Originally Posted by a500lbgorilla

What do we know about op?

What hand ranges can you put op on with preflop call?

I don't even know if I wanna waste my time with this hand since he's overbetting the pot and you don't know what cards can come that hurt you. Pushing is an option, since only a set can call.

-'rilla

Originally Posted by dsaxton

Just fold if you don't know anything about the player. If you're wrong, you lose a small pot, and if you're right you avoid losing a huge one.

I've noticed a lot of fish play often play big pairs like this. They make small raises preflop to try to "suck people in" and then put out ridiculous overbets when they flop their invincible overpair.

Originally Posted by Estrop

How does anyone call that reraise? Especially at 600NL. That's just crazy.

Originally Posted by spino1i

Pot odds. She was the 77-23 dog. However, she already had 100$ in the pot, and the pot stood at about 100$. If she goes all in she would have a 23% chance of making 634$, for this she would have to pay 171$

So if she calls:

23% of the time she makes 634$
77% of the time she loses 171$

If she folds:
100% of the time she's even

(This doesnt include the money she's already put in the pot.)

.23*634 + .77*(-171) = 145.82 - 131.67 = +14$ on average for making that decision.

So she actually had pot odds to call against an overpair (which is what I likely held from her point of view). And of course I could just be semi-bluffing, even though its unlikely.