting your statement. maybe my suspicion of you was based on bad info, but i have no past experience to go on so.... as for warpe maybe i was reading way to much into it, but his vote for willburforce didn't seem to be based on much and it looked to me like he was making an effort to stay inconspicuous by not jumping on any BW, maybe this is pretty standard but since it seems that the 1st couple lynch's are somewhat of a crapshoot i went with my crazy conspiracy theory idea's. and since you were pretty adamant in defending warpe it just added to my suspicion. hey like i said, never played and if you think I'm way off here let me know why.

as for your Occams razor, it seems that most people here have played a decent amount, why would you saying your a villager hold any more water then anyone else, and why are you so confident that warpe isn't a wolf? how is the simplest answer that the rook's/non regs are trying to get out all the tough regs. it seems way more of a simple concept that regs are trying to get out the best players as they would have more familiarity with who are the best.

[Carroters]

Okay we're running out of time. None of my other wagons have taken off and the only one I'm still confident in is BooG anyways. I'm beginging to think philly is just a villager and I agree with Wuf that he would be less out there this game as a wolf, his reactions to heat have also led me to believe he's a villager.

If we don't act soon we're going to be completely split, and some random person like Warpe is going to get lynched without any good reason whatsoever as far as I can see. I do think fulsky looks pretty damn wolfy. I'm going to switch to fulsky in the hope this wagon takes off,because we need something that isn't based on nothing and he's by far the wolfiest looking of the wagons that have any potential for going anywhere imo in this limited time. I also have no idea why I seem wolfy to people, so Fulsky casting suspicion on me with no explanation is also not sitting right with me.

JKDS is a cunt of a wolf, but I'm going to trust him just now and do share the same opinions. We can always watch him more closely should this fulsky wagon snare a villager. Well I'll prolly get attacked in that case, but whatever, I think this is our best bet and we need to act swfitly.

Rescind BooG. Lynch Fulsky.

[Roid_Rage]

I targeted fulsky in my post outlining my thoughts on wolves being noobs, and since BooGs BW (with Carroters hopping off) isn't going anywhere...

Rescind BooG (til tomorrow)

Lynch fulsky

[JKDS]

You name myself, warpe, and gator (the people still alive) as suspicious, and defended keith a bunch AFTER he was dead...yet you dont know who the best players are.

You say i defended warpe...which means you read my post. In it, i say that we should be killing off our best players. You dont rescind warpe.

You believe the first few lynches are a crapshoot despite 9 pages in this current game, but claim you dont know whats going on.

I CALL BS

as for this

as for your Occams razor, it seems that most people here have played a decent amount, why would you saying your a villager hold any more water then anyone else, and why are you so confident that warpe isn't a wolf? how is the simplest answer that the rook's/non regs are trying to get out all the tough regs. it seems way more of a simple concept that regs are trying to get out the best players as they would have more familiarity with who are the best.

Ive explained already that it doesnt matter mine or warpes roles...because we're high priority seer targes (remember, you read the post where i defended warpe and said this).

I never said rookies/non regs are trying to kill the tough regs. I said that YOU want all the tough regs dead...and so do the wolves.

[JKDS]

^^above post is directed at fulsky of course

[JKDS]

You say i defended warpe...which means you read my post. In it, i say that we shouldn't be killing off our best players. You dont rescind warpe.

who proofreads anymore

[fulksy]

He wants to lynch gator too, and his reasoning to lynch warpe isnt even coherent.

rescind sdm, lynch Fulsky

If i have any 'trust me village' cards, id like to use one.

as illogical as my reasons of why you or warpe are (or may be) a wolf may be, at least i have some. if you have any reason on why you think I'm a wolf, other then because my reasoning isn't "coherent" and that i mentioned your name, please share.

if your looking for a defense post i'll do my best. first why would i chime in and mention my suspicions when i had relatively no heat on me, and there was already some votes for warpe, if i actually didn't think i could help.

i also didn't jump on the keith BW (who we know 100% was a villager) and instead voted for dan (who we still don't know) why would i not just jump on the keith BW especially when people were mentioning that he was a decent player?

as new player having no familiarity of any of the players why would i be calling the shots on who the wolfs vote for? you implied i was trying to cast suspicion of "clearly villager" regs and that i somehow had some influence on rilla getting voted off.

again it seems with relatively no suspicion of me (before you) it would be pretty easy to cast my vote and go on with the day, instead i decided to give some reasoning for my votes, not sure how you are deciphering any of this as me being a wolf.

[fulksy]

You name myself, warpe, and gator (the people still alive) as suspicious, and defended keith a bunch AFTER he was dead...yet you dont know who the best players are.

first how am i defending Keith all i was saying is that you were 1 of the 1st to jump on the keith BW and we know that he was a villager, maybe nothing, maybe something. and i don't know who the best players are i was going by what others have said Ex. "don't like a Keith lynch though since despite having walls of text to read through he is usually quite good at sniffing out discrepancies".

[fulksy]

I never said rookies/non regs are trying to kill the tough regs. I said that YOU want all the tough regs dead...and so do the wolves.

this makes no sense, of course the wolves would want all the tough regs dead, why at all would this point more to me then any other person?

[JKDS]

as illogical as my reasons of why you or warpe are (or may be) a wolf may be, at least i have some. if you have any reason on why you think I'm a wolf, other then because my reasoning isn't "coherent" and that i mentioned your name, please share.

You want the best players dead, so do the wolves. Its that simple.

if your looking for a defense post i'll do my best. first why would i chime in and mention my suspicions when i had relatively no heat on me, and there was already some votes for warpe, if i actually didn't think i could help.

Wolves like disguising their votes with BS reasoning. Warpe's bandwagon wasnt very strong. You're vote + reasoning is an attempt to move along a lynch on a player that many consider to be the best in this group.

i also didn't jump on the keith BW (who we know 100% was a villager) and instead voted for dan (who we still don't know) why would i not just jump on the keith BW especially when people were mentioning that he was a decent player?

Because Dan's wagon was larger at the time. At this point, he looks very villagery.

as new player having no familiarity of any of the players why would i be calling the shots on who the wolfs vote for? you implied i was trying to cast suspicion of "clearly villager" regs and that i somehow had some influence on rilla getting voted off.

I didnt say that either. I said you're trying to kill the good players. A simple "hey guys, kill warpe etc whenever u can" post in the ww forum is all it takes. I didnt say you were trying to cast suspicion of " clearly villager regs", i said you want the good regs dead.

again it seems with relatively no suspicion of me (before you) it would be pretty easy to cast my vote and go on with the day, instead i decided to give some reasoning for my votes, not sure how you are deciphering any of this as me being a wolf.

Because that same reasoning is an attempt to push a bandwagon on a godlike reg.

[fulksy]

meh i should really just put these all in one post, hey i really hope everyone goes through this and honestly deciphers if they think that i seem more wolfy then JKDS (who seemed to really go hard after me when i didn't even vote for him just merely mentioned his name along with others.) but hey if you vote me off and find out I'm a villager then please take a good look at JKDS, as it seems like he found a thread to pull at and just ran with it.

[JKDS]

first how am i defending Keith all i was saying is that you were 1 of the 1st to jump on the keith BW and we know that he was a villager, maybe nothing, maybe something. and i don't know who the best players are i was going by what others have said Ex. "don't like a Keith lynch though since despite having walls of text to read through he is usually quite good at sniffing out discrepancies".

I think its pretty odd that you dont know who the best players are, yet you're trying to kill almost all of them.

[JKDS]

this makes no sense, of course the wolves would want all the tough regs dead, why at all would this point more to me then any other person?

Because you also want all the good regs dead? You want gator dead. You want warpe dead. You want me dead.

And yes, my attack on you is because you posted that the village should be wary of me. But in the same breath, you also said you were sticking with warpe...EVEN THOUGH I stated he is a high priority seer target and that its better that we dont lynch him just yet! Your reasoning to kill warpe is NOT solid enough to justify sticking with him when the potential consequence is a lost seer look up and a lost god like reg...something you are now aware of since you read my post defending warpe.

[fulksy]

You want the best players dead, so do the wolves. Its that simple.

there's lots of other votes for regs, and of course the wolves would want all the best players gone, why do you imply this apply to me more then any other player?

I didnt say that either. I said you're trying to kill the good players. A simple "hey guys, kill warpe etc whenever u can" post in the ww forum is all it takes. I didnt say you were trying to cast suspicion of " clearly villager regs", i said you want the good regs dead.

why would you think that i would say this? with my 0 past experiences in WW, what is making you think that i would chime in with a "hey kill warpe whenever you can"


honestly how are my reasoning's worse then yours??? you seem to making a bunch of inferences with not an ounce of rational reasoning.

[kingnat]

Am I dead yet?

[JKDS]

there's lots of other votes for regs, and of course the wolves would want all the best players gone, why do you imply this apply to me more then any other player?



why would you think that i would say this? with my 0 past experiences in WW, what is making you think that i would chime in with a "hey kill warpe whenever you can"


honestly how are my reasoning's worse then yours??? you seem to making a bunch of inferences with not an ounce of rational reasoning.

I can say the same things over and over but they arent gonna be any different. It applies to you because you want ALL the good regs dead. Thats why it applies to you more than anyone else, and thats why im going after you.

I never said that you would make that post, but rather that someone else could have and you would instantly know who the best were and who to go after.

I think my reasoning is perfectly rational...and its fairly simple. You want all the regs dead, so do the wolves. You have yet to try and dispute this.

[Roid_Rage]

Fwiw, I'm following what JKDS is saying here, so I'll try to clear it up a bit.

Fulsky, he's saying you stated in one of your posts pretty clearly "Idk who all the good regs are" and in another post you state you are suspicious of and would like to lynch 3 great players of WW: Warpe, Gator, and JKDS himself.

This is what seems suspicious to him. You say you dont know who the good ones are, yet you're attacking them nonetheless. Discrepancies like this typically lead to wolves.

[fulksy]

I think its pretty odd that you dont know who the best players are, yet you're trying to kill almost all of them.

first why do you keep implying that i know players, at least give me some reasoning as to why this is. maybe its not because you are the " best players" maybe i think you guys sound the most suspicious. I have never played before and i would assume boog, TLR, big red, wuf, etc. etc. are pretty close if not better to you guys as "best players". saying you shouldn't be voted out because your a great player (to me) just seems like a pretty easy weak defense. i think your reading way more into it this then's actually there, remember "Occam's razor". are you honestly saying that my reasoning for you are completely irrational.

[wufwugy]

Is fulksy somebody? I was ready to hop on his wagon since I'm sorta still at the stage when a player like JKDS says to trust him, I'll try it out. Of course, I did the same exact thing with bolding bigred based on gabe saying that in last game. But fulksy claiming this is his first game throws me off because I recognize some similarities in how I played in my first game and how people got on my wagon because of it.

It does seem like a weird coincidence that this nub happens upon only real good players, but do we have to assume he would even know that as a wolf? Seems like if he really is a nub, he would have had to ask the other wolves or they would have offered the thoughts on the players. Seems almost like that would be a really crappy strategy if fulksy was a wolf.

I'm torn. I definitely do not want any good regs to be lynched without a good reason this early on, so I'll go after fulksy before Warpe. But I also don't wanna lynch an active nub early because I'm a super nice guy who wants to let them play the game. You guys ended up not lynching me earlier on my first game after all, and I that did make my experience a bit better.


But I think we really want to make sure that the good players are not lynch on the first couple of nights. I thought this before I realized that they're also seer targets, and it could end up soooooo valuable if the seer looks up a handful of strong regs, then outs before he's gat, and then the village has a very strong position from which to figure out the lies of the other good regs.


Not sure who I'm gonna bold, but really what it's going to boil down to simply trying to derail a wagon from one of the top regs since I think that's a better strategy than any of the reads presented on any potential baddies so far


JKDS, at the expense of potentially, unwittingly defending a wolf, let me ask, why would fulksy be so vocal about the good players if he was a wolf? That strikes me as dumb, and I recall a whole bunch of people jumped down my throat in the last game when I made a similar dumb post about trying to find the specials

[wufwugy]

You say you dont know who the good ones are, yet you're attacking them nonetheless. Discrepancies like this typically lead to wolves.

Do they?

If there really is ample reason to believe the wolves make these kinds of dumb mistakes, I'll lynch fulksy in a heartbeat despite the fact that I don't want to lynch an active nub this early

[fulksy]

sorry if these seem out of order people are replying faster then i can type.

I think my reasoning is perfectly rational...and its fairly simple. You want all the regs dead, so do the wolves. You have yet to try and dispute this.

i don't know how to say it any clearer, again obv all the wolves want good regs gone, so your saying that anyone who votes for a reg for any reason is most likely a wolf? wow this seems like an air tight defense for all the "good regs".

[fulksy]

It does seem like a weird coincidence that this nub happens upon only real good players, but do we have to assume he would even know that as a wolf? Seems like if he really is a nub, he would have had to ask the other wolves or they would have offered the thoughts on the players. Seems almost like that would be a really crappy strategy if fulksy was a wolf.


JKDS, at the expense of potentially, unwittingly defending a wolf, let me ask, why would fulksy be so vocal about the good players if he was a wolf? That strikes me as dumb, and I recall a whole bunch of people jumped down my throat in the last game when I made a similar dumb post about trying to find the specials

exactly what i posted, why would you think that i would pipe up to the wolves at all and why would i say

"hey guys, kill warpe etc whenever u can"

[fulksy]

sorry i post so much i keep pushing post premature, but you can't edit posts.

i'm sure non noob wolves would have a better idea of who to vote off then me.

[TLR]

I agree with JKDS on this one
resync carroters lynch fulksy

[fulksy]

well guess this comes with being a rookie, guess you finding out I'm a villager will give me a more credit next game, also when you find out I am a villager, give me a bit credit and at least look into JKDS/warpe. hopefully i will at least get a little satisfaction at saying i told you so. anyways if I'm out of here it was fun, look forward to next one, GG JKDS you owned me.

[fulksy]

i guess keeping you mouth shut is pretty good strategy

[fulksy]

Fact #3: With Keith and Rilla gone, there is one bigtime veteran in this game that's still alive: Warpe. If he is not eaten by the wolves tonight, I would say he's a wolf for sure. I suggest we start a Warpe lynch to see how the other wolves react, as it should tell the village a lot of information.

lynch Warpe

looking back lol, wolf ^^^^ hahah JK

[fulksy]

incase this helps the village out after my untimely death, this is part of the info i was going by. if keith and rilla were "bigtime vets" and by JKDs own account " if you want good regs dead, and so do the wolf= you must be a wolf" why would he be one of the first to jump on the Keith BW? since he is/was a "bigtime vet". wow lookin this over honestly how is his reasoning better then mine lol.

[fulksy]

Looked at the vote counts on my top 3 suspects (it's a good sign I'm not alone in smelling something fishy about them)

Warpe 3
JKDS 2
Boog 2

Maybe I should switch to Warpe, but Boog feels more sure.

JKDS, ^ wolf?

[Donachello]

Jesus this thread just exploded. This feels an awful lot like two villagers going at each other to be honest. I tend to agree with wuf that it wouldn't make a whole lot of sense for fulksy to suddenly pipe up when the game seems to be at a sort of standstill. As far as I can tell before this latest BW on him there wasn't really a leading candidate to be lynched and I would think that kind of benefits the wolves. Granted he is a nub and could certainly me making a pretty bad play because of that but I think even the newest wolves would be smart enough to figure out that openly pushing a stagnant situation screams suspicion.

It's interesting that JKDS is so adamant about getting fulksy lynched but I can also see this being chalked up as an attempt by a veteran villager trying to finally take the lead and get this game going.

I don't agree with lynching fulsky really and I still think that philly is the most suspicious atm due to his high activity so I think I'll keep my vote there in hopes of people changing theirs unless I see a real slip up by someone soon.

[fulksy]

well I'm sure who ever the wolves are there lovin this, pretty ez to just sit back while me and JKDS are rambling on. well hopefully the village will be able to decipher some info in this wall of posts for future lynches, well headin to bed soon, if i wake up, to a band of villagers at my door with torches and pitchforks, I'll go in peace, and when its revealed that i'm a villager ill take solace in at least hopefully providing the village with some suspects. well in a last ditch effort at self preservation I'm gonna Try and get a BW going for someone who's been pretty dead quite which who knows, seems like a wolfy thing to do, haha. Resind Warpe, Lynch Icanhastreetbet. He voted for JKDS as well so i guess whatever warped justification you had for me apply's to him as well. anyways take er' ez

[BooG690]

Five posts in a row = wolf.

Rescind whomever
Lynch fulksy

[philly and the phanatics]

meh thread explosion makes my head hurt and its really late (5 30 in morning)....

im sticking with JKDS as his case is as compelling as any of the day 2 lynches and he had been sort of laying low and then completely explodes when he gets bolded.

lynch fulksy (rescind SDM)

[wufwugy]

I like wuf's reasoning on philly, am just as curious about what yaawn is up too, and wish the seer would look up dan_roid because they got me confused.

What good would the seer looking up Dan or roid do? The best baddy cases for them are that they're Santy, and correct me if I'm wrong, Santy appears as a villager to a look up

[XTR1000]

yay not dead yet!

It´s gonna take some time for me to catch up with the thread. I can however assure you right away that lynching me will result in a dead villager. So far not really a helpful one, I give you that, so if you guys can draw very smart conclusions from my dead I will have no objections.

I´m gonna bold some name later, it´s probably gonna be warpe.

[StillDeadMoney]

Have been away a few days.

Today was an interesting day. I'm going to stick with my Warpe lynch for now...

But if fulksy is a villager, we will have a lot to go on for the next day for sure.

[Hoopy]

Hungover as hell but I'm going to try and post some of my thoughts on this game.

Firstly the fact that the village is so confused at this point leads me to think it's mainly villagers attacking one another hence all of the different bandwagons.

Looking back at the last few games most of the wolves have usually been quiet in the first 2-3 days. Maybe 1 wolf is being really active?

Anyway I've been trying to figure out who is a villager. Obviously I can be wrong but it's a way of trying to narrow things down.

Villagers
Carrotz
philly
Dan
TLR
Willbur
DTB
Don
Roid_Rage
wuf
fulksy

I swapped Don for BooG, not really sure if BOTH Roid and Dan should be on there. Fulksy seems like a very bad lynch imo, no wolf would defend themselves in that way.

Everyone else is unknown though some seem more suspicious than others.

Oh and I can´t fight the urge to lynch JV, the wolfiest of them all.

Don't know much about Philly except for last game. And during that he kept looking at me for no reason like he's doing with Warpe right now.

Good enough for me.

lynch philly

Random lynches from XTR and Gala on day 1 to avoid looking completely inactive, very Wolfy.

Lynch keith because he's so god damned confusing and I'm a villager who doesn't want to be confused.

Lynch JKDS, he's a wolf

Same stuff from yaawn, he started the Keith BW.

Also suspicious of bigred and kingnat for similar reasons as the above. Gator or JKDS would have been good recruits imo.

So top 3 wolf suspects are Gala, yaawn and XTR. I personally think XTR is very likely to be a wolf so lets lynch him.

[Carroters]

Okay fulsky's defence is a wolf like 10% of the time or less here imo.

Rescind Fulsky

Lynch BooG

I really wanna get this going. It's picked up no steam so far really. he fits the bill of being pretty quiet but not overly so and has been sort of side stepping the limelight like any wolf would. Yeah I still get a really wolfy vibe from him expiecally now he piles on this "4 posts in a row must be a wolf" not a direct quote obv but yeah this isn't even reasoning it's way more likely a wolf piling onto the wagon making light of nit with humor. BooG is usually fairly methodical as a villager and thinks things through before comitting, especially when there's this much info drifting about for him to work with (more than usual on day 2.)

I'd like to urge Roid Rage who was originally on this wagon with me to consider Fulsky's defecne and jump back on before it's too late. I'd also urge everyone else to consdier this fulsky shit is probably just stringing up a villager based on his defence posts (noob wolves don't level like this so quickly) Boog has a way higher chance of being a baddy.

[Carroters]

I'm certainly okay with a treebet wagon if this doesn't take off also.

[jackvance]

Fulksy seems like a typical villager to me, would make little sense if he was a wolf, not sure why everyone is on his case so much. There's a good chance some regs are wolves, especially now that a recruitment happened.

Gator and Boog are either not paying much attention, but this is how they act as wolves.

JKDS I am not sure,

If i have any 'trust me village' cards, id like to use one.

This reminded me of Gabe, he said something similar when he was a wolf.

I'm not sure who's in the lead now (fulksy?) but this stigma of not lynching regs has got to end, especially when they could very be wolves (through RNG, or recruited)

[jackvance]

Well let's just lynch boog, he's like a sure thing.

rescind Warpe

lynch boog

[jackvance]

So top 3 wolf suspects are Gala, yaawn and XTR. I personally think XTR is very likely to be a wolf so lets lynch him.

Gala and XTR are most likely disinterested (or busy) villagers. Yaawn i dunno.

[fulksy]

Rescind Icanhastreetbet, Lynch Boog

[fulksy]

meh thread explosion makes my head hurt and its really late (5 30 in morning)....

im sticking with JKDS as his case is as compelling as any of the day 2 lynches and he had been sort of laying low and then completely explodes when he gets bolded.

^^^ is that normal for a villager? I never even bolded his name, i said i was wary of him ooooooo, and then BOOM .

[Roid_Rage]

Fuuuuuuckkkk

I honestly don't know who to vote for now. I would like both BooG and fulsky dead.

BooG for reasons mentioned previously, and I think he makes a strong case for being Santa.

Fulsky because if we string him and he's a wolf, it lends some credit to my 'the wolves are noobs, not vets' theory and if he's a villager I can let that rest and we can go after BooG tomorrow.

I think I'll stick with fulsky for now, but if BooG picks up steam in the next couple hours I have no problem providing the swing vote.

[lolzzz_321]

tick tock

[lolzzz_321]

2 hours

[Hoopy]

XTR lynch isn't going anywhere and BooG seems like a better choice than fulksy.

rescind XTR
lynch BooG

[BooG690]

BooG is usually fairly methodical as a villager and thinks things through before comitting, especially when there's this much info drifting about for him to work with (more than usual on day 2.)

lolwat? The ONLY time you saw me as a villager was last game where I BARELY had any input. This is you becoming obsessed with me being a wolf as you do EVERY game. Again, BooG's Theorem: I ALWAYS look like a fucking wolf. Lynching me is lynching a villager, plain and simple.

As for fulksy's defense being one of a "villager" every time, I couldn't disagree more. My first game I was a wolf and I spazzed when I was only three votes deep (check out posts 72-89). Wolf spaz is actually more common than you think. A wolf overreacts when just a small amount of heat is put on them and can't stop coming up with a defense. The way I typed it out made it sound like a dumb reason to lynch anyone but there's NO reason for fulksy to spaz out like that as a villager. I'm PRETTY sure Dan spazzed out as well as a wolf in his first game as a wolf, but I may be wrong. It also helps that JKDS thinks he's a wolf and put his "trust me" card out there. JKDS wouldn't do that unless he had a good feeling about it and JKDS' feelings aren't usually far off.

I'm sticking with my fulksy vote. I can get on a Carroters bandwagon for the reasons I outlined earlier.