Werewolf: Star Wars

Just a reg villager guys, though I can see how I might look a bit Wolfy since my posts have been short + jumping on the Jeff BW quickly.

Originally Posted by JKDS

I want to lynch hoopy

We should totally kill this guy. I dont want to give reasoning this early in the game cuz it gives the wolves an advantage...so lets just go with Warpe and JKDS want him dead. Im not a seer and dont know for sure, but i think this is probably are best bet at this point.

If you don't give reasoning I can't really defend myself.

Total Votes:

boog 2
dan 1
hoopy 4
jackvance 1
jeff 3
keith 2
treebet 1

Player Votes

Willbur - boog
Boog - jeff
Hoopy - jeff
Avatar - treebet
Don -
Icanhastreebet - keith
Rilla - hoopy
Penny -
DanA - keith
Jeff - hoopy
XTR - jackvance
Keith - dan
JKDS - hoopy
Jackvance - jeff
Gator -
TLR -
Supahole -
Dr. Anger - boog
Bode -
Warpe - hoopy

Player in danger of modkill:

None

Can we lynch levelfish again to make him extra dead? Pretty please? No? Fine uh.. Hoopy lynch seems fine. I'd be interested to see what happened if people BW'd Penny after that mild overreaction post but whatevs.

lynch hoopy

if warpe say so lynch hoopey

I'm stickin with my high level BooG lynch.

So Hoopy wasn't really on my radar one bit and I was pretty much ready to post in defense for him...but looking back at his posts, there IS something quite fishy about him. also, as much as I don't like him, dwarfman makes a good point in saying that Penney's post is unnecessarilly and overly defensive. Penney, you were nowhere close to getting lynched, why the defense?

For the sake of the bandwagon and because JKDS & Warpe usually pwn, lynch Hoopy

Originally Posted by Imthenewfish

I'm a dbag who won't play in another ww if I do this again

edited by: King Awesome

So uhh yeah I spoke to newfish in IRC and apparently he didn't read the rules or anything before signing up. It's kinda my fault actually because he's been sweating me lately and I told him to check out some previous WW games to see if it was his thing, and to sign up if he thought it was. Turns out he skipped directly to step #2. Then disappeared for a week. NH newfish!

As for this hoopy business, it would be nonsensical for me to jump on this wagon based on the fact that he rescinded a vote against newfish, and I was one of the guys who wanted to avoid lynching him originally. He's a noob, sure, and he fits the criteria I laid out earlier, but I'm going to let this wagon pass me by. If he ends up being a wolf then I guess I'll look retarded but that's a risk I'm willing to take.

Going to go over the thread now and post who I'd like to lynch today and why.

Alright here's what I've got. In order to maximize our chances of lynching a wolf, while simultaneously minimizing our chances of lynching a potentially helpful end-game villager, I will use the following criteria for today's lynch:

- generally new to WW;
- has not posted much and is "laying low";
- was on the newfish wagon on day 1.

I feel like these criterion should go hand-in-hand since it would be more likely for a noob wolf to "lay low" and ensure his day 1 survival by getting on the newfish train.

Here are some of the notes I have up until this point:

Gatorjh: just posted once to lynch newfish


Bode: ditto


TLR: “If warpe say so then lynch hoopy”. Ok.


Jackvance: was in favour of letting newfish be modkilled, -EV for village (better to lynch inactives)


Boog: Aside from usual JKDS bickering, only posted once on day 1 to hop on newfish’s wagon, and once at the start of day 2 to get on dwarfman.


AvatarKava: Again, just seems to chime in with a lynch vote and not really contributing anything.


XTR1k: “lynching JV would be really cool. Like, u kno, cool and stuff.”

----

As for Warpe and Rilla, who have been acting similarly to those above, I feel like this is just par for the course of their early-game play.

Of the above, then, I like avatarkava as our lynch target for the day. He's done just enough to stay under the radar, is new to WW and was on the newfish wagon. Good enough for me on day 2.

lynch AvatarKava

I like i how i have enough cred that i can just attach warpes name to a wagon and get it going.

Anyone that voted for hoopy using warpe and my name, your on my shit list. I provided no reasoning other than warpe voted for him, and warpe only did so randomly. I wanna see some defense posts naow from the likes of rilla, tlr, boog, don, and jeff or we should just snap kill them all.

rescind hoopy

Not having any real understanding of the game I was gonna vote to lynch Jeff just to tie it up and make it interesting.Seeing some actual strategy kicking in I'll have to think on it a bit.

Originally Posted by DanAronG

Maybe a non posting noob? icanhastreebet pretty much ticks both boxes.

Wat I posted lots in the last game I played and I helped the village win the game so I pretty much tick neither box. Kthxbai

Yea it sure seems some people were keen to have someone to vote for without having to justify it. But how much of that is just not having a clue & liking the easy route of following the experienced players.

I have no real problem with lynching Hoopy, but he doesn't stand out as particularly wolfy to me, nor villagy though for that matter though. He is a noob at least.



But I think we have better things to go on. The two super defensive posts.


It seems to me both Keith & Penny were particularly defensive with no real heat on them. At least Penny had heat based on something, ie sealed the vig lynch, so at least he had some reason to defend, although the post was way ott.



But Keith's was out of nowhere, no real heat, noone except me even mentioning him. And me giving no real justification what so ever. He then went on to furiously defend himself & atack me. In fact, he is playing the same as he did last game as a wolf, which is defend himself and attack his accuser with a vengence.



And more importantly, when does Keith go off like that without a long assed list of logical (sometimes bullshit) thinking using posts over days, this was too early for a Keith attack if he isn't a wolf keen to get rid of me as he knows I'm gonna be desperate to catch him out if he is a wolf.



I think Keith is suspicious as hell, so I'm sticking with him, But both of these two seem better choices than Hoopy to me.

I'm not sure why you think my nomination of you is interesting btw keith, it's in the super early stages so it's still "basically" a crapshoot but since you decided to get VERY defensive with no real heat and just random lynch posts early in the game this gives me a better reason to stick with my lynch post.

Originally Posted by JKDS

I like i how i have enough cred that i can just attach warpes name to a wagon and get it going.

Anyone that voted for hoopy using warpe and my name, your on my shit list. I provided no reasoning other than warpe voted for him, and warpe only did so randomly. I wanna see some defense posts naow from the likes of rilla, tlr, boog, don, and jeff or we should just snap kill them all.

rescind hoopy

yawn, I've never heard of him and someone's going to die. I'd rather play with someone I've interacted with which is many people not named hoopydude.

Nice try though.

jeff was obviously motivated to A) not have people bandwagon him and B) let people know where the bandwagon was at: mainly not him.

TLR is shrug and Don is shrug because it was obvious that Warpe was saying nothing and you were just goofing around.

TLR, Don and Boog hit me like they just weren't reading or certainly not understanding what they were reading...

what... is up with you guys? I get a bandwagon is a bandwagon but they really seemed to be bandwagoning because they saw dwarfmang say it was a bandwagon... which is very disappointing.

Nope, I remember again why I thought there was nothing here. Firstly, because I was indicted. Secondly, because I'm pretty sure if Warpe came out and said, "for very important reasons, which I can't explain fully, I'm voting this way" people would follow so early in the game. If JKDS said it though, he'd probably get lynched.

Originally Posted by Penneywize

Of the above, then, I like avatarkava as our lynch target for the day. He's done just enough to stay under the radar, is new to WW and was on the newfish wagon. Good enough for me on day 2.

To Dan's point, I'm a bit n00bish and trying to learn, and from reading past WW's I think I've gained at least decent confidence in which people know what they're doing. Also, not having subscribed to the thread was a n00b move on my part. I think I can participate a bit more now.

rescind treebet

Gonna reread and post some more thoughts shortly.

Originally Posted by DanAronG

It seems to me both Keith & Penny were particularly defensive with no real heat on them. At least Penny had heat based on something, ie sealed the vig lynch, so at least he had some reason to defend, although the post was way ott.



But Keith's was out of nowhere, no real heat, noone except me even mentioning him. And me giving no real justification what so ever. He then went on to furiously defend himself & atack me. In fact, he is playing the same as he did last game as a wolf, which is defend himself and attack his accuser with a vengence.



And more importantly, when does Keith go off like that without a long assed list of logical (sometimes bullshit) thinking using posts over days, this was too early for a Keith attack if he isn't a wolf keen to get rid of me as he knows I'm gonna be desperate to catch him out if he is a wolf.



I think Keith is suspicious as hell, so I'm sticking with him, But both of these two seem better choices than Hoopy to me.

tl;dr Keith and Penney have exposed themselves as nervous and defensive. Let's narrow it down to them. Aim for Keith.

I've now gone a flurry of defensive posts too. Also, as I recall, Keith always likes to put 2 and 2 together when there are only 3 pieces on the board and you always like to get the horses behind your lynch Keith initiative.


I would stay those staying calm and staying within themselves are more threatening than those willing to give village-wide analysis. You, Keith and Penneywize seem to be the latter.

Okay, so this being my first WW game I'll openly admit that I really am at a loss about how the game goes about, especially in the early stages. That being said, I read the last WW thread and the beginning seemed to be a spree of semi-random lynches that narrowed the field of suspects down to some extent.

Early game, as others have stated, seems to be a crap shoot and though my initial inclination was to vote for Penney due to his overzealous defense but I figured that since he's already been kind of marked why not just vote on one of the people already voted for since no one else really stands out other than the on-going keith vs. dan war.

Originally Posted by DanAronG

It seems to me both Keith & Penny were particularly defensive with no real heat on them. At least Penny had heat based on something, ie sealed the vig lynch, so at least he had some reason to defend, although the post was way ott.

And who started the newfish lynch ...no doubt you'll be using that as well.

But Keith's was out of nowhere, no real heat, noone except me even mentioning him. And me giving no real justification what so ever. He then went on to furiously defend himself & atack me. In fact, he is playing the same as he did last game as a wolf, which is defend himself and attack his accuser with a vengence.

read back through all my games , I ALWAYS defend myself and like this game I'm usually a villager. Hence suspicious of people attacking me.Just as you always dramatise your statements with words like furiously and vengence.

And more importantly, when does Keith go off like that without a long assed list of logical (sometimes bullshit) thinking using posts over days, this was too early for a Keith attack if he isn't a wolf keen to get rid of me as he knows I'm gonna be desperate to catch him out if he is a wolf.

This is more about an ego thing for you trying to bring me down as you have admitted, and nothing to do with any evidence.

I think Keith is suspicious as hell, so I'm sticking with him, But both of these two seem better choices than Hoopy to me.

There are plenty of people still alive who have played as my co wolves in previous. They can confirm that a lot of strategy teamwork and planning went into targetting victims and steeriing the village towards lynching them.

Last game , the whole plan was made right at the start with wilbur sacrificing himself to give me cover in the endgame, to take out JKDS as a dangerous opponent in the process( the fact he was semi special role was a bonus).Wheres the teamwork this game?none from me , but Treebet and Dan seem to be working together targetting me. They even have posts hinting suspicion at each other with no bolding and then completely ignore each other again.

I am known to do a lot of research , and therefore dangerous to the wolf teams.Let one of the wolf teams eat me and you'll all see that I'm just an ordinary villager. When that happens look at the people who are trying to get me out of the game as the wolves will be there.

The dynamic in this game of two wolf teams means that even if i'm a wolf , the other wolf team has an incentive to kill me . I'm a threat to them ..so let the wolves take me out.

Originally Posted by JKDS

I like i how i have enough cred that i can just attach warpes name to a wagon and get it going.

Anyone that voted for hoopy using warpe and my name, your on my shit list. I provided no reasoning other than warpe voted for him, and warpe only did so randomly. I wanna see some defense posts naow from the likes of rilla, tlr, boog, don, and jeff or we should just snap kill them all.

rescind hoopy

I can't see the logic here tbh, and I don't see what exactly I, or anyone else who voted hoopy, has to 'defend'. At that stage, we were still at the stage where random lynchings were the order of the day (things do now seem to have got a little spicy though), so 'warpe voted for him' was literally a good enough reason as any.

Originally Posted by a500lbgorilla

jeff was obviously motivated to A) not have people bandwagon him and B) let people know where the bandwagon was at: mainly not him.

This was obv also the reason I tried to get some momentum behind hoopy when I saw the opportunity to. I, like everyone villager or not, do not want to be lynched this early!


But yeah, like I said, some interesting posts since then. I don't have a compelling enough reason to rescind my hoopy vote yet, but I hope there's a lot more dialogue between now and when I wake up in 8 hours time, as we can already get a few reads/suspiscions imo, which is cool.

Goodnight!

Originally Posted by a500lbgorilla

yawn, I've never heard of him and someone's going to die. I'd rather play with someone I've interacted with which is many people not named hoopydude.

Nice try though.

qft. lynch hoopdeedoop

Originally Posted by bode

qft. lynch hoopdeedoop

Meh I sort of expected this to happen since I'm new to WW, just a shame as you'll lose a reg villager who will contribute later on.

I'll keep my vote for Jeff but fwiw I could definitely switch to Boog or Bode in the future.

Originally Posted by UnbelievableJeff

This obv I villager not

Goodnight!

Reading between the lines.

Originally Posted by Penneywize

Jackvance: was in favour of letting newfish be modkilled, -EV for village (better to lynch inactives)

This is where you're wrong. Looking over my past WWs killing the inactives has netted zero wolves. They're usually just regular villagers who aren't very motivated because they didn't draw anything special. We only go after them as a meta-game strategy to get everyone to contribute. That is why it's better to let them get mod-killed now that we have that option and use our daily lynch on someone that actually has a better chance of being a wolf!

I'm in agreement with rilla here. Penney, Keith, and Dan always seem to post a lot, and Keith is pretty defensive to anyone coming at him at any point in the game. And Dan just so happens to go after Keith 99% of the time.

We need to focus on the people that are sitting in the background right now. Bode, Gator, Warpe, XTR, TLR, and Donachello are all pretty suspicious in my eyes. None have been very active (its still early so w/e) and Don is new, so maybe he's just afraid of posting too much.

But Warpe and Bode have posted twice in the entire thread I think. One of Warpe's was just a random 1st day one liner and the other was for a random lynch of Hoopy.

Bode's were both bandwagon lynches.

Rescind BooG

Lynch Bode

From playing with Keith as a wolf he can get up to some serious devious shit, so I wouldn't mind lynching him.

Gator as a wolf seemed to sit back and let the village level itself.

and hes been quiet so far.

so recind Boog , Lynch Gator

I'd happily lynch anyone on my list from earlier; I just singled out Avatarkava because he's a WW noob, and a noob wolf is more likely to be quiet than a vet (who might level and try to be extra active, etc). If there is support for a TLR, bode or XTR1k lynch I'd happily switch over. But for now I say we stick with the low-risk, high-reward choice of avatarkava.

If we're right, we hang a wolf; if we're wrong, we don't lose someone with the skills of say bode or warpe which would potentially come in handly later in the game.

This is more to my liking. Bode is imo pretty good at WW so I'd rather go for someone else, but for now.

rescind Jeff

lynch Bode

OK, let's see where this goes today. Still not massively compelled to vote for anyone, but I'm not sure a hoopy lynch is very proactive.

rescind hoopy

Ok I've reread the thread and feel that Bode is a better lynch than Jeff at this point, partly because I don't think Jeff would post "here comes the BW!" if he were a wolf.

rescind Jeff

lynch Bode

Meh... the only thing that rubs me the wrong way about this bode lynch is that it's pretty much right up his alley to play this way early in WW games. He's almost never an active contributor early on. Any other vets with me on this?

Based on this, I think I'm gonna go with my gut and stick with an Avatarkava lynch guys.

So, yeah, now I cross my fingers and hope that if the bode BW goes through, he turns out to be a villager LOL...

The last time I played werewolf here (years ago), bode eventually played a really active and helpful role as a villager. That's why I'm a little reluctant to lynch him at this early stage, just to see if his approach to this game does change at all, so we can get a better read there.

I agree with Penny.

I'm gonna recind a final time.

recind Gator

lynch Avatarkava

I just got back from Pennsylvania and have caught up on this thread.

JKDS, do you still feel I need to defend myself? Again, I didn't like the idea of JKDS just saying "Warpe and I say we lynch Hoopy so let's lynch Hoopy." I wanted to go back and see if Hoopy actually did something weird, so I did. In post 13, he votes to lynch newfish. In post 27, he rescinds. In post 30, he votes to lynch again. That in combination with the fact that he's a noob, we're in the early stage, and JKDS/Warpe wanted to lynch him (even though JKDS' vote was apparently some strategy in finding wolves) was enough for me to bold him.

Since when do we need reason and logic to lynch somebody in days 1 & 2?

Oh, hello page 2.

So wait, we're lynching Bode and Gator now because they aren't very active? Bode is never that active in the beginning. There's nothing to go on. Gator, on the other hand, is probably a better lynch. He is usually active and last time I remember him sitting back, Dan and him were wolves. I see no reason to lynch Avatar. Penney's list is pretty much retarded.

rescind Hoopy
Lynch Jeff

Again, this is simply based on principle. He shouldn't even be allowed back at FTR.

So the theory is that experienced players are quiet early on and shouldn't be lynched, but n00bs are quiet early on and should be lynched. Guess going back and reading through past games to try to get a feel for strategy is working against me in Penny's eyes. Don't waste time killing another villager who is willing to contribute once there's a bit more information available!

Reading Penny's original post about jack and then his defense doesn't make a lot of sense to me:

Originally Posted by jackvance

This is where you're wrong. Looking over my past WWs killing the inactives has netted zero wolves. They're usually just regular villagers who aren't very motivated because they didn't draw anything special. We only go after them as a meta-game strategy to get everyone to contribute. That is why it's better to let them get mod-killed now that we have that option and use our daily lynch on someone that actually has a better chance of being a wolf!

At the early stages, going after a modkill candidate is basically a freeroll - they're going to die anyway, and there's at least some nonzero chance that they're a wolf. Meanwhile, picking someone at random has a < 50% chance of success with the current group sizes.

Originally Posted by AvatarKava

So the theory is that experienced players are quiet early on and shouldn't be lynched, but n00bs are quiet early on and should be lynched. Guess going back and reading through past games to try to get a feel for strategy is working against me in Penny's eyes. Don't waste time killing another villager who is willing to contribute once there's a bit more information available!

Reading Penny's original post about jack and then his defense doesn't make a lot of sense to me:



At the early stages, going after a modkill candidate is basically a freeroll - they're going to die anyway, and there's at least some nonzero chance that they're a wolf. Meanwhile, picking someone at random has a < 50% chance of success with the current group sizes.

The question is always going to remain though AK - is it a coincidence that you start contributing when you're a target? That's something you're going to struggle to dispell for this round of voting.

I'm still undecided....

Originally Posted by UnbelievableJeff

The question is always going to remain though AK - is it a coincidence that you start contributing when you're a target? That's something you're going to struggle to dispell for this round of voting.

I'm still undecided....

Meh.

The first day was a random lynching and as a n00b I didn't have a lot to go on - was more busy trying to read old WW threads to figure out play styles, plus I didn't have the thread subbed yet. It's tough to contribute a heck of a lot when you don't know historical styles of play of everyone in the game.

I think it's std new WW player behavior to be defensive rather than wolfy/not wolfy ... "I waited forever to play and you guys are gonna randomly lynch me on day 2?? wtf?" This would be equally true if said new player were a villager, wolf or otherwise.

I just want to make this clear now so it gets some credit: I finally got a job and the company blocks all gambling related interwebs including FTR. Thats why I will be posting less than usual. Thanks for your attention, if you have further questions feel free to ask.

Iyam Gator can do more good for the village than he could do bad if he was a wolf. He´s also too good to reveal anything once he gets a couple of votes on him so lets leave him alone for now. Penney is up my list for getting very defensive on just a few votes. I dont trust the english so it´s lynch WillForce this round.

Oh and screw that "to lynch or not to lynch the vets" thing. Yes, some are much better at this game than others. They are however much better regardless of their role so right now when chances of any old vet being a villager are >50% its kinda -ev to lynch one of them.

Lynch boog.Cuz I don't wanna play w/ him anymore.

Well my plan to derail a random wagon to start a different random wagon and then rescind and go 'ha your a wolf' in an effort to get ppl discussing things instead of just going OMG LYNCH HIM seems to have succeeded.

I hate a jeff wagon as im pretty sure hes a villager at this point. Same with Keith and dan. Also i dont really see much coming from a JV wagon at this point. Im still speculating so these guys arent for sure villagers or anything...i just think its unlikely based on whats happening so far. Penneys in here too.

In all honesty hoopy did have a legit reason to get lynched as he was on the first two bandwagons that either succeeded or looked like they were going too. I like a Avatar lynch for similar reasoning.

I can easily get behind a lynch for anyone thats being overly quiet. People (especially vets) tha arent talking and telling you where they stand (even if theyre lying) arent revealing any information that the village can use to help themselves make better choices.

Current vote tally to help out br and the village at this point

avatar 2
jeff 1
bode 3
hoopy 5
keith 2
willur 1
dan 1
boog 1

ill go ahead and lynch avatar. hoopy didnt get much resistance other than me but i dont know how much thats gonna matter in this game since thered only be 2 wolves on his team helping him out.

Originally Posted by AvatarKava

Originally Posted by Penneywize
Of the above, then, I like avatarkava as our lynch target for the day. He's done just enough to stay under the radar, is new to WW and was on the newfish wagon. Good enough for me on day 2.

To Dan's point, I'm a bit n00bish and trying to learn, and from reading past WW's I think I've gained at least decent confidence in which people know what they're doing. Also, not having subscribed to the thread was a n00b move on my part. I think I can participate a bit more now.

rescind treebet

Gonna reread and post some more thoughts shortly.

Why is Avatar quoting penney and then saying Dan's point?

Bc I fail at multiquote obv

Well nothing much is taking off, but at least we've had a lot of posting from most players.

Still bugger all from Bode of Gator. Am I right in thinking Gator has only posted twice in the whole game? That's a bit slack. Trying not to leave a trail which will trip him up later?

As far as current bandwagons go, I have no problem with any noob, so Hoopy & AK, I'll bold either of you if you get a few more votes.

Originally Posted by AvatarKava

Bc I fail at multiquote obv

but it wasn't even a multiquote . So much logic fail here that I'm going to rescind Dan , lynch Avatar

It wasn't a multiquote because I didn't multiquote it when I was intending to.

How is that a logic fail?

Go ahead and lynch if that's enough for you guys. Was fun playing...

you were intending to address multiple points if you were intending to multiquote. Where are the follow up posts where you address those extra point that you were going to make?

Originally Posted by dranger7070

We need to focus on the people that are sitting in the background right now. Bode, Gator, Warpe, XTR, TLR, and Donachello are all pretty suspicious in my eyes. None have been very active (its still early so w/e) and Don is new, so maybe he's just afraid of posting too much.

But Warpe and Bode have posted twice in the entire thread I think. One of Warpe's was just a random 1st day one liner and the other was for a random lynch of Hoopy.

I'm lying low b/c I haven't had time to read the thread closely and, for some reason, people follow my lead a tad too much imo. I'll weigh in when I have something to contribute.

Originally Posted by Keith_MM

you were intending to address multiple points if you were intending to multiquote. Where are the follow up posts where you address those extra point that you were going to make?

One point, two posts.

One of the reasons Penny cited for me being in the crosshairs was jumping on the BW in the first vote. Dan had pointed out exactly why I would do such a thing:

Yea it sure seems some people were keen to have someone to vote for without having to justify it. But how much of that is just not having a clue & liking the easy route of following the experienced players.

Past that, I hopped on the treebet "wagon" (which never really got started) simply because there was little information to go on at that point and it seemed like we were headed for another random lynching. I've since rescinded because posting has picked up.

I'm just hoping I don't get lynched now because I've made a bunch of posts defending my use of bulletin board software

Total Votes:

boog 1
hoopy 5
jeff 1
keith 2
avatar 4
bode 3
willbur 1

Player Votes:

Willbur - avatar
Boog - jeff
Hoopy - bode
Avatar -
Don - hoopy
Icanhastreebet - keith
Rilla - hoopy
Penny - avatar
DanA - keith
Jeff -
XTR - willbur
Keith - avatar
JKDS - avatar
Jackvance - bode
Gator -
TLR - hoopy
Supahole - boog
Dr. Anger - bode
Bode - hoopy
Warpe - hoopy

Modkill List:

None

sorry for not participating as much as some of you, i've been busy and like warpe haven't really had time to follow that closely. I do think everyone is getting way too fired up for the 2nd day of the game. All of the accusation this early in the game can lead to one of 2 things: we either have some solid discussion to analyze once we are further into the game and know who a wolf or 2 is, or we have a clusterfuck of name calling and pointing fingers that just leads to more confusion down the road. more often than not its the latter.

i'll stick with my hoopy lynch because we have nothing to go off of and hes a noob that i've never heaerd of.

lynch hoopy

Anyone else I consider suspicious seems to be a reg so isn't "worth" lynching to the other regs.

Originally Posted by AvatarKava

lynch hoopy

Anyone else I consider suspicious seems to be a reg so isn't "worth" lynching to the other regs.

This post makes you seem a lot more Wolfy in my eyes.

lynch Avatar

A lot of the posts on this day so far are just noise imo. Its day 2 for christ sake, its so so difficult to be solidly pointing fingers at all atm. Although it is a good thing that we're getting this level of discussion even at this stage I guess - this will probably be a good game of werewolf when things get interesting.

Originally Posted by UnbelievableJeff

The question is always going to remain though AK - is it a coincidence that you start contributing when you're a target? That's something you're going to struggle to dispell for this round of voting.

I'm still undecided....

In terms of my vote, that's the best reason to vote for anyone I have at the moment. Its a bit thin-veiled, but starting to post when votes start piling up against you is as good a reason as any atm. Lynch AvatarKava

Avatar and Hoopy tied at 6 votes a piece

sorry I have been quiet guys but got absolutely slammed at work (7 hours of sleep over the last 2 days imo). I will catch up on the thread tonight and post again, but will then be quiet again through the weekend cuz I am off to my high school reunion.

Things will return to normal Sunday night though and I promise that my posting will pick up then.

read through a couple of things and honestly don't like either lynch going. Gonna look over some more stuff

I really haven't got this game worked out yet.This may be premature but reading through the thread I get the vibe that Hoopy and Jeff are in kahoots together.I know that they voted to lynch eachother but that could just be strategy.The fact that they rescinded eachother within 2 minutes kinda reinforces this.I'll wait a bit to rescind my last vote but I'm thinking that if we lynch Hoopy and find out he is a wolf than we have even more reason to suspect Jeff for the next lynching.

Originally Posted by supahaole

I really haven't got this game worked out yet.This may be premature but reading through the thread I get the vibe that Hoopy and Jeff are in kahoots together.I know that they voted to lynch eachother but that could just be strategy.The fact that they rescinded eachother within 2 minutes kinda reinforces this.I'll wait a bit to rescind my last vote but I'm thinking that if we lynch Hoopy and find out he is a wolf than we have even more reason to suspect Jeff for the next lynching.

Ok this doesn't really make sense if you think about it. If we were both wolves lynching each other would be terrible at this stage since I'm new to this game and Jeff seems to be disliked by several people for whatever reason (no offence intended). So it's highly likely a strong Bandwagon would form on one of us for the above reasons.

Plus for wolves this isn't the time for epic leveling or associating with others - their gonna sit back in the shadows with just enough posting to seem active.

have read enough to know that I want to lynch donachello (although I would miss seeing his avatar).

Originally Posted by supahaole

I really haven't got this game worked out yet.This may be premature but reading through the thread I get the vibe that Hoopy and Jeff are in kahoots together.I know that they voted to lynch eachother but that could just be strategy.The fact that they rescinded eachother within 2 minutes kinda reinforces this.I'll wait a bit to rescind my last vote but I'm thinking that if we lynch Hoopy and find out he is a wolf than we have even more reason to suspect Jeff for the next lynching.

Lol, I noticed this too. After we also just voted to lynch AK within 10 mins of each other, I'm basically fucked if hoopy is a wolf

For the record it's coincidence though.

Well it looks like it's coming down to either AK or Hoopy, (sadly there's not much happening with regard to keith, and a couple of regs have made positive comments about both Keith & Penny, so I think those bandwagons are dead before they started).

I'm inclined to prefer to lynch Hoop, firstly, I can abbrieviate Ak's name to AK, so saves for future typing, and secondly for the lynch newfish, rescind newfish, lynch newfish voting, which isn't the best reason to lynch someone, but seems as good as any.

So regretfully rescind Keith and instread lynch hoopy

Originally Posted by DanAronG

Well it looks like it's coming down to either AK or Hoopy, (sadly there's not much happening with regard to keith, and a couple of regs have made positive comments about both Keith & Penny, so I think those bandwagons are dead before they started).

I'm inclined to prefer to lynch Hoop, firstly, I can abbrieviate Ak's name to AK, so saves for future typing, and secondly for the lynch newfish, rescind newfish, lynch newfish voting, which isn't the best reason to lynch someone, but seems as good as any.

So regretfully rescind Keith and instread lynch hoopy

Sigh the only reason I vote/rescinded/re voted newfish was because we were at 9 votes and didn't want the BW to get to 11 without giving him the chance to say "OMG I iz da seer guyz" or whatever. Then JKDS said he hadn't been on FTR in 7 days, so he'd probably forgotten about the game and would be modkilled, better to lynch him then and pray he wasn't a special.

rescind hoopy
lynch donachello

1. Getting antsy being on the front train.
2. Don has 3 posts, 2 bandwagons and 1 "Noob here! I just read the last game" Who does homework for a game?

Originally Posted by a500lbgorilla

rescind hoopy
lynch donachello

1. Getting antsy being on the front train.
2. Don has 3 posts, 2 bandwagons and 1 "Noob here! I just read the last game" Who does homework for a game?

Yeah... DC hasn't exactly been rubbing me the right way either. He's pretty much shut up after putting in his BW vote in a perfunctory manner and seems to want to wait till teh day closes given that two bandwagons have taken off. Very much in the Avatarkava mold.

It definitely merits further consideration, but for now I'll stick with Avatar and hope the BW swings over in his direction because I still feel a noob playing the way he has would turn out to be a wolf more often than not.

Originally Posted by Penneywize

Yeah... DC hasn't exactly been rubbing me the right way either. He's pretty much shut up after putting in his BW vote in a perfunctory manner and seems to want to wait till teh day closes given that two bandwagons have taken off. Very much in the Avatarkava mold.

It definitely merits further consideration, but for now I'll stick with Avatar and hope the BW swings over in his direction because I still feel a noob playing the way he has would turn out to be a wolf more often than not.

Well I don't want to edit my post, so I'll just point out that by "in the avatarkava mold" I meant the whole 'putting in his BW vote in a perfunctory manner' and essentially laying low bit. Obviously DC does not have a bandwagon on him. Yet.

Hey guys, just wanted to throw my two cents in again.

@Penney and 'rilla. The main reason I haven't said much since I posted the hoopy lynch is essentially that I haven't seen much evidence to point towards anyone very clearly at this point. I thought about posting a rescind at first but seeing as how I don't really have any reads on anyone and in the interest of not being modkilled for not having a vote up I thought I might as well leave it as in until there is clear evidence pointing away from a hoopy lynch. Obviously, I can see how this can come off as wolfy since according to a lot of people the wolf M.O. is to lie low in the beginning.

That said, there also seem to be plenty of "vets" who have taken around the same line of action as myself. I guess trying to emulate experienced people kind of made me suspicious despite really having no idea what's going on :P

Originally Posted by Donachello

I haven't seen much evidence to point towards anyone very clearly at this point.

qft. Although thats kinda a given on day 2, would still expect more contribution from you.

Is this a record for longest day 2 ever?

Originally Posted by UnbelievableJeff

Is this a record for longest day 2 ever?

Not even close

Originally Posted by Penneywize

Not even close

yeah, there have been "days" that have lasted close to a week before the time limit was implemented.

It seems we've hit a stalemate. There doesn't seem to be anybody wanting to change votes. In the interest of getting the ball rolling again (and because he's only posted once):

Rescind whomever
lynch TLR

Originally Posted by BooG690

It seems we've hit a stalemate. There doesn't seem to be anybody wanting to change votes. In the interest of getting the ball rolling again (and because he's only posted once):

Rescind whomever
lynch TLR

God forbid you use your tie-breaking vote to push one of the two existing bandwagons forward boog. We have until 6PM tonight, there isn't even really time to get a new one started.

Not that I'm in love with TLR or anything.

I can happily switch to either TLR or donachello.