just because "most" of the players on the site play that way doesn't give you an excuse to call this. its an easy fold and a terribly hard call. so fold
Bair, thanks for your opinion--I'm gonna argue my point a bit more, but I don't want to come off like one of those people that post a HH asking for critques and then defend it to the death. However...

Isn't the fact that most players at whatever site/buyin level play a certain way, exactly the point? I mean, most winning players' games are modeled on assumptions based on countless iterations of certain hands. This is particularly true, I think, at specific buyin levels and sites--you get a feel for how the average player plays a hand and you play your hand accordingly, especially in situations like this, where you have little other info to work with. It seems like very strange logic to say that I should fold here in spite of what I feel most players would do.