I Think your biggest issue is POSITION dude. I wonder what your VP$IP% from Button down to the just after the blinds. It should go from big to small (like maybe 40 down to 5 in a nice steady trend)? If so then your OK. If not, this is your problem.

Poker is all about:
1. POSITION
2. POSITION
3. POSITION
4. SKILL
5. PLAYING THE PLAYER & NOT THE CARDS