Quote Originally Posted by dalecooper
I'm fine with 1 but I think 2 is borderline. Technically your hand is stronger in the 2nd hand but the board is worse/may hit his range a little harder on average. I also think you get more calls by worse hands in the first one than the second, although both of these guys are probably capable of astonishing feats of derring-d'oh!.
i think this is well put and i dont know what else to add. im definitely happier betting the river in 1 than 2, but i still think donks like this look you up with worse.

i would probably leave out villains river action in both hands to encourage more discussion.