The Matrix Werewolf - Game Thread

The Matrix Werewolf - Game thread

http://i.imgur.com/cp0Dd95.jpg?2

The Matrix theme is for flavor and is not necessarily indicative of roles.

This game is based off of the Pick Your Poison Open Game Setup. In it, the Wolves choose three roles out of five before the game begins to be given to the village. Here's the link on Mafia wiki.

The living:
a500lbgorilla
BankItDrew
baudib
BooG690
gabe
GatorJH
Hoopy
JKDS
MadMojoMonkey
OngBonga
philly and the phanatics
SuperMonkeyFace
wufwugy

Living roles:
7 vanilla villagers
3 Vanilla PRs
3 Vanilla Wolves

Rules:
- No editing posts.
- Wolves will have 24 hour chat which will start prior to the game for them to "pick their poison" for village PR roles.
- Village PR roles will only be mod revealed upon death.
- No night posting. At stated EOD, stop posting, even if I don't post that day has ended. SOD will be announced in the thread.
- Votes at :00 will be good and votes at :01 will not be counted.
- No discussing the game anywhere outside of this thread.
- Lynches and rescinds are submitted in bold, e.g., Lynch lilrascal.
- Days will last roughly 48 hours unless majority is reached. Nights are 24 hours. Days on weekends will be extended if requested.
- Night actions are submitted by PM to me. Wolves can submit night actions via the den if they wish.
- No posting in the game thread after death.
- If I've missed anything or you have any mod specific questions PM me, don't ask me in thread as it may be ignored.

All times mentioned are EST time.

DO NOT POST YET! PMs incoming...

Thread still closed

Notes:
1. No N0 actions other than "Pick Your Poison" selection by wolves.
2. All role PMs have been sent out. Please let me know if you didn't receive your role PM, or if you have any questions.
3. SOD will be 8AM on 23 November.

DO NOT POST YET!

Thread still closed

Additional Note:
1. Wolf NK is submitted by an individual wolf for the team. Therefore, it is trackable and/or blockable if those roles are in the game.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zE7PKRjrid4

DO NOT POST YET!

Day 1 ends 8 AM Wednesday EST.

Votes at :00 are good, votes at :01 are bad

IT IS DAY YOU MAY POST.

Sup. I'm a villager but not vanilla.

lynch boog

I took the red pill.

i took the blue one but it got caught in my throat and now I have a stiff neck....yay Viagra jokes and yay village!

I assume the blue one is rat posion, designed to punish faggots with no sense of adventure.

baudib is playing!

dude is wolfy already.

lynch baudib

If I were a wolf, I'd want to get rid of the tracker and the 1-shot cop.

I think we're likely to have inno child, vig and jailer.

Jailer is much more powerful in endgame, so if we have one, sit tight.

I got my favorite role.

rescind

Solid defence.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OngBonga

If I were a wolf, I'd want to get rid of the tracker and the 1-shot cop.

I think we're likely to have inno child, vig and jailer.

Jailer is much more powerful in endgame, so if we have one, sit tight.

---

I agree with this I think.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BankItDrew

Sup. I'm a villager but not vanilla.

lynch boog

---

Bolding someone as your first post? That's pretty wolfy. Therefore lynch JKDS.

Did you hear that a truckload of Viagra was hijacked yesterday?

Police are on the lookout for hardened criminals.

***
BID screwed up his impression of dhubs.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MadMojoMonkey

Did you hear that a truckload of Viagra was hijacked yesterday?

Police are on the lookout for hardened criminals.

***
BID screwed up his impression of dhubs.

---

Let me try this again... Ahem.

As some of you may be aware, this game includes vanilla villagers. Well, I happen to be one of them. Some players are wolves but I am a vanilla villager. I have not been a vanilla villager for many games now but I can assure you that this game, I am a vanilla villager.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BankItDrew

Sup. I'm a villager but not vanilla.

---

What is the point of saying this?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BooG690

Bolding someone as your first post? That's pretty wolfy. Therefore lynch JKDS.

---

Good to see all is well with the world!

I'm not vanilla, I'm vanilla.

I'll give drew a villager lean for that shambolic entrance.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OngBonga

I'm not vanilla, I'm vanilla.

I'll give drew a villager lean for that shambolic entrance.

---

Did you expect him to make a graceful entrance into any game? He leans wolf, if you ask me.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BooG690

Did you expect him to make a graceful entrance into any game? He leans wolf, if you ask me.

---

I didn't ask you.

And it's not about grace. It's about spazz. Why would a wolf soft claim special and then hard claim vanilla after two posts? There would be literally no point in doing so, and it can literally only happen if drew thinks to himself "I know I'll post something so fucking stupid and random that only boog will suspect me".

boog is wolfy already. That's makes him null.

Remember I owed drew after one post last game. Let's forget that I ended up leaning town with him while boog was alive, but I nailed him after one post last game, and I have done this game. Villager.

Sorry that's a lie. It's not one post this game, it took two.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OngBonga

And it's not about grace. It's about spazz. Why would a wolf soft claim special and then hard claim vanilla after two posts? There would be literally no point in doing so, and it can literally only happen if drew thinks to himself "I know I'll post something so fucking stupid and random that only boog will suspect me".

---

He redacted his first post only after being called out on it by MMM. Why not let BID defend his own post, Ong? It was an awkward entrance. He gets a wolf lean for it. There's a 0% chance I'm the only one that thought it was wolfy.

It's still too spazzy for a wolf, in my opinion. Even drew. You saw him last game, he's not bad at this game, he just has a weird style about him. Last game, as wolf, drew dived straight in, swinging for you after you took a swing at his wolfbro. Here, he's wolfy because he's spazzing a soft claim or some shit? I don't agree. I think it's villagery, because it's so loose.

Quote:

---

Why not let BID defend his own post, Ong?

---

And this, I mean cmon. There's literally one thing of interest to talk about, and I'm here. I'm not gonna sit here holding my dick waiting for drew. I wanna post and talk about stuff. I think his post is villagery, you think it's wolfy, so we discuss. That's what this game is all about.

Crappy time to start a game, but whatevs.

I agree with Ong on Drew. That would either be a very balsy play as a wolf (with the double post) or an epic mistake if the first post was a play that went wrong.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OngBonga

baudib is playing!

dude is wolfy already.

lynch baudib

---

I laughed when I read this because I always think his posts are wolfy, even though he has been villager like 90%of the time.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OngBonga

It's still too spazzy for a wolf, in my opinion. Even drew. You saw him last game, he's not bad at this game, he just has a weird style about him. Last game, as wolf, drew dived straight in, swinging for you after you took a swing at his wolfbro. Here, he's wolfy because he's spazzing a soft claim or some shit? I don't agree. I think it's villagery, because it's so loose.

---

So we're saying TWTBW or whatever that acronym is? Agree to disagree. I don't think the entrance itself is much of a big deal; I disagree with you saying it gives BID a villager lean. Wolfy if anything, maybe null, but not village.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OngBonga

And this, I mean cmon. There's literally one thing of interest to talk about, and I'm here. I'm not gonna sit here holding my dick waiting for drew. I wanna post and talk about stuff. I think his post is villagery, you think it's wolfy, so we discuss. That's what this game is all about.

---

I just don't want Drew to fall back on the "LOL I was being stupid and spazzy. Ong knows." defense.

^ this...i highly doubt he turns out to be a power role or a wolf, although i have never played with him before. It would be a pretty sick level.

my ^this was directed at ong lol

Gator always == wolf so theres one of the three in the bag

TWTBW is too wolfy, not too spazzy. spazzy does not equal wolfy.

wolfy implies an ulterior motive. If drew had just left it at the first post, he leaves all sorts of doors open from a wolf pov... he could be laying the foundations for a fakeclaim, or he can backtrack saying it was an attempt to get the nom. But to hardclaim vanilla next post, it implies he's not thinking about this from a wolfy pov.

The fact you're unable to see village hints when they smack you in the face, it has me thinking maybe you don't want to find reasons for people to be villager, especially those easy to push like drew.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by philly and the phanatics

Gator always == wolf so theres one of the three in the bag

---

gator hasn't been a wolf in forever, like probably since you last played.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OngBonga

And this, I mean cmon. There's literally one thing of interest to talk about, and I'm here. I'm not gonna sit here holding my dick waiting for drew. I wanna post and talk about stuff. I think his post is villagery, you think it's wolfy, so we discuss. That's what this game is all about.

---

This had me in stitches.

Fwiw, my first post was legit, my second post was not. I was just doing an impression of dhubs

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by philly and the phanatics

Gator always == wolf so theres one of the three in the bag

---

I am really digging my run of vanillager!!!

because BID has never, ever, spazzed something dumb as a wolf.

He wolfy

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BooG690

He redacted his first post only after being called out on it by MMM. Why not let BID defend his own post, Ong? It was an awkward entrance. He gets a wolf lean for it. There's a 0% chance I'm the only one that thought it was wolfy.

---

I was not meaning to "call him out." My intent vis-a-vis BID was just to lament the loss of dhubs, and note the subtle difference between BID's post and dhub's usual entrance to a game.

FWIW, I thought BID's first post was legit. It could be wolfy from someone else, and BID has shown growth as a player in the last few games, but I don't think it's what he's about as a wolf.

I think it's a terrible move if it gives the wolves real information w.r.t. special hunting. I think it's a terrible move if somehow the 3 specials are identified and BID is alive... as his lie is obv. at that point. Whatever his team, he's lynch bait at that point.

I wonder if BID pulled a double-ruse on us, but his later posts emphasizing that his first post is legit have me thinking that BID's first post is legit.

***
*secretly laces all of SMF's bamboo with Viagra and hallucinogenics*

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BankItDrew

This had me in stitches.

Fwiw, my first post was legit, my second post was not. I was just doing an impression of dhubs

---

I really can't see a wolf making this post. Not sure why the post at all, but it would be legit horrible if he did this as a wolf.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hoopy

What is the point of saying this?

---

Has the pot not been stirred?

The fact that I claimed a villager PR role and some players have me as a wolf, I have those players as wolfy. Wolves are the only ones who want villager PR players dead asap.

I caught boog already.

yea i can get with ong and BID on a boog lynch...seems as reasonable as an early day 1 target as we are going to get imo

still super early but still awaiting posts from :

rilla
wuf
gabe
SMF

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BankItDrew

The fact that I claimed a villager PR role and some players have me as a wolf, I have those players as wolfy. Wolves are the only ones who want villager PR players dead asap.

I caught boog already.

---

meh, boog tends to do that a lot. He is always tinfoiling these kinds of things so I have it more neutral than anything.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BankItDrew

The fact that I claimed a villager PR role and some players have me as a wolf, I have those players as wolfy. Wolves are the only ones who want villager PR players dead asap.

I caught boog already.

---

I thought your second post to be what screamed wolf, not your first. You're back in my villager pile, don't you worry.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BooG690

I thought your second post to be what screamed wolf, not your first. You're back in my villager pile, don't you worry.

---

You though I was worried about being in your wolf pile? You must think highly of yourself.

Gator was my #1 villager until he decided derailing the boog train was a good idea.

I hate getting nommed N1 50% of the time when I'm a villager so I'm gonna keep quiet for a while.

after being so unintentionally suspicious last game, im going to try and see how suspicious i can be intentionally, as a villager

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BankItDrew

I hate getting nommed N1 50% of the time when I'm a villager so I'm gonna keep quiet for a while.

---

Has this ever happened?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by a500lbgorilla

Has this ever happened?

---

Feels like it :(

Might just be paranoia.

BID, what are you doing?

My strongest village lean is Gator so far.

That's all I got.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by gabe

after being so unintentionally suspicious last game, im going to try and see how suspicious i can be intentionally, as a villager

---

Easily the wolfiest post ITT, so good start.

If this is your new meta, I'm not a fan.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MadMojoMonkey

Easily the wolfiest post ITT, so good start.

If this is your new meta, I'm not a fan.

---

Agreed, but bordering on TWTBAW

That post pinged me somewhat, but the more I looked at it, the nuller it became.

idk, I can see him saying that as either alignment.

I think MMM is wolfier off that exchange than Gabe. Thoughts?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by baudib

I think MMM is wolfier off that exchange than Gabe. Thoughts?

---

I agree with MMM. Gabe's post is the single wolfiest post so far. Another fluffy post by gabe (in addition to his fluffy first post last game).

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by baudib

I think MMM is wolfier off that exchange than Gabe. Thoughts?

---

idk, his post pretty much echoed my initial thought about gabe's post, only I thought about it longer and decided it wasn't worth commenting on because I could see him doing that as villager or wolf.

The only reason I have so far to suspect mojo is he isn't a villager read of mine already. But it's too early to consider that alone to be wolfy.

I hope rilla is a villager, because if so I don't need to bother trying to read baudib, I'll just leave him to rilla.

Rilla seems villagery so far. I like boog too

JKDS doesn't seem villagery yet.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MadMojoMonkey

Easily the wolfiest post ITT, so good start.

---

thanks. i'm sorry it has to be this way


fellow villagers, you will have to deal with suspecting me this game. the payoff will only come in the distant future when i'm actually a wolf. then you will be delighted at the village finally not winning. unfortunately you wont get such a surprised delight this game

I like Boog too.

im already loving this new persona. i'm like a trans villager. i identify as a wolf but i was born a villager. you can only lynch me if you think a wolf would try to fake this. i dont even have to help the village and im cleared

just realized there is a problem with this plan. there is mystery in this game about the roles where people might get paranoid that i'm some bs special role that tries to fuck with people. this is not the case for me. i'm only posting this way because of getting my wolf game torn down last game. im building a new foundation now

That's B.S. Gabe. This is why we have to lynch Ong every once in a while -- so wolves can't get away with being TWTBAW.

rilla seems like page 1 rilla. I'll start to believe anyone claiming to have a read on rilla by page 2 or 3. He usually can't make it to D2 without giving his wolfy self away.

boozh kinda the opposite of rilla... I mean, boozh usually seems totes wolfy to start the game, but by EOD1, he's shown his villager knees. Still, I agree that boozh seems villagery.

JKDS saying easy things to say.

ongie seems to be onging. I got nothing on him. I'll rely on BID to set me straight, though.

***
I think baudib's push against me lacks a sense of my history with gabe. I've been defending gabe on D1 for most of a year now. I also pride myself on being able to read him. If he (gabe) is going to go and change his meta, then that puts a wrench in my motor, and I don't like it. If he's gonna flip wolf twice in a row, then this is a nice way to open this game and he certainly knows it and would use it.

Mostly, though. This stated strategy of his doesn't seem like a good way to win if he's a villager, and it does seem like a good way to win if he's a wolf. If there's one thing about gabe, it's that he always plays to win. If he's going to start valuing meta over strategy, then I have every right to be suspicious of him being out of character - i.e. wolfy - especially until I'm proven wrong to be suspicious.

My most recent post was written and posted before I read the recent string of posts by gabe.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by gabe

thanks. i'm sorry it has to be this way

---

Until I see you flip villager I will not be confident saying:
"It's cool. You're my bro, and I support you even when you don't make sense to me."
(although that was my gut reaction.)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by gabe

fellow villagers, you will have to deal with suspecting me this game. the payoff will only come in the distant future when i'm actually a wolf. then you will be delighted at the village finally not winning. unfortunately you wont get such a surprised delight this game

---

So you're trading a ~70% winrate for a ~30% winrate (raw odds of flipping W in a game).
Winning as a wolf is worth the big monies, I guess.

That tone, though!

:puke: reading you just got even more complicated than it already was.

lynch Gabe

good.... good... let the suspicion flow through you

i almost accidentally submitted a defense, but then i realized i dont have to do that anymore

i identify as a transwolf

my motto is TWTBAW

i am NOT trying to kill villagers. i am still trying to kill wolves


carry on

man its been so long since ive played....i tried to read the game from 2 games ago (america vs russia) to get some reads but at page 8 it was still day 1, so i have taken a break for the time being to go and shoot myself in the face.

BID thinks that gator's "derail" of the boog momentum is wolfy, while baudib thinks it contributes to gator being villagery. In my opinion i tihnk that it leans towards villagery, given that one second he is defending BID, and then he defends the person who is "attacking" BID.

So far my only strong opinion is that baudib seems to have the most villagery tone and is doing things to move the discussion forward, although i have never played with him before.

MMM and baudib, i think you guys get it

the thing is, there are always more villagers than wolves. to make the most people happy, you should try and play ultra villager. most of the time, you are a villager, so always playing ultra villager gains you mucho win equity averaged across all the games. but like MMM pointed, winning as a wolf is worth the big monies. not all wins are equal

also its cool as a villager to test the boundaries of posting. its impossible to experiment as a wolf because of the word paranoia i get (and i assume others get). where every sentence you reread and go "shit are they going to see how plainly i'm a wolf?"

i'm freeing myself from that. or at least trying... god knows i couldnt type a post with this detail and tone as a wolf

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by philly and the phanatics

Gator always == wolf so theres one of the three in the bag

---

Glad to see you've not forgotten rule 1 of FTR werewolf.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BankItDrew

Has the pot not been stirred?

---

I suppose it has.