This might be a stupid question

Originally Posted by Fnord

You fire up a NL100 table.

One player has a $110 stack
Another player has a $200 stack

Who is more likely to be a tight/solid winning player against most of the player pool?

I believe it's the bigger stack. In my experiences many players (especially tight ones) become even tighter after increasing their stack past 200BB. I also believe that big stacks hold a mental advantage, if nothing else, versus the rest of the table, which would make him/her a better candidate to be a winning player.