A similar decision was presented to me playing $1/$2 NL at Foxwoods last night.

I was one of the larger stacks with about $400. I got AQo and raised to $10 from middle position (we were short-handed at this point). A tight player with a short stack ($65?) to my left raised to $20. A guy on the end raised all-in for about $80.

My read was that he was making a move, that he didn't have a very strong hand. But the tight player to my left did have a hand, so I folded.

Turns out the tight player had JJ and the other guy had ATs.

I was kicking myself when a Q fell on the flop. But I'm not sure if I would make this call, given the decision again. Maybe if it was suited?