Too tight. With the fact only three hands dominate you if you hit your flop, it's very bad. Just because he's a typical tag doesn't mean he's always going to raise you with the goods.

My question for you is, what hands do YOU call him with then? Are you willing to call him with a mid-high pocket such as 9-9, 10-10, JJ and then folding if an overcard hits because of your read as a tag?