As andy-akb wrote, re-raise more, to $7, and in hand 2, call the push. Also, only widen your re-raise range against players that are at least slightly laggy pre-flop. I'd say PFR% over 7 at minimum. Then widen it more and more the laggier they are. Against someone who's raising 15%+ of hands pre-flop or more I'm re-raising TT+, AQ+, AJs+, occasionally something worse.