Generally speaking you're going to pay off when you have an underset to an overset. They are really hard to see. In this particular hand, however, when you get into a re-re-reraise-push situation with that flop, I would have put the guy on a lucky flopped straight and slowed down.

You have to ask yourself why this guy is reraising. He either made the straight or has 2 pair. I never put someone on an overset unless there was alot of preflop raising and the flop comes with kq or something like that. Then you have to think "is the guy playing a big pocket pair".

Generally, though, on a 10nl table players only get really involved in raise-re-re-reraise situations with nut hands (or close to them). Otherwise they are either pushing (with a mistake or draw) or they are going to back down and start calling. There are exceptions, but generally speaking 10nl players are passive in the face of strong bets. when they get active you have to think they have something strong. Or they decided to bet it all on their drawing hand.