Wait, does that mean you're thinking of penalizing jerks for being jerks?

I'm all for freedom of speech here. We're all grown ups who can decide to listen to whomever we like and ignore those who we don't like. People post hands and that means that person is opening themselves up to getting criticized and torn to shreds. That person shouldn't take anything personally regardless of how harsh the criticism might be, because it's not about his person, but his game.

Sure, some great players are crap teachers, but I'm sure we're grown up enough to figure out for ourselves what's constructive and useful to our game, and what is not. I vote no to coddling and over-moderating.

I'm curious to know what brought this about in the first place, d0zer?

Voted option 2 in case it's not obvious.