Once you completed from the SB I can see how you would have trouble with this hand. That was the biggest problem, and it could have turned out very well. Once he flat called your reraise it's hard to say how to play from there because he catches his King. Usually a push here will take the pot, and maybe even get you a call from AJ, or an overpair that hasn't tripped up.
So I dunno. I could very possibly play that like that.