Ok Carroters first off, i'm not sure who you think i am, but i can assure you i'm not. Benny with a picture like that it's hard to argue, i like it. But all i can say for now is lynching me would be a waste. I'm sticking to my guns!
Lawyer TLR
Printable View
Ok Carroters first off, i'm not sure who you think i am, but i can assure you i'm not. Benny with a picture like that it's hard to argue, i like it. But all i can say for now is lynching me would be a waste. I'm sticking to my guns!
Lawyer TLR
lawyer SDM
Just for the cats, bah.
Ohh and the reason i disappeared is so i could stay in bed all day and miss the royal wedding. :)
Well this is a weird game. My plan for first day is to just wait and see who gets a train run on them, because that person is never a wolf. Just look at two games previous, I said there was no chance Keith and Dan were wolves because their wagons went crazy, and you will simply not find that happening to a wolf. The closest that will happen is like in the same game when Roid's wagon went to the tipping point early on but kinda died off gradually, and he was a wolf. But none of this is happening this game
After last game I refuse to let people skate by to the point that the remaining villagers don't care enough to find the remaining wolves. Compound that with I believe everything else I said about that stuff in last game, and the only people I want to lynch in the early game are the low content players. People like JV and TLR are always low content at first, but they get a pass in the early game because I know they pay attention, plus I don't believe in lynching good players until later anyways.
So my question is: who's skating by? Right now it's mainly, Roid, fulksy, DTB, Labour, flomo, and SDM
(as I type this up I see Labour actually do something, so I'll take him off the list)
Roid ain't doing shit. He didn't do shit last game either, until we attacked him. I don't like how somebody of Roid's quality is playing like this. It's easy to skate by as a wolf, and low/crappy content regulars are so often wolves
Fulksy ain't doing shit either. He shows up right after he's called out, yet doesn't seem to take the time to provide some input. He could be a wolf but in his nubness doesn't know what to do and is trying to work with advice from other wolves, or if he's a villager with this approach to the game he won't provide much value in late game (which is why we lost last time)
DTB went after the easiest choice ever in SDM early, and has been no content since. This normally fits my bill for wolf, but the last time he was a wolf he was actually very active
Flomo is fucking Flomo. I like flomo but he always just skates on by, and I don't think he provides much value at all. He's shown that he's a very dangerous wolf because the only time he dies is when the village wonders why he hasn't done anything
SDM is being dumb, but I have a hard time gatting him on the first day because it always seems like a grudge kill, and I generally feel like I gotta stick up for him, plus I kinda like him even though he can do things lolbad
So I'm having a tough time picking between these guys, but they need to go due to providing no worth. If I bold SDM he stands zero chance because JV also bolded him, and everybody looks for an excuse to kill him. Honestly, in the last game, I was fully expecting to derail an SDM wagon because I hate grudge kills, but the whole seer/finding a wolf thing changed that. But I still feel kinda like I don't wanna wagon what I consider a grudge kill. However, I'm okay with it because he ain't doing shit this time
But in order to provide a choice, I'll lawyer fulksy because I think he's getting coached, and if he's not, he's not into it enough to provide value that the village needs in the late game, but I'm down with anybody on my list as I wanna get rid of all the low/weird content types
This comment looks a little too "coached up" for my tastes so although I generally don't favor lynching noobs I think I am ok with a lynch labour at the moment.Quote:
Originally Posted by LabourHater
I assure you i'm not being "coached", I just have a brain.
lawyer DropTheBanana
Quote:
Originally Posted by wufwugy
I'm sticking to my strategy from last game when I had the wolves soul owned with 4 remaining and I really don't give a shit if it looks weird or not. It's obviously effective. This time, I'll try be more verbal with my thoughts though.
For now my vote stays with SDM. Not because he's an easy target but because it's a win/win "lawyer" especially now that he's posting in interpretive lolcats.
Until a pattern emerges from other peoples posts, I see no reason to change and think it's sound judgement for everyone to jump on.
Soul reading on page 2 of a 19 man game seems lolretarded (No offense Onga :/)
None taken. I'm not soul reading, I'm just commentating my thoughts. No-one really thinks that I think I'm capable of soul reading the game on day 1 do they? I just like being active, I have a lot of time on my hands at the moment.
No-one stands out as an obvious lynch in terms of wolfiness, right now I've got TLR something like 2% more likely than anyone else.
Having said that, I don't like gator's posts so far, but then I realise it could just be paranoia after he coasted through last game. No way can we let him get to endgame again.
I think you misunderestimated my words.Quote:
Originally Posted by philly and the phanatics
I believe in you!Quote:
Originally Posted by OngBonga
This game feels like skin and bones, no meat to bite into. I don't really care about lynching anyone, but SDM is starting to show that he'll be playing a statement game of some sort and I can already tell it's going to be lame.
rescind philly
lynch SDM
Quote:
Originally Posted by OngBonga
sigh
Sticking with my vote for now, especially since it hasn't taken off too quickly.
rescind DTB
lawyer LabourHater
Total Votes:
Hoopy 1
Labour 3
OngBonga 1
Philly 1
SDM 3
TLR 2
Willbur 1
fulksy 1
I did not see much from labour, I agree with Gator that there is a decent chance that he is coached, usually noobs in thier first game are either all over the place or very low key, he is neither
lawyer labour
As Wuf mentioned Flomo and fulsky did not post anything that can be counted as content, Flomo played the low key strategy in the past when he was a wolf, so if they keep flying under the radar we should consider lawyering them relatively early, as the option of having them as villager who do not give a fuck at end game will not benefit us
Wuf, man, I don't even want to start a shit storm on Day 1 about how I'm not posting. There isn't a whole hell of a lot to go on, and I've been busy working whack ass shifts (rotating schedule from 1st-3rd shifts in the last two weeks, resulting in a jacked up sleep schedule. Not to mention I turned 21 in the last month which means I want to get out any night I can, PLUS the NFL Draft kicked off last night and I had to DVR it due to jacked worked schedule above and I've been catching up on mah Lions.
So gtfo with your Day 1 BS. You're looking way too inactivity less than 48 hours in. If we get to like, Day 3, and I'm still pulling this shit, by all means string me up/shoot me because I'm either A.) a dumbass wolf thats trying to play the same game 3x in a row, or B.) a villager that really doesn't give a shit.
Imma just Lawyer SDM since he sucks ass. I don't like killing vets early.
soudns like all the bull shit drivel you gave us last time roid .....mmmm???....ldo dont tihnk ur a wolf this time but dont act as if saying any of that shit absolves you in any way.
obv you didnt use the draft as an excuse last time but clearly the mclife was bought up
I mean, believe what you want obviously. I put it out there and you guys can discern whether it's the truth or not. I'm not here to post on command.
Also, no longer working the mcjob. Success!
Both of these wagons (SDM and Labour) are about the best we can muster right now imo. Happy to see either go through.
Wuf - fuck defending a guy who's essentially boycotting the game by only posting lolcats. As has been said, lynching him is win/win. I sure as hell don't want him around in the late or even middle game as a villager, and as a wolf, he wont be giving himself away if all he posts are lolcats.
I'm down stringing up sdm. lawyer sdm Fuck lolcats!
rescind Willbur
Lawyer SDM
They're obviously not our best lynches. Like wuf says, day 1 wagons are never wolves. I wouldn't know that for sure, but it makes sense and I have no reason to think wuf is wide of the mark.Quote:
Originally Posted by Carroters
Imo the most likely wolf candidate is someone trying to push through the easy lynches. Carrots here seems happy with either. I'm not happy to lynch them now, because neither are likely wolves. The wolves should never allow SDM to be thrown under the bus on day 1, he could actually be quite a good wolf due to him being such a bad villager, it wouldn't arouse suspicion if he wasn't getting nommed, with guidance I think SDM would be a dangerous wolf. Labour is a different matter, him being a noob means the wolves would gain some decent cover by getting rid of him, without sacrificing someone who could be useful to the wolves.
I don't see SDM being a wolf ever in this spot, the wolves would be much happier to push through Labour. I doubt very much I have the influence to successfully derail this wagon, but I'll try.
rescind TLR
lawyer carrots
Nothing personal, I just don't like his last post one bit.
I thought you weren't trying to soul read?Quote:
Originally Posted by OngBonga
This is why I've voted for you. If we have a spastic vomiting of words from you on Day 1, what are we going to have from you Day 6, when there is actual evidence to go on? I can't deal with that, whether from a wolf or a villager, it's excessive and inefficient and only serves to confuse.
Ong - If I'm a wolf and they're villagers, am I really going to feel the need to state something that level 0 and push wagons that are going fine when they're the only ones getting heat? I really think you need to think shit through a bit more.
Think labour is a slightly better lynch than SDM for now. Think he could defo be getting coached from the looks of his posts; I like the point about him being niether quiet nor all over the place and we can always give SDM a day to prove he's going to stop lol catting and contribute properly, although I'm doubtful that's going to happen.
Yup, i think we'd be wise to aim for OB or SDM. Both seem like they'd be swinging towards noise and away from signal.Quote:
Originally Posted by BennyLaRue
I prefer SDM over OB. I detest the bigspenda strategy of conveying the absolute minimum which looks like cat picks and lynches in this case. At least I can read OBs all over the place'd-ness unlike Keith's accusations of the past.
What you're saying here is that I shouldn't try and take info from day one posts, I should just happily string up a random because info on day one is lol.Quote:
Originally Posted by BennyLaRue
No, stringing up obvious villagers is lol. Are the wolves going to let SDM get strung up if he's a wolf? Not when there's another easy wagon. SDM isn't a wolf, I'd put my neck on the line for that. That's as much of a soul read as I've made. I've got one villager in my list.
I'm not fussed if you're trying to string me up. I'm just a regular villager, so I don't care if I die, but from the perspective of the rest of the village, I should be considered a better lynch than SDM. I'm more suspicious of those trying to lynch SDM than those trying to lynch me.
I also realise that you want me gone simply because I annoy you. From my point of view, I'm leaving silly little internet squabbles out of the game. So long as there's the slightest shred of evidence to go by, I won't be picking on cyberenemies out of spite. I suggest you put aside you're dislike for me and try to win the fucking game.
Sorry carrots, but your day 1 argument with Keith last game was pretty level 0. Forgive me if I don't respect you too much right now as a WW player.Quote:
Originally Posted by Carroters
But there is going to be nothing to go on with SDM's posts to tie him to anyone else later in the game.Quote:
Originally Posted by OngBonga
You can't be like "Oh he posted this lolcat when a villager would have OBVIOUSLY posted and loldog in this spot. Which is why either way we can't go wrong with getting rid of him.
Let's just do it before we have to waste a lynch when there's actual info to go on.
I'd like to think SDM isn't going to continue with his lolcat strategy, he must realise it's worse than just spazzing. If it continues then he's a real easy lynch or vig target later.
Forgive me here guys, I thought the point of the game was to string up wolves, not idiots.
Updated Votes
Hoopy 1
Labour 4
OngBonga 1
Philly 1
SDM 6
TLR 1
fulksy 1
Ong is right about SDM probably being a villager. But everyone is probably a villager. It'll be difficult to nip a wolf on day 1 so as we're likely going to be getting a villager, we should minimize the damage. lolcatsers are a detriment to the village so it's at least a good idea to nick off SDM.
carroters 1
So would be the hope, but thinking you'll bingo one based on parsing the words of day 1 posts is folly.Quote:
Originally Posted by OngBonga
It takes days to put together the pieces of the puzzle.
SDM is like the kid with down syndrome who keeps eating pieces to our puzzle instead of his zip lock bag of fig newtons. If we don't kill that kid, then our puzzle will never be complete.
Lets just get rid of him and try to salvage as many pieces as we can.
Probably, but it's not as folly as blindly going for the wagon that the wolves are likely pushing through. There is info on day 1, not a lot, but there's some. The info I have is that SDM is a villager. That is all. So anyone is a better lynch than SDM right now, it increases the chances of hitting a wolf by a small %.Quote:
Originally Posted by a500lbgorilla
Oops, my excel pivot table was filtered...i dont know wai?!?! Didn't have a fulksy vote either.Quote:
Originally Posted by OngBonga
Updated Votes
Hoopy 1
Labour 4
OngBonga 1
Philly 1
SDM 6
TLR 1
fulksy 1
carrots 1
Thanks for keeping me honest and questioning my genius...guy who totally won't get modkilled tonight.
I agree with you. I just don't really care to change my vote.Quote:
Originally Posted by OngBonga
That was me trying to balance what I do in every game of WW, argue with Keith!Quote:
Originally Posted by OngBonga
There's certainly nothing wrong with lynching SDM today since we're likely gonna have to lynch him for being a useless tard anyways and can save the more meaningful lynches or vig shots for that matter for when we have the info to make finding wolves way more likely. Losing one non participating villager on day 1 is hardly "losing the game" and that tiny % you speak of that makes it more likely we're finding a wolf by not lynching him is meaningless when a later informed lynch/shot is going to get wasted by having to kill him.
The wolves aren't going to eat him, and we sure as hell want him gone long before the end game, so the day when we have an effective shot in the dark is by far the best time to do it even if the likelyhood of him being a wolf is low.
How is sdm a likely villager based on his use lolcats? He stated pregame he'd be doing it, why would being a wolf cause him to deviate from this most annoying of plans?
Er, he's not a villager based on lolcats, he's a villager because his wagon on day 1 has taken off. When does a wolf wagon ever take off on day 1 without seer intervention?Quote:
Originally Posted by DanAronG
Don't think SDM is a wolf and sticking with Labour. Btw, I'd Labour is a wolf my so fear tells me there is a greater than 75% chance that rill a is one as well.
Above post I'd = if. Stupid iPad.
I just call mine, my Angry Birds machine. Didn't know it could do anything else :/
Being honest we've got no idea who the wolves are at this point or what they are doing. Day 1 is good to look back on around day 4 or so to look for patterns and incriminating posts. First few lynches are usually random so as long as we don't hit specials it's all good.Quote:
Originally Posted by OngBonga
Right now it's about choosing the guy who won't be a bad loss to the village, that guy is the one who's posting lolcats.
lol, feelingsQuote:
Originally Posted by OngBonga
Quote:
Originally Posted by GatorJH
http://img683.imageshack.us/img683/4156/quotescat.pngQuote:
Originally Posted by OngBonga
Quote:
Originally Posted by DropTheBanana
http://img535.imageshack.us/img535/558/lawyercat.pngQuote:
Originally Posted by Carroters
Sorry for the delay, My sleep pattern is crazy messed up atm. Being the new guy i have to admit that i am finding it difficult to gain any "reads" on anybody but based on Gators new found hard on for me i am tempted on changing my vote. But at this point if i get lynched then i win either way because you guys will see you made a mistake and that i am a villager + you'll see that i'm not being coached. :)
That's fine.Quote:
Originally Posted by a500lbgorilla
rescind OngBonga
lynch SDM
I hate to say it but I agree with this man. SDM and Labour are the easy lynches right now. Easy bandwagons and lynches are almost never wolves, let's face it.Quote:
Originally Posted by OngBonga
Honestly, this reeks of a Dranger wolf post. He's posted very similarly in previous games where he was, in fact, a wolf. Ironically enough, it usually involves beer and football. From the Santa Klaws game:Quote:
Originally Posted by Roid_Rage
I'm sure there are others but I'm in Pennsylvania right now and apparently they don't believe in high-speed internet. Anywho...Quote:
Originally Posted by Roid_Rage
Rescind Philly
Lawyer Roid_Rage
Also, SDM is almost confirmed non-wolf. You really think wolves would allow SDM to continue posting pictures with all the heat he's getting for his stupid lolcats? I say we lynch someone that givees us some goddamn information.
Why do people keep saying that and never offer up a suggestion and what that will in turn lead us to?
Such as: if xxyy is a wolf then yadda yadda but if he's not then blah blah blah
If you say you're lynching for information then you need ties to other people and if I learned anything from last game is that holding back information (as miniscule and stupid as you think it is) is detrimental to the village winning.
I think if someone suggests to lynch someone for information they should also provide what info that lynch will turn up and that's the best way to get group discussions going.
In shame I admit that last bunch of lolcats made me chuckle, so I'll rescind but not sure who to lynch then.
rescind SDM
Omfg! People are stupid.
SDM had only 6 votes, a total noob had 4 and we need 10 to lynch. He wasn't that close to death.
SDM stated he would be lolcatting for the game before the game started and therefore would be lolcatting regardless of role.
If SDM is a wolf and I was on his team, I would have told him to carry on with the lolcats as he is prob gonna get lynched soon anyway and at if he does at least his lolcats give no clues away. I would then have either I or another wolf throw out a post like boog did, which if bought by the village can have the effect of giving SDM near villager status and let him get away with nothing but lolcats right up to the endgame.
My point...... there is no fucking way that we can conclude that SDM's behavior makes him an unlikely wolf!!!!!!!!!! But it does make him a very dangerous wolf if he is one and a completely useless villager if he is on our side. Hence why I think he is the better lynch.
So if you wanna lnch someone else, fine. But don't throw out this "SDM is never a wolf" bollocks as it can potentially fuck the village over later on.
In fact I'm willing to lynch boog just for his post above.
I disagree that SDM can't be a wolf because of how he's posting. Anybody else and I would agree, but SDM is a special case and IMO would also be a special wolf. I would expect the wolves to use him in such a way that he gets a train ran on him, however I do not think they would do it on day one since nobody would remember that shit
If he's a wolf they wouldn't have a choice. Nobody was stopping the train starting, but derailing it was an option.
And wuf, the double negative makes reading that post like reading a Keith post.
I'm going to ignore BooG because fuck him, he's Mexican.
SDM is unlikely to be a wolf, but Dan makes a great point in the above post. BooG coming after me right now is kind of lol. Like I said before, as dumb as I am, even I'm unlikely to play the same way 3x as a wolf in a row, so this makes BooG stand out from the crowd to me.
But yea, back to SDM, like Dan says, if he was a wolf, why would he deviate? He's likely to be lynched early anyways and doing so provides little/no info. BooG throwing a distraction post in there is also suspect.
Lets finish off SDM, get what information we can from today, and start trying to puzzle stuff out tomorrow.
I'm going to work from 4pm-11pm(EST) and might be going to play pool/drink with my dad for the night. So thats why I might now post until tomorrow afternoon, so chill.
might not* post
Was also referring to post #132 from Dan, him and Wuf got in a few posts before I was done :P
I guess I'm just saying that I'm neutral. I think it's very likely that SDM is a villager, but I think it's still reasonable to kill him.Quote:
Originally Posted by DanAronG
Also rescined fulksy. Zero percent chance he's a wolf IMO. I would fully expect him to have posted at least once more if he was
Somebody gets lawyered tomorrow at 3pm EST. Right now its SDM with 6 votes
Okay it is guaranteed that SDM dies today, and if not today then tomorrow or next day. We should probably try to speed the game up since that's always a problem. It's hard to do so though because of a "wait for info" mentality. But since SDM is a defo die, let's get the votes up to ten and get on with it
lawyer SDM
Sorry homey, I quite enjoy playing with you, but you had to know it would go down like this
recind Hoopey, lawyer SDM
I can't be doing with this lolcat millarky.
in the vaks game his wagon took off and all the wolves were on it, given he was inactive and it was pretty obvious everyone was going to want to go for him, SDM is obnoxious and its pretty obvious everyone is going to want to go for him.Quote:
Originally Posted by OngBonga
im not trying to say SDM is a wolf, its day 1 i dont know shit lol. I am just saying "LOL HIS WAGONS TAKING OFF HE CANT BE A WOLF" is dumb imo
I'm the seer. GFG. Great game wolves, you did the right thing by taking me out first.
Oh and excellent work village with your "lolol let's hang people that post lolcats", right in the wolves hands. fuck.
rescind sdm
Lame shit, but could be a fake outing
http://youlookfiiine.files.wordpress...pg?w=356&h=400
if you really are the seer and you thought it would be smart to do the lolcat bit then you are seriously a moron.