Originally Posted by
a500lbgorilla
I've been reading 'Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance' based on some discussion in some thread I can't remember around here. Someone said that the Scientific Method was flawed in some way because there are an infinite number of hypothesis capable and not an infinite number of ways to test/verify them.
It is definitely a very thought-provoking book and it welcomes anyone who is up for the challenge but I have to say I have many, many issues with this book.
I think the author says it best when he talks about his alter-yesteryear-ego's experience reading philosophy where you accept the premise of what they're saying and then get frustrated that they simply go in the wrong direction.
I think the most striking aneurysm this book threw me was when his alter-yesteryear-ego Phadreus tries to define Quality. The build up to this question is pretty long and the author does well to build you into his frame of mind (though I think it's flawed severally in places along the way) but he tries to say "We have proved that quality, though undefined, exists. Its existence can be seen empirically in the classroom, and can be demonstrated logically by showing that a world without it cannot exist as we know it." Every point of this frustrates me to no end.
His proof is that he tells you about a class he demonstrated Quality to by telling them "You know what quality is, here's a shitty paper and an awesome paper, who can't tell the differences?" And claims that everyone knew. Of course they did, it's all fiction. Every character in the world of this book fits his philosophical waxing and wanning and it's irritating in the first degree.
He continues his proof by supposing a world without this undefined, but known, Quality and that he gets, in my opinion, strikingly incorrect.
Finally, he says that you can't define quality. It took me 1 page of reading about it and I defined it.
I'm held by a sort of Stockholm Syndrome to this book. I'm just trying to survive it before I can crack open Cat's Cradle.
It's definitely a read to get some blood-flow upstairs and if you find yourself agreeing with any large parts of it, I would love to figure out how that could be.