Now?Quote:
Originally Posted by Irisheyes
Printable View
Now?Quote:
Originally Posted by Irisheyes
See what I mean?
the difference is that the dog is a sentient animal whereas the bug is not.Quote:
Originally Posted by boostNslide
if you express remorse for the fact that you injured the bug, it is for your sake alone, since the bug cannot feel comfort from anything you do. some religions and cultures would be inclined to exhibit compassion towards this bug while others would not.
if you do not express remorse for the fact that you injured the dog, you are leaving another living being - one that is aware of its pain, agony and terror - alone to die a cruel and unusual death. there is more compassion in backing up over the dog to make sure it's dead than there is in simply driving away.
the least you could have done was call 911 to alert the agencies with the skill and authority to give the dog proper attention. doing nothing is the worst option.
link? bugs feel pain just like anything else, they're just too small and too numerous for us to care. Do you fish?Quote:
Originally Posted by alias2211
Quote:
Originally Posted by bigred
:heart: :heart: :heart:
Should we stop if we hit one of these bad boys?Quote:
Originally Posted by Greedo017
me and bigred were talking, we think its a penis with a penis, so i'm there
no i do not fish.Quote:
Originally Posted by Greedo017
let's get our semantics in line: 'pain' is the subjective mammalistic experience that happens as the result of instinctual neurological response to external stimulae. step on a george forman grill after breakfast in bed, and you'll tear your foot off the hot surface before you decide to commit that action in a self-aware manner. there are humans that have neurological disorders that rob them of this protective reaction, perhaps you have seen the people who can stick forks in their legs and stuff, but these same people are able to experience the terror of 'fear' in different situations, like being in a convenience store while it's being robbed.
invertebrae also experience these same natural responses to stimulae, but they are not 'aware' of it in the same way that mammals are. is this 'pain' in the same sense that mammals experience it? i don't think so, but it's almost impossible to prove.
http://www.enature.com/expert/expert...stionID=20796/
http://dels.nas.edu/ilar_n/ilarjourn...Question.shtml
We used to chase and kill rabbits when we were young. Does this make me a bad person?
how about shooting frogs with a BB gun?
How about popping the kittens necks because the damn cat had too many kittens again. +EV?
(Apparently my parents were too cheap to spring for a spaying)
how about taking the cat for a ride and dropping them off in an apartement complex somewhere? +EV?
ev+ for sureQuote:
Originally Posted by EricE
Hahahahaha. I never thought when I wrote that that somebody would think that my buddy was STILL 5.Quote:
Originally Posted by bigred
He's 20 now. He's one of my best buddies. When he was 5, he did this. His mom told everyone this story during dinner one time and I thought it was hilarious.
I'd turned sig's off, so I completely forgot about it. Hahaha.
Very negative expected morality...Quote:
Originally Posted by EricE
No, it makes you a dog. Stay off the roads at night.Quote:
Originally Posted by ItDepends
alias - bugs have nerve cords. I assume that nerve cords have the same function in humans as they have always had in every other creature. Just because a grasshopper doesn't duck and cover after I rip its leg off isn't sufficient to assume it isn't feeling pain. A large part of the human response to pain is learned - not instinctive, and I don't think we can generalize that our reaction is the only appropriate one, especially to a creature that might not even be intelligent enough to realize that when something rips its leg off it should protect its leg.
Your first link didn't work, your second one more explores the idea than anything else. In fact it says this in one place, "The well-being of invertebrates used for research is being taken increasingly seriously. Wigglesworth (1980), for example, has suggested that for practical purposes it should be assumed that insects feel pain and that they should, therefore, be narcotized in procedures that have the potential to cause pain".
Another example is that if you shock an animal it will demonstrate a memory. For example aplysia have basically a couple "limbs" sticking out. If you shock one it will pull it back in, and next time you touch it even without shock, it will jerk that "limb" back in extra hard clearly demonstrating memory. Why is it showing "fear" of the shock if it didn't find it unpleasant? Sure, none of this is conclusive, but its a lot more likely that I am right and a cricket getting its leg ripped off hurts it, than that it doesn't, just by common sense.
Illegal in the state I live in. If you hit a deer with an automobile you have to leave it there and are supposed to call the authorities. If you are caught picking up a dead deer from the side of the road you will be fined, if not worse.Quote:
Originally Posted by Bailey
yes, a part of our subjective experience of pain is learned. but the part that gets your leg off the damn grill is all old brain nerve instinct, free of charge, and still most efficient for reaction. and that is more like what the bug response is like. your new brain instead focuses on communicating to others that you need assistance, and formulates a plan of avoiding that situation altogether in the future.Quote:
Originally Posted by Greedo017
this is not a value judgement in favor of humans' awareness-added experience of pain, just clarifying the physiological response.
fixed, sorry and thank you.Quote:
Originally Posted by Greedo017
that assumption is not practical in nature, but ethical. it's more practical for scientists to be able to do anything they want with the test subjects. it's ethical for them to adapt their normal investigative process based on the belief that the insects do feel pain, even if there is no possible way to know for sure.Quote:
Originally Posted by Greedo017
only sentient animals can be afraid.Quote:
Originally Posted by Greedo017
this is not memory as we experience it, either, and another example of how non-sentient beings and sentient animals differ fundamentally. for the aplysia it's mapped stimulae, that's it. the aplysia is not going to therapy to work on his fear of death after this incident.
the purposeful abuse of insects should not be tolerated any more or less than it would be against any other being. you don't owe the insect an apology, because it doesn't have feelings to be hurt in the first place. if you want to have a moment of silence for it, that is fine, but it's not going to know one way or the other. so if that is important to you in the construct of your belief framework, then do it, but realize first that it's for your own benefit and not helpful to the bug in any meaningful way.
but back to the matter at hand, i would encourage you to stop and assist the animal next time you find yourself in a similar situation. and if you don't feel up to it (rabid dog concerns, large animal like a deer, etc.) that is reasonable. but then at least call the authorities who might be able to offer the animal medical attention or a less painful death. just be aware that there might be a family out there - human or otherwise - that relies on that animal as a member.
Quote:
Originally Posted by alias2211
sounds reasonable........................................ ........................................Quote:
Originally Posted by PO$$E$$ED
of course it is reasonable. i probably should've looped around and looked for it for a minute and if i saw it injured it probably would've meritted calling 911. i just doubt any of you would've done it if it was you.
cant own hand guns in chicago and a lot of suburbs around it, and you def cant carry it in your car :(Quote:
Originally Posted by flomo
this chicago must be in holland or some other fag countryQuote:
Originally Posted by boostNslide
come to america and enjoy the freedom of owning guns and shooting stuff
I would have definetely turned around. Maybe to run it over again if it was really messed up. Or hit it over the head with the softball bat in my trunk.Quote:
Originally Posted by Greedo017
Why would you call 911?? It is for life and death emergencies of people. You call them for a dog that has been hit you could be jeoprodizing a person's life. I think even Esign has to admit a person's life is more valuable than a dogs.
All Dogs Go To Heaven. Just remember that.
Quote:
Originally Posted by flomo
good bump
haha, nice Office reference.Quote:
step on a george forman grill after breakfast in bed, and you'll tear your foot off the hot surface before you decide to commit that action in a self-aware manner.
http://members.lycos.co.uk/utsc/bump.gif
This is one of my favorite threads, anything new?
I'm gonna run you over.
then u can call me SpeedBump333
lol
i just got a new dog the other day here is a picture of me and the little fella isn't he cute.
http://www.wingsandstrings.com/River...g_walking2.jpg
Jesus christ man, did you take an axe to his left leg or something before you put it out of it's misery for good?
So earlier I'm driving home and listening to WMMS on the radios (rock station, airs the browns football games). And inbetween songs, the voice on the radio says "here's a fun little fact, a cat will blink when struck with a hammer."
BTW I was going to put this awesomeness in my thread, but I figured I'd give you guys a treat.
Quote:
Originally Posted by bigred
wtf Im gona forever, and you still love me enough tgo post about me?!
And Im back. Not that anyone cares.
liesQuote:
Originally Posted by ProZachNation
why'd in god's name did you bump this.
I bumped the Open Letter to FTR post then about a min later I get pure pwnage pm from Xianti.
since this got bumped for some reason
http://img171.imageshack.us/img171/6...ckyvickhw0.png