Quote Originally Posted by spoonitnow View Post
You're all wrong except !luck. It depends on way more than whether they're tight or loose. If it's a tight player who can't let go of TP+, then that's probably cool. If it's a loose player who fires three streets with any piece, then that's probably cool too. On the flip side, if it's any player who folds to much aggression postflop, then that's great as well.
Well that's not the question that was asked. Or at least that's not the way it was worded. The question was which would you rather be against a loose or a tight player when facing a Preflop raise. Nothing was said about post flop tendencies At least not in the actual question. Even when you include post flop tendencies i still say it's better to be up against a loose pf raiser. Simply because they are more likely to stack off post flop. Both extremes can be very profitable to play against though. in short i'm kinda agreeing with you about it being important how the villain plays postflop. Just not sure that vin wanted us to think about such things. It looks to me like he wanted us to consider the question in a vaccum.