|
Originally Posted by JKDS
Rascal, I feel like you're holding a grudge for when I voted to kill you as loki. Regardless, you should not be voting for people just because you disagree with their arguments. The essential question, and this goes for MMM as well, is whether a person's actions are role-indicative.
MMM is an emotional person. Any case against him is sure to generate an emotional response, and the more pressure there is the greater the response. Emotions are typically hard to fake, and can be indicative of villageryness. But MMM is an intelligent, and arrogant, person as well; so I found it fishy when he responded with "i dont remember that" and "your twisting my intent" even though I did not do so. Add in the fact that he found people voting for him wolfy and people defending him villagery, and we have a bunch of posts that dont feel genuine.
But, I remembered that he actually does this as a villager too. I remember one game where he attacked me for attacking him (the game he self-lynched). I remember another where he started day1 intentionally silly as opposed to his normal style. Both games he was a villager. So these ingenuine actions are not role-indicative for him, even though he should know better.
Just like fence-sitting is not role-indicative for you. (That same loki game).
I dont have MMM as a villager. I dont have him as a wolf. The fact is that he hasnt demonstrated that he is obv-villager like he has in previous games, so I'm hesitant to give him any villager credit.
First off, I don't hold grudges; life is too short for that. This is a game and I try to have fun and win. So, no I'm not voting for you for grudge reasons. From my perspective it looked like you were trying to fabricate a reason to vote someone, which is wolfy. If there would have been some substance to your case, then I would have found it villagery.
I may be wrong about you, but I don't play the meta game that you play. I used to do that to some extent and people were able to abuse that, so I read every player based on the individual game.
Actually, the only person that stands out for me from the Vikings game when I got lynched after I hard claimed Angel is Wuf becuase he was so vocal about lynching me. In that game, I did have it right in that Gabe was the last wolf and the village did win that game.
I also find it funny that you said "fence-sitting is not role-indicative for you". I've only been villa on this forum, so you haven't seen me play as a wolf.
|