It's not easy to get an answer to that question is it?

That's why I went out and got both. And I use both. I use PO mainly for it's HUD capabilities and it's ability with the iPoker network.

Add PA-HUD to PT and you've probably got a better package (at about the same price). (I like the reports in PT, but a few filter things in PO2 I've not been able to do in PT).

But to my mind, supported sites is a big issue for beginners. I mean if you are at an iPoker or PokerRoom site, or Paradise; then AFAIK only one or other of the products will be able to help.