What he had in hand 1 would directly influence my decision for hand 2. Also, what did he do on the river when he called two streets with gutty+overcard? Did he bluff at it, check it down? And what did he have in the hand he called 3 barrels with? U should include this info!

Incidentally, if u have a read that he's a chaser u should bet turn harder in both hands. Pot bet both (+ flop in hand 2). I also wouldn't cbet hand 1.