Congratulations to the Shadow Faction of Metropolis

[bigred]

Congrats to Stacks, Lolz, Sasquach, Hoopy, and Supa. Even the wolves had themselves pegged for the loss after supa was lynched!

Metropolis Superlatives!!!!

MVP: Ugh? A village win would be given to one of Rilla, Wuf, and Ong or a three way tie. Although people were frustrated with Ong he generated a lot of discussion which I think contributed to finding 4/5 wolves. He also hid relatively well as the re-animator. I'll also be damned for giving it to Lolz for doing the bare minimum not to get mod killed. I'll let you guys vote on this one!

I accidentally the village Award: Bankitdrew

Mr. Clutch Award: DanAronG

Worst Seer Ever: Flomo

AARP Award: Gator!

Look Mah! I can bold letters Award: Wufwugy

The overlooked for next ww signup Award: Modkills!

Best Will Smith impersonation: Boost

Angry PM(s) Award: Rilla

[bigred]

So feedback, what did you guys like? What did you hate?

I'll start:

What I liked:

1) Conversation of the wordy three this game
2) Reading Page 20, seeing the BID rescind by Rilla, the follow up by stax and going:



3) Introducing story/role/game changes as a new concept in WW
4) Dynamic time limits

What I disliked:

1) Inactivity. There were a ton of mod kills and mod kill warnings. I'm not hosting another game until people convince me I should sign up as a mod. Not that I have to convince fringe people to sign up to play my modded game.
2) Introducing complex story/role/game changes without having roles reviewed for balance by a few third parties, confusing the shit out of people, making it far too long of a read, etc. It's a new concept and I should have done it very simply to avoid "rocking" the boat.
3) Modkill rules were FAR too lenient

[rong]

The annoying thing is there's a core bunch of us who get really involved and clearly enjoy the game and imo make it enjoyable. We just need a few more who are keen to play. Rounding up random extras is a path that leads to a somewhat frustrating game.

[bigred]

I was also going to introduce one final game change if JKDS hadn't been killed that night.

Basically, through some story line explanation, the village was going to discover that if it lynched an infected, there was a shockwave that would emanate down the infected chain with a 50% chance of remedying each infected player.

Example: Players 1,2,3,4, and 5 are infected and were infected in that order (1 is the source). If player 3 is lynched (noms and vig shots didn't have this power) there is a 50% chance of remedying 4 and 5.

This was going to be originally included in the day 3 role additions with a few different twists but I nixed it at the last minute for whatever reason.

[a500lbgorilla]

Angry PM(s) Award: Rilla

I suggested Warpe could be subbed out for fulksy since fulksy got left off the list and Warpe would never have posted. bigred liked the idea and ran it by the wolves who consulted this chart:

Is Warpe one of us?

No? "We don't like the idea."
Yes? "We love it."

They said no, another village mislynched tied up in a modkill.

[bigred]

BTW, wtf is with warpe not posting once? I even emailed him.

[bigred]

Twice

[bigred]

Let's move this convo back to game thread since we're all talking there...

http://www.flopturnriver.com/pokerfo...189887-21.html

[TLR]

Reposted from game thread:
Lets have some feedback about the new roles

my 2 cents

1. Reanimtor - the role by itself is great, I did not really like the spilt role of villagers who cant vote or talk, I think reanimated should have full villager capabilities, and wolves should be able to lynch them with X% of success. If we keep the idea of reanimated dying when the re-animator is dead then maybe they should be aware of who the reanimator is. I think that in the future we should use the reanimator role in a different mode, reanimator will start with no reanimations and will get 1 for each modkill, this will also offset the unpredicability of the modkills in the game
2. Source and infected - Given that the source died early I dont think we can really evaluate it, I personally dont like random effects in the game (villagers / wolves affected at random) as it really screws up strategy (for example with the source alive wolves cannot do any cooperative plans when they dont know if someone may be infected or get randomly infected in the future)

[TLR]

Metropolis Superlatives!!!!

MVP: Ugh? A village win would be given to one of Rilla, Wuf, and Ong or a three way tie. Although people were frustrated with Ong he generated a lot of discussion which I think contributed to finding 4/5 wolves. He also hid relatively well as the re-animator. I'll also be damned for giving it to Lolz for doing the bare minimum not to get mod killed. I'll let you guys vote on this one!

If the village has won Rilla would have been the MVP alongside Dan, LOL for MVP for Wuf for getting every one of the wolves wrong when he was alive, getting Gator nommed and totally getting the wolves gameplay wrong.
Since the wolves won the MVP is BID for snatching the wolves a victory from the jaws of defeat, although I think the wolves played a very decent game.

[TLR]

For next game we really should find a better solution for modkills, as it fucks up the village and the gameplay, one way is to use the reanimator has I have suggested earlier to compansate for it, another option is to have someone replace the inactive person in the same role. For example instead of modkilling Wrape on day 3 the mod would select any of the dead people and announce they are now replacing wrape in the game in the same role Wrape was in

[lolzzz_321]

any of the dead people? not a wolf or special

[TLR]

any of the dead people? not a wolf or special

It cannot be a wolf because he knows the other wolves, it can be a special as long as it is not the seer

[lolzzz_321]

ya