I'm trying to get several responses for this specific scenario to see what most players do in this situation. I didn't anticipate a myriad of concerns, but I understand your points - I'm sorry if I initially didn't cover all the bases. That's why I tried to address each of your concerns - not trying to get in argument. I'm still not sure if Full vs. Short and having one spade will drastically affect Hero's play here specifically. However, if it does then I'm very interested in hearing how the decision changes and why. But I'd like an honest answer about Hero's next move based on you sitting at the table in this situation. Preflop already happened. Villain is still unknown. Include AK and/or QQ at your leisure. Again, I'm trying to get a consensus on what people do here.