|
|
 Originally Posted by d0zer
...and you're the one complaining about unrealism...
I'm not complaining about unrealism, but bad realism. The cult of realism isn't the only way to play, but TWD is attempting to have it both ways by trying to be both realist and fantastical in ways that don't work together.
This scene is a perfect example of merging realism and the fantastic because everything is embellished yet plausible
However, the TWD scene when 3dog was overwhelmed by zombies yet he fought his way out was an example of embellishment that had no plausibility. This all in a show that attempts high levels of plausibility. I agree with Boost that the show would benefit greatly by enhancing its fantastical elements, but it still has to do them plausibly according to what is palatable and the internal rules it creates. There are many ways to explain how Rambo pulls it off but TWD doesn't. One of them has been addressed ITT: Rambo is illustrated as an insanely talented badass, so it makes sense when he acts like one, but many TWD characters are portrayed as blundering idiots yet still get running headshots
As for my example of the dumb blonde, it's as plausible as the Walter White story. A transition from a high school cheerleader to a stone cold post-apoc survivor is on the level of an underachieving high school teacher turned meth lord supervillain
|
Reply With Quote