So far everybody in this thread has been right, except for Dana Rong, curiously

For the most part, she would be more attractive if she was thinner. But the way sexuality works, variety and freshness will sometimes make her physique more attractive than a thin counterpart. Also, there is something about her look in the first place. Maybe some of why we think thinner is so much better is social conditioning, and as somebody who fully understands that thinner is usually hotter, there is just something about a good chubby girl that can be amazingly bonerific

Most of the time, I'm more attracted to the standard hot just like everybody else, but man some plump women are just super special. And even if they could be arguably hotter if they were thinner, it feels wrong to ruin a good plump

Also, she's fatter than she looks. Her muscle is making her appear more fit than she is. Regardless, I would find much more enjoyment in banging her than 90% of skinny/hot chicks. Picturesque perfection is often less sexual than expected

Was browsing chubby porn. Most of it is gross, but some is great, and sometimes there are girls that make me go 'wtf that's not chubby at all'. These girls are simply not anorexic skinny, yet not fat in the slightest, and they're always so much hotter than the standard model look