3.5K hands is nowhere near a big enough sample size to be meaningful. That said, instantly you're attempt to steal stat sticks out. I'd recommend opening more pots if it's folded to you in LP. Add hands gradually if you aren't used to playing less than premium hands (which is obv the case w/ a 14% AtS ), try opening more suited Aces and broadway combos, SCs if the blinds are tight etc. etc.

Oh and don't be worrying too much about your red line, you're up 10BIs in 3K hands!