Select Page
Poker Forum
Over 1,291,000 Posts!
Poker ForumWerewolf Village

Werewolf Blank

Page 2 of 16 FirstFirst 123412 ... LastLast
Results 76 to 150 of 1188
  1. #76
    The wolves would take advantage of the momentum from last game to get BID picked off easily...it's certainly the strat I employ as a wolf (because lynching absent or useless villagers ((BID, I gather you're the latter)) is something that can look pretty villagery but at the same time furthers the numbers game) and BID is just as likely to be a special as anyone so hey, added bonus for them and I just like saying BID. BID. BID BID.

    What I'm saying is, not BID. Not BID now, anyway.

    lynch mattc16

    Dude got defensive to wuf's ldo joke. It's special related anxiety, imo.

    BID
  2. #77
    Quote Originally Posted by BennyLaRue View Post
    The wolves would take advantage of the momentum from last game to get BID picked off easily...it's certainly the strat I employ as a wolf (because lynching absent or useless villagers ((BID, I gather you're the latter)) is something that can look pretty villagery but at the same time furthers the numbers game) and BID is just as likely to be a special as anyone so hey, added bonus for them and I just like saying BID. BID. BID BID.

    What I'm saying is, not BID. Not BID now, anyway.

    lynch mattc16

    Dude got defensive to wuf's ldo joke. It's special related anxiety, imo.

    BID
    This state of mind is exactly why the village lost the last game, we let a useless villager (BID) hang on till end game and then at a crucial time he threw in a random vote without reading the thread and let the wolves jump on that and win the game when half the village figured out the real wolves. As the game progress we will have more info and real targets will emerge

    BID is an asset to the wolves as a villager so lynching him is a win win for the villager, the only problem is if he happens to be the bodyguard (if he is the seer dont expect any seer info in this game) so he is the natural choice.

    The only reason I can think that someone who read or partipated in the last game will even consider not voting BID is if BID is on his wolf team


  3. #78
    I understand he's not an asset to the village and shouldn't be around at end game, but why does he HAVE TO get lynched today? Doesn't the point about the wolves capitalizing on the BID momentum have merit?

    BID

    BTW, I only read enough of the last game to understand BID played like a retarded child in a fighter jet. If there's some particular nuance you're getting at, it's going to go over my head.

    BID BID
  4. #79
    Quote Originally Posted by BennyLaRue View Post
    I understand he's not an asset to the village and shouldn't be around at end game, but why does he HAVE TO get lynched today? Doesn't the point about the wolves capitalizing on the BID momentum have merit?
    Because he is the best target for today, you know how this game goes, tomorrow we will have more info and better targets then the village idiot

    The wolves might capatalize on that but having BID dead is beneficial for the village


  5. #80
    I'm gonna lol soooooooooooo hard if BID makes it to endgame again (and bolds boog ofc)
  6. #81
    JKDS's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Posts
    6,780
    Location
    Chandler, AZ
    I think we're all forgetting the real issue here.

    I have a cold. Colds suck, because boogers. Boogers is a nickname for Boog. Therefore lynch boog, or youre a blimey brit like ong.

    Ps <3 ong
  7. #82
    Quote Originally Posted by BankItDrew View Post
    A wolf wouldn't see the harm in keeping me around. I'm going to lynch you people.
    Comments like this make me think drew actually does have the capacity to think logically. He's right, wolves would want him around because of his performance last game.

    Cmon leave him, he's like as retarded as SDM but much funnier. If he's looking wolfy, then fair enough, but don't blame him for the village loss last game. It wasn't solely drew's fault that those who were left couldn't be bothered to piece it together, he's as gulity as everyone who was left for the village loss (rilla can obv be excused from blame). Drew is your scapegoat imo.

    @ vig - just a thought, but if you shoot lolz, wolves will think I'm vig and nom me. Do it...
    Quote Originally Posted by wufwugy View Post
    ongies gonna ong
  8. #83
    Quote Originally Posted by OngBonga View Post
    Comments like this make me think drew actually does have the capacity to think logically. He's right, wolves would want him around because of his performance last game.

    Cmon leave him, he's like as retarded as SDM but much funnier. If he's looking wolfy, then fair enough, but don't blame him for the village loss last game. It wasn't solely drew's fault that those who were left couldn't be bothered to piece it together, he's as gulity as everyone who was left for the village loss (rilla can obv be excused from blame). Drew is your scapegoat imo.

    @ vig - just a thought, but if you shoot lolz, wolves will think I'm vig and nom me. Do it...



    The last two wolves were on the chopping block, but that changed after BID started wigging out. He then became a must-lynch, which would have failed all if it wasn't for the timing of rilla's post. Then in our "second chance" scenario, the wolves were back on the chopping block, and all we had to do was make sure they weren't allowed to run a train on somebody. Enter BID jumping on any wagon, and thus all that needed to happen was for somebody to merely start the wrong wagon, then BID and both the wolves would finish it off
  9. #84
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Posts
    27
    Location
    Birmingham, UK
    Quote Originally Posted by BennyLaRue View Post
    The wolves would take advantage of the momentum from last game to get BID picked off easily...it's certainly the strat I employ as a wolf (because lynching absent or useless villagers ((BID, I gather you're the latter)) is something that can look pretty villagery but at the same time furthers the numbers game) and BID is just as likely to be a special as anyone so hey, added bonus for them and I just like saying BID. BID. BID BID.

    What I'm saying is, not BID. Not BID now, anyway.

    lynch mattc16

    Dude got defensive to wuf's ldo joke. It's special related anxiety, imo.

    BID
    i didnt see it as a ldo joke! not played with everyone enough to know when theyre joking
  10. #85
    Dranger voted for boog too on final day iirc. I should point out I am a little drunk and didn't really think through my last post thoroughly. I just find him amusing and lolz winning last game tilted me, also the fact that lolz knows it tilted me will make him even more smug, which in turn tilts me more, which in turn makes him more smug... I wanna see him die today goddamit.
    Quote Originally Posted by wufwugy View Post
    ongies gonna ong
  11. #86
    Day 1, we don't have any real data to inform our decisions, so our best bet is to lynch someone that is unlikely to provide any real value to the village. The new post-count rules may also affect our final vote, but only once the clock starts ticking so I'll ignore that for now.

    So who would be the low-value villagers?

    1) BID -- his existence on this list obvious and needs no explanation. He seems to be paying attention, however, so I wouldn't call him an automatic lynch. But he's definitely an early front-runner.

    2) mattc16 -- since he's a new player, I'm leaning towards letting him make it to day 2. As a new player last game, it was nice to at least be able to play 2 full days. However, this is conditional on him showing some interest in the game. So far, his posts have been pretty low-content, strategy-wise. However, he does seem to be paying attention, so we'll see what the rest of the day brings.

    3) Boog -- 2 posts, typical lynching of JKDS (zero value), but does agree that BID is a liability. Little value so far, maybe he'll post more when everyone is asleep (like last game?).

    4) lolzzz -- one post, all in caps, calling us "nignogs" (made me laugh a little), and then lynching a random player. No value yet. Plus, as a wolf last game he was very silent, which made him very difficult to find.


    Currently I favor:

    BID > lolzzz > boog > mattc16
  12. #87
    bigred's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Posts
    15,437
    Location
    Nest of Douchebags
    woooooo vacation and drinking!

    let's lynch lolz for the lols! plus he does nothing and is terrible at fifa
    LOL OPERATIONS
  13. #88
    bigred's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Posts
    15,437
    Location
    Nest of Douchebags
    I saw an eel eat a fish today. Owned in the face!
    LOL OPERATIONS
  14. #89
    How bigred thinks he plays Werewolf:



    How bigred really plays Werewolf:



    How good bigred thinks he is at finding wolves:



    How good bigred really is at finding wolves:

  15. #90
    here i am

    soulreading the wolves

    drunk as shit

    but still souldreading

    BID dana and bigred

    dont ask me why

    still lynching lolz cuz why the fuck not, that dicksuck deserves it. nigga said he didnt even know that hoopy was a wolf last time. lol like i didnt know tits are nice
  16. #91
    BankItDrew's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Posts
    8,291
    Location
    Losing Prop Bets
    ^^^^
    LOLOLOLOL

    Here's my history with this game:

    A long time ago I tried playing twice but didn't make it to day 3 in either attempt. It was one of those 'lynch the pointless new guy' sort of situations. It totally sucked and it turned me off of the game until this most recent one, when I decided to give it another chance.

    In the previous game, I wasn't expecting too much and thus didn't post for the first little bit, expecting to get lynched off. To my surprise, I lasted longer, and longer, and longer, to the point where I was like "woah I should totally start to contribute because my shit may start to have an impact!" And thus began the train-wreck that is my strategy. I posted more but I was still more concerned about lasting longer than winning the game, so I jumped on every new wagon that came along. This may have been the straw that broke the camels back in the end-game but come the fuck on people. I was one single piece of straw. It wasn't my sole responsibility for the loss. I am your scapegoat, I understand. It happened to Buckner and Bartman too.

    Although I have been preoccupied with other things over the last few days, I'm going to try and dedicate more time to this game so that I can not only last longer than a 40-year old virgin but also to help my team. The best way to do that is to provide as much analysis as possible so that I can prove to be an asset. So, here goes. P.S. Cut me some slack, this will be my first effort:


    lynch mattc16
    Last edited by BankItDrew; 03-21-2012 at 04:26 AM.
  17. #92
    BankItDrew's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Posts
    8,291
    Location
    Losing Prop Bets
    JK
    rescind mattc16

    rilla - thanks for taking the time to put this game together. I'm starting to love Werewolf almost as much as my gf. Your help as a villager will be missed.

    Myself - I stick to what I said about how it would make sense for the wolves to want to keep me (up until now). I was a pointless villager that was going to only fuck shit up for the village.

    In order of post count:

    JKDS -10
    A few of his posts have been content less and just silly, so don't let the post count sway too much of an impact at this point. I for one do not put too much stock in the post count as far as a 'tell' because different people have different lives and priorities. So far he has boog on the lynching block for no reason at all. It was his first post and early in the game, so ignore the lynch for now, it was probably just a joke for the luls. Boog's first two words are: "lynch jkds." How boog turns out may be helpful in prioritizing jkds later in the game. It's obvious though that he lynches low post players. Aside from the rhetoric, he's highly strategic and analytical as far as the math side of the game goes (yes, there is some numbers to this game, of which I haven't quite grasped yet).

    OngBonga -10
    Also highest post count but possibly the least productive as far as helping solve the puzzle. For no apparent reason, he jumped on wuf's lynch lolz wagon. This is either because he wants to live long or because he's on wuf's team and knows it, still too early to tell though. I must say that he is #1 on my list as far as defending me.

    TLR -8
    Also very strategic and understands the special roles well and the significance of their timing (this is by far my biggest flaw). He snap called on the lynch BID wagon which makes me think he's a villager. TLR, you're smart, but you lynched too early. A quote from him early on: "(cliff notes on BID play - dont read the thread, throw in random lynches and sometimes a post made up of random words)." This is your reason to lynch me. Take it back or else give the hammer to the wolves very early on. Due to >50% of your posts made reference to lynching me because I am a useless villager, I think you're a villager.

    BennyLaRue -7
    Half of his posts were pointless but the other half were very informative (I can't count). He seems to be on TLR's side of the game but on the other hand wants to keep me around for a bit while keeping me at the top of the lynching tree. I'm on the fence about him at this point.

    NightGizmo -7
    Also on the side of TLR. If my read of TLR is correct, Benny and night are villagers even more often. If I'm wrong, TLR is a sick wolf so far and is already building a nice wagon for himself. He's got the same thinking Benny does regarding a BID lynch too.

    wufwugy -7
    Has contributed little to this point but has been very lol. At the beginning of the game, when neither myself nor lolz had made a post yet, he states us as his top two lynching possibilities. He obviously sees me as a liability, like everyone else, and wants to lynch a player like lolz for no apparent reason other than for post count. It was too early to be making a lynch for this purpose because it was still the first page! Also, he strongly disagrees (as seen by the pear with teeth jpg) with Ong, while I strongly agree with Ong. Wuf, look at this game from the wolves perspective for a moment. If you were a wolf, wouldn't you want to keep me around before now?

    bigred -6
    Two posts with any content and 4 with zilch. The two posts that had anything on them were: don't lynch BID yet; and snap call on the lynch lolz bandwagon. So far, he's the wolfiest of any player I've analyzed.

    DanAronG -5
    Has contributed nothing other than a walk-thru strategy guide on how to be a special if he ever was one. He typed in such a way that leads me to believe he's not a special but only wishes he was one, just like everyone else.

    Hoopy -5
    After snap lynching me he says "Thinking about the lost wolf, the problem with him outing early is that we are essentially giving up a villager to the wolves for free." This sounds very villagery. Not too much content but seems to have a good idea going forward with what sort of route to take if he were a villager.

    flomo -5
    "lynch BID" are his first two words. Maybe the wolves see me as an easy nom off the get go. Maybe the villagers see a BID lynch as an elimination of a liability. I'm still leaning towards the latter as the stronger of the two. Then, after a good argument is put forth for my rescinding, he rescinds me and lynches boog, a second boog vote for zero reason other than post count.

    mattc16 -5
    New to the game but is already on TLR's side. The following sounds extremely villagery too "With regards to the lost wolf, do we know if the wolves have tried to kill them and has been converted (i.e the playerlist will show 4 wolves, not 3 wolves 1 lost wolf?) if so, they should not come out, as we will know if they have been converted, so easy lynch!!"

    BooG690 -2
    Boog took a while to get into the game (hasn't yet really but whatever). His first two words are "lynch JKDS." This is because JKDS voted for him. Also, he thinks of me as a liability and wants me out of here asap. I think this is a combination of reserving the right to nom an easy target and also nom a villager with a high post count who may be a very good asset in the future.

    lolzzz_321 -1
    Of all of the players, I thought hoopy was one of the few that stood out to me as a villager. lolz voted for hoopy and has contributed nothing else. I'm not going to jump on the lolz bandwagon yet though, there's just not enough evidence for it. If anything, there is evidence against it in the form of a lolz lynching wagon being created for no apparent reason very early on.

    cliffs:
    big red is the most suspicious and TLR is playing like rilla did last game.
    Last edited by BankItDrew; 03-21-2012 at 04:33 AM.
  18. #93
    BankItDrew's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Posts
    8,291
    Location
    Losing Prop Bets
    Also,

    rescind ong

    That was a premature ejaculation. I'm going to start trying as of now.
  19. #94
    JKDS's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Posts
    6,780
    Location
    Chandler, AZ
    I think the above, plus the fact that everyone was able to identify with near 100% accuracy BID's role last game, is enough to keep him around. If hes a villager, it should be clear as day...especially if he keeps this kind of posting up.

    Im fine with lynching lolz, just because hes not playing again. Honestly i think that fucked us more than anything bid/dranger did. I must have flipflopped on lolzzz a dozen times, and this game probably wont be any different.

    Sidenote instead of double post: Dont thank rilla! HE DIDNT EVEN POST AN INTRO!!!
  20. #95
    JKDS's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Posts
    6,780
    Location
    Chandler, AZ
    Im double posting anyway. Its what i do. So take that rilla and your post count rules!

    rescind boog, lynch lolzzz

    Im really hoping something super cool happens this game though, and we get a massive train on somebody...and then it just completely derails and a new one takes off with just as many votes. The end of day lynch is good rilla!
  21. #96
    Wow, BID is actually trying
    resync BID, lynch Lollzzzz


  22. #97
    BooG690's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2009
    Posts
    5,090
    Location
    I am Queens Blvd.
    TLR seems to be leading the pack early. He's posting very similarly to how he did last game where he was a villager. I feel comfortable with him leading us atm though I may get all scared at the idea of him being an epic wolf like I did with Rilla last game.

    Ong's a bit different this game as in he's not posting ultra-long babble. I don't know what to make of this, he's pretty useful.

    lolzzzz isn't posting...again. Being beat by players with low-post counts sucked last game. I want him dead.

    rescind JKDS
    lynch lolzzz
    That's how winners play; we convince the other guy he's making all the right moves.
  23. #98
    I'm happy to leave BID alive for a while if he keeps making good posts like that.

    rescind BankitDrew

    Lynching quiet people will almost never be bad for the village, look at last game where people were leveling themselves the first 4 days while the wolves (including me) stayed quiet. We need to get rid of them early on to keep the village healthy and functioning.

    Switching my vote to lolzzz, revenge time obv.

    lynch lolzzz_123
  24. #99
    Quote Originally Posted by BankItDrew View Post
    long thoughtful analysis
    Cool, you're trying this game! Nice analysis, I'm still unsure of your actual role (sudden changes of attitude / interest are suspicious) but for a day one lynch we have better targets.

    I'm liking a lolzzz lynch more and more as time goes on and he stays silent. He's playing the same way as last game (ie, unreadable) which hurts the village regardless of his role.

    lynch lolzzz_123
  25. #100
    The time stamp on drew's two posts are interesting... two minutes apart. There is no way he makes that second post in two minutes, so he had it ready to go when he posted the first. Seems odd, not least because he makes a vote in post one then rescinds it in post two. Now suddenly everyone wants to keep him.

    This lolz wagon is interesting, 5 votes in 5 posts from 5 people, I usually see wagons like this when we lynch an outed wolf. I think everyone but me is a wolf. Lynch everyone imo. Seriously, I doubt lolz is a wolf judging by how easy he is to wagon today, might actually find myself rescinding him if I can figure out a better target.
    Quote Originally Posted by wufwugy View Post
    ongies gonna ong
  26. #101
    a500lbgorilla's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Posts
    28,082
    Location
    himself fucker.
    I am going to try to keep the days about the same length, but they should be considered variable. I'll probably announce 24 hour clock tonight or tomorrow morning.
    <a href=http://i.imgur.com/kWiMIMW.png target=_blank>http://i.imgur.com/kWiMIMW.png</a>
  27. #102
    BankItDrew's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Posts
    8,291
    Location
    Losing Prop Bets
    Quote Originally Posted by OngBonga View Post
    The time stamp on drew's two posts are interesting... two minutes apart. There is no way he makes that second post in two minutes, so he had it ready to go when he posted the first. Seems odd, not least because he makes a vote in post one then rescinds it in post two. Now suddenly everyone wants to keep him.
    The rescinding and lynching of matt was a joke. I'm not going to get into the logic of my sense of humor. Obviously it wasn't funny nor noticeable so meh whatev.

    Easy explanation on the time stamp thing - It was originally one single post that I had been working on using notepad. Notepad made it easier to make notes while also scrolling through the thread in its entirety. I broke it up for three reasons: to make the lynch matt joke; to make it an easier read for other players by separating the historical explanation with the analysis; and to up my post count in case I get modkilled for whatever stupid reason.

    Quote Originally Posted by NightGizmo View Post
    Cool, you're trying this game! Nice analysis, I'm still unsure of your actual role (sudden changes of attitude / interest are suspicious)
    I was aware that this may have been a concern for other villagers but I can assure you it's because I want to have the satisfaction of nomming the shit out of the wolves this time around.
  28. #103
    rong's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Posts
    9,033
    Location
    behind you with an axe
    I just typed up a post about wanting bid to survive and wanting to lynch lolz but not wanting to because his waging had took off too quickly but I got a weird message from ftr telling me token had expired and I can't be bothered to retype with my reasoning.

    On a more positive note, its 1am, I'm sitting on my veranda drinking beer and its still warm outside. Fuck you England.
    I'm the king of bongo, baby I'm the king of bongo bong.
  29. #104
    rong's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Posts
    9,033
    Location
    behind you with an axe
    I don't get bids sense of humour.
    I'm the king of bongo, baby I'm the king of bongo bong.
  30. #105
    rong's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Posts
    9,033
    Location
    behind you with an axe
    I would still like lolz to die for being generally useless and usually not participating much. But due to Tue quick wagon, lynch Bigred for the same reasons. Plus he is also on holiday, which devalues my holiday as my main source of pleasure comes from knowing I am having a better time right now than you, and he makes it one less you.
    I'm the king of bongo, baby I'm the king of bongo bong.
  31. #106
    BankItDrew's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Posts
    8,291
    Location
    Losing Prop Bets
    I would think that the average wolf would increase their normal post count in this game because there are only three of them. If I had only two teammates, I'm sure as hell not sitting on the sidelines the entire time. Besides, players usually get lynched for not posting very much - even more incentive for one of the only three wolves to post more.

    lolz is neither a liability nor a threat at this point.

    lynch bigred for reasons explained earlier.
  32. #107
    rong's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Posts
    9,033
    Location
    behind you with an axe
    Quote Originally Posted by BankItDrew View Post
    The rescinding and lynching of matt was a joke. I'm not going to get into the logic of my sense of humor. Obviously it wasn't funny nor noticeable so meh whatev.

    Easy explanation on the time stamp thing - It was originally one single post that I had been working on using notepad. Notepad made it easier to make notes while also scrolling through the thread in its entirety. I broke it up for three reasons: to make the lynch matt joke; to make it an easier read for other players by separating the historical explanation with the analysis; and to up my post count in case I get modkilled for whatever stupid reason.


    I was aware that this may have been a concern for other villagers but I can assure you it's because I want to have the satisfaction of nomming the shit out of the wolves this time around.
    villagers don't nom.
    I'm the king of bongo, baby I'm the king of bongo bong.
  33. #108
    BankItDrew's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Posts
    8,291
    Location
    Losing Prop Bets
    Quote Originally Posted by DanAronG View Post
    villagers don't nom.
    more importantly, wolves don't get nommed
  34. #109
    Quote Originally Posted by OngBonga View Post
    This lolz wagon is interesting, 5 votes in 5 posts from 5 people, I usually see wagons like this when we lynch an outed wolf. I think everyone but me is a wolf. Lynch everyone imo. Seriously, I doubt lolz is a wolf judging by how easy he is to wagon today, might actually find myself rescinding him if I can figure out a better target.
    You're overthinking this Ong, wolves aren't going to be piling onto one wagon right now on day 1. They'll be dispersing into different wagons so it's tougher to find a pattern linking them later on.
  35. #110
    JKDS's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Posts
    6,780
    Location
    Chandler, AZ
    With only 3 wolves, i doubt their impact is even gonna be noticeable on wagons tbh.

    @BID: Its hard to say how often wolves are gonna post. Ppl hated how little the wolves posted last game because it wasnt fun,and ppl hated how much the villagers posted last game cuz of clutter. With the limits, id expect wolves to be posting just enough to not get votes though.

    Also i think BID is a villager. Mistakes like saying 'nom' instead of 'lynch' arent mistakes wolves make. Its too thoughtless.

    I dont get the bigred hate
  36. #111
    I didn't suggest seriously that those pushing for his lynch are wolves, but if he were a wolf, you'd expect wolves to try and get a different wagon running, for example, like last game where you voted for flomo and stacks for me when lolz was picking votes up on day one. There's no resistance here, everyone is happy to see lolz die. Thus he's unlikely to be a wolf.

    rescind lolzzz_321
    Quote Originally Posted by wufwugy View Post
    ongies gonna ong
  37. #112
    JKDS's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Posts
    6,780
    Location
    Chandler, AZ
    Ppl are lynching bigred, and 2-3 ppl have said things to the tune of rescinding. No majority lynches allow for this kind of thing from wolves, where they could all just wagon one of their own and then try and switch to someone else.

    I find it cool that most of this talk about not lynching lolz happened after rilla said the day was gonna end tomorrow.
  38. #113
    BankItDrew's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Posts
    8,291
    Location
    Losing Prop Bets
    Quote Originally Posted by JKDS View Post
    With only 3 wolves, i doubt their impact is even gonna be noticeable on wagons tbh.

    @BID: Its hard to say how often wolves are gonna post. Ppl hated how little the wolves posted last game because it wasnt fun,and ppl hated how much the villagers posted last game cuz of clutter. With the limits, id expect wolves to be posting just enough to not get votes though.

    I dont get the bigred hate
    Yeah, you might be right. Everyone plays differently in all of the different positions though, so it's still too early to make a decision based on this info just yet.

    My thoughts of bigred being a wolf are probably more to do with a lack of info overall in the village than it has to do with any suspicious activity by bigred. My vote was for him but I admit it's a light one.
  39. #114
    BankItDrew's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Posts
    8,291
    Location
    Losing Prop Bets
    Quote Originally Posted by JKDS View Post
    Ppl are lynching bigred, and 2-3 ppl have said things to the tune of rescinding. No majority lynches allow for this kind of thing from wolves, where they could all just wagon one of their own and then try and switch to someone else.

    I find it cool that most of this talk about not lynching lolz happened after rilla said the day was gonna end tomorrow.
    I think the wagon jumping has less to do with the rilla announcement and more to do with the idea that it just doesn't matter if we lynch him today or tomorrow.

    Your theory about the jumping is interesting though, with regards to the wolf strategy. If it turns out that lolz was a wolf and the new lynched victim is a villager - it may shed a lot of info.
  40. #115
    I hadn't noticed drew's post where he bolds bigred when I made my last post, I just saw the one of hoopy's and responded. So ok there is some resitance to the lolz wagon, in the form of drew and of course myself now. I'm not gonna cry if we lynch lolz today, it's just if he's obviously a villager then we shoulnd't. He's not obviously a villager yet though, so whatever. I'll decide who gets my vote when rilla sets a deadline.
    Quote Originally Posted by wufwugy View Post
    ongies gonna ong
  41. #116
    JKDS's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Posts
    6,780
    Location
    Chandler, AZ
    Ong you can do pretty much whatever the fuck you want at this point in the game. Same with Dan. Its pretty lol to attack either of you on day 1, and while you both could be wolves there no way in hell anyone is gonna lynch ya.
  42. #117
    BankItDrew's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Posts
    8,291
    Location
    Losing Prop Bets
    Will someone share with me their thoughts on the timing of a lynch? Ie. ong waiting till deadline to vote.

    My concern for waiting is:

    - bottleneck effect
    - shares less information
    - you may not get a vote in due to timing with other priorities irl

    my concern with voting early:

    - shares too much information (problem only if a wolf imo)
    - starts and stops pointless wagons
  43. #118
    a500lbgorilla's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Posts
    28,082
    Location
    himself fucker.
    In case it was unclear, you get a 24 hour warning. The warning hasn't been issued yet. I'll probably do it tonight or tomorrow morning at the latest.
    <a href=http://i.imgur.com/kWiMIMW.png target=_blank>http://i.imgur.com/kWiMIMW.png</a>
  44. #119
    bigred's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Posts
    15,437
    Location
    Nest of Douchebags
    Quote Originally Posted by JKDS View Post

    I dont get the bigred hate
    Hatters gonna hat!

    I'm a little torn by ong's post since he makes a good point about a villager being more likely to bandwagon so quickly. However, I don't see a villager lolz being more help and it's ever so dangerous to have him play like last game. I think day 1 still needs to be lynching a useless player and some general discussion. Hard to pick out a wolf this early.

    BID is acting super strange and I don't get it. I feel like I'm just looking back and forth in a car.
    LOL OPERATIONS
  45. #120
    bigred's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Posts
    15,437
    Location
    Nest of Douchebags
    Looking through thread, Benny, Flomo, and NightGizmo stick out as participating people who are contributing enough to be playing but nothing to stick out such as BID, jkds, ong, and dan. Wufwugy is saving up his posts no doubt.
    LOL OPERATIONS
  46. #121
    This is going to sound like a wolfy excuse, but Daylight Savings Time always makes me a zombie for a couple of weeks. I can barely read, let only piece together whatever the fuck that was that BID posted enough to react.
  47. #122
    a500lbgorilla's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Posts
    28,082
    Location
    himself fucker.
    Alright, boys and bigred

    6 votes for lolzzz_321(Hoopy, BooG690, JKDS, TLR, wufwugy, NightGizmo)
    2 votes for bigred (DanAronG, BankItDrew)
    1 votes for BooG690 (flomo)
    1 votes for Hoopy (lolzzz_321)
    1 votes for mattc16 (BennLaRue)
    3 votes for blank (bigred, mattc16, OngBonga)

    PM/email any corrections
    <a href=http://i.imgur.com/kWiMIMW.png target=_blank>http://i.imgur.com/kWiMIMW.png</a>
  48. #123
    If he's only posted once all game, then sure I want to lynch lolzzz. I just wish it wasn't so easy - lends credence to the idea he likely isn't a wolf.

    BooG, do something, please.
  49. #124
    JKDS's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Posts
    6,780
    Location
    Chandler, AZ
    The problem is that this is exactly how lolzzz played last game, and he turned up as a wolf.

    Also, lets lynch boog!
  50. #125
    bigred's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Posts
    15,437
    Location
    Nest of Douchebags
    Quote Originally Posted by a500lbgorilla View Post
    Alright, boys and bigred

    6 votes for lolzzz_321(Hoopy, BooG690, JKDS, TLR, wufwugy, NightGizmo)
    2 votes for bigred (DanAronG, BankItDrew)
    1 votes for BooG690 (flomo)
    1 votes for Hoopy (lolzzz_321)
    1 votes for mattc16 (BennLaRue)
    3 votes for blank (bigred, mattc16, OngBonga)

    PM/email any corrections

    Pretty sure I voted for lolz already but just to make sure, lynch lolz
    LOL OPERATIONS
  51. #126
    We should make two wagons on the possibility that lolz can get modkilled instead of lynched. I guarantee he doesn't even know that he has to post 5 times each day.

    I do think bigred is a wolf, and I'm somewhat solid on that (as solid as can come from a mere day 1), but I also don't wanna lynch him today since he never gets to play

    BID does look pretty villagery here. Ong's point about the post timing was expert, but it seems BID could explain that pretty easily. I've got flomo in my village camp, and don't wanna kill mattc right now. That then leaves me only one other person I want to lynch on day 1 (I'm mainly looking to weed out the low post counts), which is boog

    I would like some clarification from rilla on what it will take to get people modkilled, and what will happen WRT replacements. I'm hoping we can just skip a lolz lynch and have him modkilled. Regardless, he pretty much must die based on the way he's playing. If it's a modkill, great, if it's a lynch, so be it

    That said rescind lolzzz_321 lynch BooG690

    FYI, you guys need to use the full names. My guess is rilla will still count the non-full names, but he did say that he wouldn't, so it would be nice to not have a complete fuckup happen where he only counts the full names yet doesn't tell us during the day that he's sticking to that plan
  52. #127
    BooG690's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2009
    Posts
    5,090
    Location
    I am Queens Blvd.
    Quote Originally Posted by BennyLaRue View Post
    BooG, do something, please.
    I'm trying, sir. I post every single night I get in.

    Concerning BID, I like that he is now into WW. I no longer think he's a good lynch since:
    a) he'll actually be trying this time
    b) it'd be bad to turn him off of the game again.

    Quote Originally Posted by bigred View Post
    Looking through thread, Benny, Flomo, and NightGizmo stick out as participating people who are contributing enough to be playing but nothing to stick out such as BID, jkds, ong, and dan. Wufwugy is saving up his posts no doubt.
    I like this thinking a ton. I think hoopy sticks out more in terms of "just posting enough."


    Quote Originally Posted by wufwugy View Post
    FYI, you guys need to use the full names. My guess is rilla will still count the non-full names, but he did say that he wouldn't, so it would be nice to not have a complete fuckup happen where he only counts the full names yet doesn't tell us during the day that he's sticking to that plan
    I don't think we have to worry about it if rilla counted your vote here:
    Quote Originally Posted by a500lbgorilla View Post
    Alright, boys and bigred

    6 votes for lolzzz_321(Hoopy, BooG690, JKDS, TLR, wufwugy, NightGizmo)
    2 votes for bigred (DanAronG, BankItDrew)
    1 votes for BooG690 (flomo)
    1 votes for Hoopy (lolzzz_321)
    1 votes for mattc16 (BennLaRue)
    3 votes for blank (bigred, mattc16, OngBonga)

    PM/email any corrections
    It's nice to be safe...but it sounds like a pain.
    lynch lolzzz_321 just in case though
    That's how winners play; we convince the other guy he's making all the right moves.
  53. #128
    Quote Originally Posted by wufwugy View Post
    I do think bigred is a wolf, and I'm somewhat solid on that (as solid as can come from a mere day 1), but I also don't wanna lynch him today since he never gets to play
    I agree on that, actually. Instead of coy-on-vacation-not-really-giving-a-shit-bigred, we're getting on-vacation-trying-to-act-casual-but-not-pulling-it-off-naturally-bigred. He's way too invested for someone who should be secksing his lady right now. I hear what you're saying, that it's kind of a dick move to pick on the guy that always gets picked on, but this has been a robust Day 1. There's no shame.

    About lolzzz playing like this last game, did he not post at all in the face of potential modkill or was it more just lack of good content? Because he's in the former situation right now and generally that doesn't mean wolf, it means shitty villager.

    rescind mattc16, lynch bigred
  54. #129
    a500lbgorilla's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Posts
    28,082
    Location
    himself fucker.
    24 Hours Remaining. No one has over 25 posts today.
    <a href=http://i.imgur.com/kWiMIMW.png target=_blank>http://i.imgur.com/kWiMIMW.png</a>
  55. #130
    resync lolllz, lynch BigRed

    Agreed that BR is being even stranger then the regular weird bigred

    Lollzzz is a decent Vig shot BTW


  56. #131
    flomo's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Posts
    5,603
    Location
    mashing potatoes
    I'm all for a boog vs. bigred wagon battle.

    Those B's are bad.
  57. #132
    flomo's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Posts
    5,603
    Location
    mashing potatoes
    Rescind boog. Lynch BooG690
  58. #133
    a500lbgorilla's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Posts
    28,082
    Location
    himself fucker.
    Yeah, please post full names. I'm not going to screw anyone over for not doing it, but help a brother out and make it clear who you're going after.
    <a href=http://i.imgur.com/kWiMIMW.png target=_blank>http://i.imgur.com/kWiMIMW.png</a>
  59. #134
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Posts
    27
    Location
    Birmingham, UK
    If lolz has only posted once, hes gonna get 4 extra votes against him. This could be a problem when it comes to the end of the day, if we're not lynching lolz we need to make sure whoever is getting lynched has at least 5 more voted than lolz.

    Just a thought. Personally I like a lolz lynch, hes going to die one way or the other, better to lynch than wait for him to get modkilled, or let the vig shoot him.

    I'm not sure on bigred, does he usually play this way or is he a little quieter on day 1?

    I'm gonna throw out a lynch BooG690 for my vote today, how many times has he posted?
  60. #135
    On a usual Day 1, voting for non-contributors like lolzzz or BooG is a good approach. It has the potential to nab a low lying wolf at little risk to your core group of villagers and with such little info to go on, you really want to contain your risk. This game seems different though as we've had analysis (or attempts at it) from the get go. We have more to go on already than most games and I like a bigred lynch because it's not about doing something that has little risk but about something that takes advantage of that extra info and has a better chance of nabbing a wolf.
  61. #136
    Quote Originally Posted by a500lbgorilla View Post
    Yeah, please post full names. I'm not going to screw anyone over for not doing it, but help a brother out and make it clear who you're going after.
    Yeah, how's rilla supposed to know who you mean by wufBoonGredKDS16mo?

    Smarten up.
  62. #137
    a500lbgorilla's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Posts
    28,082
    Location
    himself fucker.
    Quote Originally Posted by BennyLaRue View Post
    Yeah, how's rilla supposed to know who you mean by wufBoonGredKDS16mo?

    Smarten up.
    All undecipherable lynches now count against BennyLaRue.
    <a href=http://i.imgur.com/kWiMIMW.png target=_blank>http://i.imgur.com/kWiMIMW.png</a>
  63. #138
    Quote Originally Posted by BennyLaRue View Post
    On a usual Day 1, voting for non-contributors like lolzzz or BooG is a good approach.
    I don't think it's fair to put boog in the non-contributors group. He's putting time in when he can, much like last game. If only everyone wasn't so paranoid of him, you might realise he actually helped the village last game, he was always on lolz's case, it was just unfortunate he couldn't participate as much as he and the village would like. But he's not a non-contributor, I think that's being unfair to him. He's not a liability as far as I'm concerend, where lolz is.

    Not sure about bigred, I'd rather see lolz die, so I'll get back on that one now a deadline is set and I have no better lynch.

    lynch lolzzz_321
    Quote Originally Posted by wufwugy View Post
    ongies gonna ong
  64. #139
    Quote Originally Posted by OngBonga View Post
    I don't think it's fair to put boog in the non-contributors group.
    Just going by simple post count here.
  65. #140
    Quote Originally Posted by BennyLaRue View Post
    Just going by simple post count here.
    Fair enough, but even with a low post count boog has useful input, he does make the effort and as such is better kept than other targets, such as one-post-lolz. If lolz is intent on playing the same game he played last game, then he's gonna be easy for wolves to wagon later when it matters, because he'll get extra votes for not posting. Everyone else seems to show they are aware of the post count rules and are doing what's needed to avoid picking up unneccesary votes, but lolz doesn't care, so he's an easy target today. He plays like this as a wolf, so it's a no brainer imo. Boog will at least post his thoughts, even if he's finding it hard to engage directly with people due to his time zone.

    If people have reason to think boog is a wolf, then go right ahead and lynch him, but don't pick him off as an easy day one pick based on his contribution, that I don't think is fair on him. That's my position on boog, anyway.
    Quote Originally Posted by wufwugy View Post
    ongies gonna ong
  66. #141
    bigred's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Posts
    15,437
    Location
    Nest of Douchebags
    Quote Originally Posted by wufwugy View Post
    We should make two wagons on the possibility that lolz can get modkilled instead of lynched. I guarantee he doesn't even know that he has to post 5 times each day.

    I do think bigred is a wolf, and I'm somewhat solid on that (as solid as can come from a mere day 1), but I also don't wanna lynch him today since he never gets to play

    BID does look pretty villagery here. Ong's point about the post timing was expert, but it seems BID could explain that pretty easily. I've got flomo in my village camp, and don't wanna kill mattc right now. That then leaves me only one other person I want to lynch on day 1 (I'm mainly looking to weed out the low post counts), which is boog

    I would like some clarification from rilla on what it will take to get people modkilled, and what will happen WRT replacements. I'm hoping we can just skip a lolz lynch and have him modkilled. Regardless, he pretty much must die based on the way he's playing. If it's a modkill, great, if it's a lynch, so be it

    That said rescind lolzzz_321 lynch BooG690

    FYI, you guys need to use the full names. My guess is rilla will still count the non-full names, but he did say that he wouldn't, so it would be nice to not have a complete fuckup happen where he only counts the full names yet doesn't tell us during the day that he's sticking to that plan


    I must say your early game soul reads are about as bad as your late game soul reads are good (observations from my modding sessions). Too bad gator isn't playing this game so my usual "I'm always looking suspicious or weird" argument will fall on deaf ears.

    A little odd that Benny and TLR are also coming after me. I did label Benny as an early non-contributor to which he quickly refuted and is possibly now coming after me in the standard revenge line. As for TLR, no idea. You say you want to lynch me and lolz makes a good vig shot, why?
    LOL OPERATIONS
  67. #142
    bigred's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Posts
    15,437
    Location
    Nest of Douchebags
    Do we have a recent vote count? I could switch to Boog simply for the lolz (pun intended!).

    Doing a night dive tonight and then I'll be back.
    LOL OPERATIONS
  68. #143
    rong's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Posts
    9,033
    Location
    behind you with an axe
    I could live with either lolz or Bigred. But Im more inclined to say lolz now due to the ease of a bw later on due to the extra votes he'll automatically hey.

    rescind Bigred, lynch lolz_321
    I'm the king of bongo, baby I'm the king of bongo bong.
  69. #144
    lolzzz_321's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2004
    Posts
    7,476
    Location
    My ice is polarized
    anyone who is still band waggoning on me is more likely to be a wolf
  70. #145
    Quote Originally Posted by lolzzz_321 View Post
    anyone who is still band waggoning on me is more likely to be a wolf
    Awesome defence, I'd better rescind then so I don't look wolfy. Do you realise you have more votes than there are wolves?
    Quote Originally Posted by wufwugy View Post
    ongies gonna ong
  71. #146
    lolzzz_321's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2004
    Posts
    7,476
    Location
    My ice is polarized
    wat

    When I die, take a look at mid to late bandwaggoners like hoopy and night gizmo.
  72. #147
    If you die a villager lolz, I'm looking at bigred and boog, and those who tried to go for you instead of those. Yeah hoopy and gizmo fit that bill, dan too, people should also look at me if you're a villager. You're an easy target today, so there's going to be wolves on your wagon if you're not a wolf, that goes without saying.
    Quote Originally Posted by wufwugy View Post
    ongies gonna ong
  73. #148
    Quote Originally Posted by lolzzz_321 View Post
    When I die, take a look at mid to late bandwaggoners like hoopy and night gizmo.
    Umm... I had you as my second favorite lynch early on behind BID, and you moved to the top after BID made a good defense post. You still haven't given me a good reason to change my vote, so far your posts have been pretty empty of value. Antagonizing those already on your wagon isn't a great way to get them to change their vote.

    To make it clear why I'm not changing my vote yet -- both boog and bigred have posted more than you and provided more value to the village.
  74. #149
    Quote Originally Posted by DanAronG View Post
    I could live with either lolz or Bigred. But Im more inclined to say lolz now due to the ease of a bw later on due to the extra votes he'll automatically hey.
    At first I was all, "OMG, brilliant" but the more I ruminate, the more I think that's probably not really a factor. The wolves can't gang rush in a timed game so it will be more about us making sure that we spread the votes around. If someone gets lynched and is a wolf, it becomes more likely the remaining wolves were not part of the lynch. If someone gets lynched and is a villager, it becomes more likely the wolves were part of the lynch.

    If we all gang up on one player, the easier it will be for the wolves to hide.
  75. #150
    lolzzz_321's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2004
    Posts
    7,476
    Location
    My ice is polarized
    Damn, you got here pretty quick to defend yourself. Here is my defense - I'm a villager. Sorry if you feel antagonized. It's just a fact you're going to find wolves bandwaggoning the primary lynchee; even if those wolves give a reason for lynching.

    Also, BID is playing way too hard to be a villager. TBH, I think he finally got a PM that said I'm a wolf. You should probably keep him around though because he is contributing.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •