|
Originally Posted by wufwugy
The vig not shooting hurt the village since it gave the wolves a higher percentage of noms.
lol, we disagree
Originally Posted by wufwugy
Any time a seer can cinch it up on Day 4, it's very imba. The earliest the seer should be able to cinch is Day 7,
lol, we disagree again. e.g. in a thirteen player game with three wolves, where the seer looks up a wolf each of the first three nights the game is guaranteed imba?!?
Originally Posted by wufwugy
The only two things I did as a turncoat was get Ong killed and get myself looking like a villager, despite having tried to do a lot more. I probably hurt the wolves more than I helped due to inadvertently giving the Huber wagon steam.
you also fake-outed when you (i.e. the wolves) were still in with a chance. If you had survived the day and then ended up switching over then we would have had to start over to find the wolf.
Originally Posted by wufwugy
As a rule of thumb, anytime there are more specials than wolves, the game favors the village.
ong talks about the vig being viewed by many as a pro-wolf role. So depends on the specials i imagine.
Originally Posted by wufwugy
I think balancing this version would involve making the seer only work on the first two nights, there's no vig, and the turncoat is the traditional kind, where he and the wolves dont know who the other is, but if the wolves nom him, he becomes a wolf
results orientated. The fact that none of the seer's lookups got nommed or lynched is clouding your thinking. The fact that the vig didn't cause a village bloodbath too. The turncoat as setup in this game is an immensely powerful wolf in endgame. Turncoats role until late-game here should be to avoid being lynched or nommed, i was at least in part hoping for an endgame situation involving me, the wolf, and the un-converted turncoat. Cos then I would have had to fakeclaim as wolf to win the game for the village - that one messes with the head huh
but we disagree 100% on everything in werewolf strategy as far as i can tell - so, meh, cats can get relieved of their coats all kinda ways.
|