|
|
 Originally Posted by Renton
Let's just say that I am highly confident that [...]
I'm not questioning your confidence. I just want to see the data that led you to this confidence, so I can judge for myself.
Originally Posted by Renton
Most people in support of this tax would disagree.
What have I said that led you to think that I would agree with them?
OR
What does their opinion elucidate about my opinion?
I feel like you're attributing ideas to me based on stereotypes and not based on what I've said.
Case in point:
Originally Posted by Renton
Yes, you think everyone should be made to overpay for a service whether they want it or not.
What I said is that I like the service. I want the service provided efficiently.
Not for nothing, but it seems like you're trying to rattle me by putting the word "overpay" in there. I doubt you believe that is the language I would use to describe my position.
Originally Posted by Renton
You believe they are incapable of making the correct call. I guess I'm a little more optimistic about people.
Am I supposed to feel bad for being a bit cynical about people acting for their own long-term benefit?
:/
This is one of those things that I would buckle on if asked to provide data, so feel free to call me out on that. However, look around. With the tiniest preparation, most people could solve or avoid their own biggest problems. Yet they don't.
One the one hand, serves them right for failure to plan ahead. On the other hand, no one can foresee all the challenges that will crop up. I don't believe the system should ignore this human problem, nor should it cater to it. It needs to be a balance.
***
This discussion is so emotionally loaded.
I guess with the word sentiment in the thread's title, I should expect as much.
|
Reply With Quote