He c-bets more than I do!

This is why I don't like AF. It misses so much of the story. Best guess here is you have a guy who's learned to c-bet, also his nitty PFR suggests that he usually has a hand. Otherwise he's passive, straight-forward and misses value bets/stabs. Lots of guys like him play online 200NL (although they usually have a higher PFR.)